Imagine you are a student at the University of Karachi. Your fees have gone up, the hostel has problems, and there is no elected body of students to take these issues to the administration. Meanwhile, a law passed by the provincial assembly says your university must hold student union elections — and it has said so for seven years. The law exists on paper. The elections have never happened.
On Thursday, 23 October 2026, the Sindh High Court decided it had heard enough about the delay. Justice Ali Haider summoned the Registrar of the University of Karachi to appear at the next hearing and explain why the Sindh Students Union Act 2019 has still not been implemented at the university. The court wanted to know why no student union polls have been held even though the legislation providing for them was enacted seven years ago. Proceedings were adjourned to the second week of November 2026, when the Registrar must personally answer the court's questions.
This article explains, in plain language, what happened at that hearing, what the petitioners are asking for, the long history of student unions in Pakistan, what the 2019 Act actually requires, the constitutional route the students have taken, and what this case means for students at every university and college in Sindh.
What Happened at the Hearing on 23 October 2026
According to a report published by the Pakistan Observer (via Scoop), the Sindh High Court took up a petition challenging the failure to hold student union elections at the University of Karachi despite the 2019 law. During the hearing, Justice Ali Haider directed the university's Registrar to appear before the court at the next hearing and explain why the law introduced in 2019 had not been implemented at the institution.
The court's questioning was pointed: if the legislature enacted a law providing for student union elections seven years ago, why had the university not held a single poll under it? The proceedings focused on the delay in implementing the law and on the university administration's responsibility to ensure compliance with its provisions. The Pakistan Observer report, also carried by GTV News, described the hearing as centred on the prolonged delay and the administration's duty to act under the law.
During the hearing, the court also sought information about who was behind the petition. In response, Advocate Usman Farooq, counsel for the petitioners, informed the bench that the petitioner was a law student. Counsel argued that student unions play an important role in promoting democratic values and developing leadership skills among young people, giving students a way to participate in democratic processes, express their views, and develop leadership abilities through representative activities.
The court then adjourned further proceedings until the second week of November 2026, with the Registrar required to clarify, at the next hearing, the reasons for the non-implementation of the law. It is important to understand what this step is — and what it is not. A summons to the Registrar to explain is an interim direction, not a final order and not a finding of guilt. The court is asking for an explanation first; what follows will depend on what the Registrar says.
The Petition: A Law Passed, Never Implemented
The hearing on 23 October was the latest step in a constitutional petition filed about a week earlier. As reported by ARY News (via Scoop) on 17 October 2026, students of the University of Karachi's School of Law filed a petition in the Sindh High Court seeking the revival of the student union at the institution. The petitioners — Ali Sher and others — named as respondents the Chief Secretary of Sindh, the Secretary of Universities and Boards, the Secretary of Colleges, the Law Secretary, and the Vice-Chancellor and Registrar of Karachi University.
Their case, as reported by The News in its report titled "SHC moved for holding student union elections at KU," is straightforward. The Sindh Students Union Act 2019 provides the legal framework for the establishment and functioning of student unions at educational institutions in the province. Yet, the petitioners say, almost nothing has been done to give it effect. The provincial government never framed or notified the Rules under the Act, and the University of Karachi never made the regulations it was required to make.
The legal centrepiece of their argument is Section 3(3) of the Act. Their counsel, Advocate Usman Farooq, told the court that this provision requires that, subject to the principles of the Act, each educational institution shall, within two months of the promulgation of the Act, formulate regulations and procedures for the conduct of a student union. The petitioners' case is that the two-month deadline expired years ago, and Karachi University still has no regulations, no procedure, no election commission, and no student union — "even after almost four years since the Act came into force," in counsel's words as reported by The News.
Crucially, the petitioners did not rush straight to court. Before approaching the High Court, they moved applications to the Universities and Boards Secretary, asking that the draft Rules be placed before the provincial cabinet and notified, and to the Vice-Chancellor of Karachi University, asking that regulations be framed under Section 3(3) and arrangements made for student union elections. Only after those representations went unanswered did they file the constitutional petition. This matters legally, because courts generally expect a citizen to knock on the authority's door before asking the court to intervene — and these students can show they did.
The relief they seek is practical: directions to the provincial authorities to complete the process of the Sindh Students Union Rules, constitute an election commission, and make all arrangements for holding student union elections at the University of Karachi.
A Brief History: From the 1984 Ban to the 2019 Act
To understand why this case matters, you need to know the history — because student unions in Pakistan have been banned, restored, and banned again over four decades.
