Pakistan now has two courts at the very top of its judicial system, and the Supreme Court has now said, in plain terms, that it is not subordinate to the other one. In a 13-page order authored by Chief Justice of Pakistan Yahya Afridi, a two-member bench of the Supreme Court — comprising the Chief Justice and Justice Shahid Bilal Hassan — ruled that the Supreme Court and the Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) are coordinate courts. That is a legal word worth understanding, because it decides which court an ordinary citizen, a business, or a government department must approach, and what happens when a case touches both constitutional questions and ordinary disputes at the same time.

The ruling arose from a set of petitions connected to a consolidated judgment of the Peshawar High Court dated 17 February 2020. The Supreme Court was dealing with a writ petition, a civil revision and a contempt application that had been clubbed together — that is, heard together because they shared common questions. In deciding how those proceedings should now be routed, the Court had to answer a much bigger question: after the 27th Amendment to the Constitution, is the Supreme Court now below the Federal Constitutional Court, or do the two courts stand side by side?

The Supreme Court's answer was unambiguous. The constitutional scheme after the 27th Amendment, the order said, does not place either court above the other, and neither court is an appellate forum — a court of appeal — for the other. Each court has its own exclusive domain, and each decides the cases assigned to it independently. This article explains, in plain language, what changed, what "co-equal" really means, which court hears which kind of case, and what remains unsettled.

What the 27th Amendment Changed

Before the 27th Amendment, Pakistan had one apex court: the Supreme Court of Pakistan. It heard constitutional cases, including petitions about fundamental rights and disputes between the federation and the provinces, and it also heard ordinary appeals in civil and criminal cases from the high courts. The 27th Amendment, passed by Parliament in November 2025, changed that structure fundamentally. It created a new court, the Federal Constitutional Court, and transferred to it the constitutional jurisdiction that the Supreme Court used to exercise.

Under the new arrangement, the FCC hears matters of a constitutional nature. That includes disputes between the federal government and the provincial governments, public interest matters, and cases about the enforcement of fundamental rights. The power to take suo motu notice — to take up a matter on the court's own initiative — on constitutional questions also moved to the FCC. The Supreme Court, meanwhile, retained its role as the country's highest court of appeal in ordinary civil, criminal and other non-constitutional cases.

This is why many commentators described the FCC as a parallel judicial body, and why some argued that the amendment effectively stripped the Supreme Court of its constitutional jurisdiction and left it only as a court of appeal. Others saw it differently: as a division of labour at the top, with each court specialising in its own field. The Supreme Court's new order comes down firmly on the second reading.

What "Co-equal" and "Coordinate" Mean

In everyday language, people often assume that if there are two courts at the top, one must be senior to the other. The Supreme Court has rejected that assumption. "Coordinate" means the two courts sit on the same level, side by side, like two departments of equal rank rather than a boss and a subordinate. Neither court can hear an appeal against the other's decision. Neither court can give orders to the other about how to decide a case within its own domain.

This matters because of a simple but powerful idea: jurisdiction. Jurisdiction means the legal authority of a court to hear a particular kind of case. When the Constitution assigns a category of cases exclusively to one court, only that court can decide them. The Supreme Court's order says the post-27th Amendment framework assigns "exclusive competence over different categories of proceedings" to the two courts, rather than establishing a "vertical hierarchy". In other words, the Constitution divided the work, it did not create a ladder.

For an ordinary person, the practical meaning is this: the Supreme Court has not become a lower court. It remains the final court of appeal for the cases that belong to it, and its decisions in those cases are final. At the same time, it cannot overrule the FCC in constitutional matters, because those matters no longer belong to it. The two courts are equals in status, but they work in different rooms.

Article 175F and Article 189(1) in Plain Words

Two constitutional provisions sit at the heart of this debate, and it helps to understand each of them separately.

Article 175F is the provision that divides the work. Read together, clauses (1) and (2) of Article 175F give the FCC jurisdiction over constitutional matters, including appeals from judgments or orders of a high court in such matters. The Supreme Court's order notes that Article 175F "expressly affords" this jurisdiction to the FCC. All matters falling within the FCC's appellate jurisdiction stand transferred to the FCC, which has the exclusive jurisdiction to hear and decide them.

Article 185, by contrast, defines the Supreme Court's appellate jurisdiction. It says that, subject to Article 175F, the Supreme Court hears appeals from judgments, decrees, final orders or sentences of a high court. The Chief Justice explained that Article 185 therefore governs appeals in cases which do not fall within Article 175F. The two articles fit together like two halves of a map: Article 175F marks out