The ban. In January 1984, the military regime of General Ziaul Haq imposed a nationwide ban on student unions. In Sindh, unions had in fact been banned even earlier, in 1979, a period when automatic weapons first surfaced on campuses in Karachi and Lahore, according to contemporaneous reporting. The ban shut down elected student representation across the country.
A brief restoration. During the first government of Benazir Bhutto in 1989, the ban was lifted. But the revival was short-lived: in 1993, the Supreme Court of Pakistan placed a blanket ban on political activities by students on campuses, and student unions once again disappeared from institutional life.
Sindh moves first. The bill that became the Sindh Students Union Act 2019 was introduced in 2019 and deliberated for about three years in the Standing Committee on Law, Parliamentary Affairs and Human Rights. In February 2022, the Sindh Assembly unanimously passed it — every party in the house, government and opposition alike, voted in favour — making Sindh the first province in Pakistan to restore student unions by law. The Chief Minister at the time called the passage historic, saying the revival of student unions would create a healthy and conducive environment in educational institutions.
What the Act provides. The law is detailed. Every educational institution in Sindh is to have a student union consisting of bona fide students of that institution, made up of 7 to 11 members elected by the students, with polls to be held every year. Each institution was required, within two months of the law's enactment, to formulate its own rules and procedures for the conduct of its student union. Every university or college must give the elected student union at least one nominee on its syndicate, senate, or board. Institutions must also constitute a gender-balanced committee for protection against harassment, with at least one nominee of the elected student union on it. And the union is defined as the bona fide representative body of the institution's students, with functions including working for the social and academic welfare of students, ensuring students' rights and interests are represented and protected, organising social, cultural, intellectual, and extra-curricular activities, and helping form students' personalities as responsible citizens.
The stall. Despite all of this — a unanimously passed law, a two-month deadline for institutional regulations, annual elections on paper — no student union elections have been held at the University of Karachi, and the provincial Rules under the Act were never framed or notified. That is the seven-year gap the High Court is now asking about.
What Is a Student Union, and Why Does the Court Care?
For readers who have never seen a student union in action — which, given the decades-long ban, includes most Pakistanis under forty — a plain explanation is in order.
A student union is an elected body of students within a university or college. Think of it as the students' own representative council. Its members are chosen by the students themselves through a vote, and its job is to speak for the student body before the university administration: on fee increases, hostel conditions, transport, examination schedules, library facilities, and academic grievances. Under the 2019 Act, it also has a formal seat at the table — a nominee on the university's syndicate, senate, or board, the bodies that actually make institutional decisions — and a role in the harassment protection committee.
Supporters of unions, including the petitioners' counsel in this case, argue that they are training grounds for democratic life: students learn to campaign, to debate, to represent others, and to accept electoral defeat — skills that transfer directly to citizenship. This is the "nursery of democracy" argument, and it is why the petitioners describe unions as important for promoting democratic values and developing leadership among young people.
Why does the court care? For a simple reason that has nothing to do with anyone's politics: a validly enacted law is being ignored. The Sindh Assembly passed the Act unanimously. It imposed duties with deadlines. Those duties were not performed. When a law exists and the authorities simply do not implement it, citizens can ask the High Court to direct the authorities to do their job. That is what this petition is about — not whether student unions are good or bad, but whether a law on the statute book must be obeyed.
The Law, Step by Step: What the Act Requires and Where It Stalled
One of the most useful things this case teaches is the difference between an Act, Rules, and regulations — three layers of lawmaking that must all work for a statute to come alive.
Step 1 — the Act. The legislature (here, the Sindh Assembly) passes the Act. This sets out the framework: there shall be student unions, they shall be elected, institutions shall make regulations within two months. The Act is the skeleton.
Step 2 — the Rules. The government (the executive) frames detailed Rules under the Act: the machinery of implementation — forms, timelines, the composition and powers of the election commission, the procedure for notifying elections. The petitioners asked the Universities and Boards Secretary to place the draft Rules before the provincial cabinet so they could be notified. This never happened. Without notified Rules, the machinery has no engine.
Step 3 — institutional regulations. Section 3(3) of the Act places a duty directly on each educational institution: within two months of the Act's promulgation, it must formulate its own regulations and procedures for the conduct of its student union. The University of Karachi, the petitioners say, never did this. This is the specific failure the High Court is now asking the Registrar to explain.
Step 4 — the election commission and the polls. Once Rules and regulations exist, the institution constitutes an election commission, announces a schedule, and holds the poll. None of this has occurred at Karachi University.
So the chain broke at steps 2 and 3: the government did not notify the Rules, and the university did not frame its regulations. The petition asks the court to restart the chain — direct the secretary to complete the Rules, and direct the university to constitute the election commission and hold elections.
The Constitutional Route: Article 199 and Articles 17, 19-A, and 25
The petitioners have approached the Sindh High Court through a constitutional petition under Article 199 of the Constitution. In plain language, Article 199 is the provision that lets any citizen ask a High Court to issue directions to a public authority — including an order directing an authority to do something the law requires it to do. When a government department or a public university ignores a statutory duty, Article 199 is the standard legal route to compel action. It is the same provision citizens use when, for example, an authority refuses to decide an application or enforce a regulation.
The petition also invokes three fundamental rights, and each is worth understanding in plain terms. An order sheet of the Sindh High Court in a related 2026 student-union petition (reported as 2026 SHC KHI 154 on the court's caselaw website) shows petitioners invoking Articles 17, 19-A, and 25 in exactly this context:
Article 17 — freedom of association. This article guarantees every citizen the right to form associations or unions. In plain language: the Constitution itself protects the right of people — including students — to organise collectively. A law like the 2019 Act does not create this right out of nothing; it gives it a statutory framework. The continued absence of any mechanism for student association, the petitioners argue, sits uneasily with this guarantee.
Article 19-A — the right to information. This article gives every citizen the right to access information in matters of public importance. For students, this connects to transparency: the status of the draft Rules, the reasons for the delay, and the university's plans for elections are all matters students are entitled to know about.
Article 25 — equality before law. This article guarantees that all citizens are equal before the law and entitled to equal protection of the law. The argument here is straightforward: the Act promises student representation to students across Sindh; students at Karachi University are being denied, in practice, a benefit the law extends to them — unequal treatment in the application of a valid law.
None of these arguments has been finally decided — the case is at an early stage, and the court has so far only asked for an explanation. But they show the legal shape of the petitioners' case: a statutory duty ignored, and fundamental rights engaged by that failure.
What a "Summons" Means — and What Happens Next
When the news says the High Court "summoned" the Registrar, it is natural to read drama into it. Legally, the step is more measured than it sounds.
A direction to a senior university officer to appear and explain is the court gathering information, not delivering a verdict. The Registrar will be expected to tell the court, factually, why the 2019 Act has not been implemented at the university: were regulations ever drafted? What happened to them? Did the university ever write to the government about the missing Rules? Is there any legal or practical obstacle, or was it simply never done?
What happens after the explanation depends on what the court hears. The realistic possibilities, in the ordinary course of such petitions, are these: the court may fix a time-bound schedule — directing the government to notify the Rules within a set period and the university to frame its regulations under Section 3(3) within a further period; it may direct the constitution of an election commission and the announcement of a poll schedule; it may call for comments from the respondents (the Chief Secretary, the secretaries, the Vice-Chancellor) before passing any direction; or, if the explanation reveals genuine legal complications, it may frame the questions that need fuller argument.
The next hearing is fixed for the second week of November 2026. Until then, nothing is decided. But the direction itself carries weight: it signals that the court treats seven years of non-implementation as something requiring a personal answer from the university's administration — not a routine adjournment, but a demand for accountability.
What This Means for Students at Other Universities and Colleges
The Sindh Students Union Act 2019 does not apply only to the University of Karachi. It covers educational institutions across the province — public and private universities and colleges alike. If the petitioners succeed, the precedent will matter far beyond one campus. Here is what students elsewhere can practically do:
1. Read the Act's promise as it applies to your institution. Your university or college was under the same Section 3(3) duty: regulations and procedures for a student union within two months of the Act's promulgation. Ask your administration, in writing, whether those regulations exist and where they are published.
2. Make a written representation first. Follow the petitioners' example: before thinking of courts, write to your Vice-Chancellor, principal, or director asking for the regulations to be framed and an election commission to be constituted. Send a copy to the relevant departmental secretary. Keep dated copies of everything — courts take notice when citizens can show they asked politely first.
3. Use the right to information. Under Article 19-A, ask for the status of the draft Sindh Students Union Rules and any correspondence between your institution and the government on the subject. Written answers create a record.
4. Act collectively and lawfully. Representations signed by a large number of bona fide students carry more weight than individual complaints, and they mirror the democratic character of what the Act promises. Keep all activity peaceful and within campus rules — the Act regulates unions; it does not license disruption.
5. The court is a last resort, not a first step. Article 199 petitions are powerful, but High Courts expect petitioners to have exhausted the available administrative remedies. The Karachi University petitioners' prior applications to the secretary and the Vice-Chancellor are precisely what made their petition maintainable. Build your paper trail before you brief a lawyer.
6. Watch the November hearing. Whatever the Registrar tells the court in the second week of November 2026 will shape the timeline for every institution in Sindh. If the court fixes deadlines for the Rules and the regulations, those deadlines will effectively apply province-wide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What exactly is the Sindh Students Union Act 2019?
It is a provincial law whose bill was introduced in 2019 and which was unanimously passed by the Sindh Assembly in February 2022, making Sindh the first province to restore student unions by statute. It provides for elected student unions of 7 to 11 members in every educational institution in Sindh, with elections every year, representation for the union on the institution's syndicate, senate, or board, a gender-balanced harassment protection committee including a union nominee, and a duty on each institution to frame its own election regulations within two months.
Q: If the law exists, why have there been no elections?
Because a law on paper needs two further layers to work: the government's Rules under the Act, and each institution's own regulations under Section 3(3). According to the petitioners, the provincial government never framed or notified the Rules, and the University of Karachi never formulated the regulations Section 3(3) required within two months. Without Rules and regulations, there is no election commission, no schedule, and no poll. The petition asks the High Court to direct the authorities to complete these missing steps.
Q: The Registrar has been "summoned" — does that mean the university has lost the case?
No. A direction to appear and explain is an interim step, not a final order. The court is asking the Registrar to account, factually, for why the 2019 Act has not been implemented at the university. No finding has been made against anyone, and no penalty has been imposed. What the court does next — whether it fixes deadlines, calls for comments from the other respondents, or issues directions — will depend on the explanation given at the hearing in the second week of November 2026.
Q: I study at a private college in Sindh. Does the Act apply to me?
Yes. The Act applies to educational institutions across the province, public and private. The Section 3(3) duty to frame regulations for student union elections was placed on each institution, not just on public universities. If your college has no union and no regulations, the same gap the petitioners complain of exists at your institution, and the same remedies — representation to the administration, and ultimately a constitutional petition — are in principle available to you.
Q: Can students go directly to the High Court, or must they approach the authorities first?
They should approach the authorities first. High Courts exercising jurisdiction under Article 199 generally expect petitioners to show they sought relief from the concerned authority before coming to court. The Karachi University petitioners did exactly this: they wrote to the Universities and Boards Secretary asking for the Rules to be placed before the cabinet and notified, and to the Vice-Chancellor asking for regulations and elections, before filing their petition. Anyone considering a similar petition should build the same paper trail — dated written representations and the authorities' responses, or their silence.
Q: When is the next hearing, and what should we expect?
The Sindh High Court adjourned the matter to the second week of November 2026, when the Registrar of the University of Karachi is required to appear and explain the non-implementation of the Act. Expect the court to question the Registrar on the missing regulations and the missing Rules, and possibly to call for comments from the government respondents. Any time-bound directions — for notifying the Rules, framing regulations, or constituting an election commission — would likely come after the court has heard these explanations.
The Bottom Line
Seven years after the legislation that was supposed to restore them, student union elections at the University of Karachi exist nowhere except on paper. A group of law students, after writing to the department and to their own Vice-Chancellor and getting no result, has asked the Sindh High Court to enforce the law. On 23 October 2026, Justice Ali Haider answered the first part of that request by summoning the university's Registrar to explain the delay in person at the next hearing, fixed for the second week of November 2026.
The deeper principle at stake is one every citizen should understand: a law that is never implemented is a promise the state has not kept. The Sindh Assembly passed the Students Union Act unanimously; Section 3(3) gave institutions two months to frame their election regulations; the government was to notify the Rules. None of it happened. Article 199 of the Constitution exists precisely for this situation — it allows citizens to ask the High Court to direct public authorities to perform the duties the law already imposes on them, with the fundamental rights of association, information, and equality standing behind the claim.
Whether the November hearing produces a timetable for Rules, regulations, and polls remains to be seen. But the case has already done something important: it has put the seven-year silence on the record, in open court, with the university's senior administration required to answer for it personally. Students across Sindh — at public universities, private colleges, and every institution the Act covers — will be watching what happens next, because the answer will belong to them too.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for your specific case.
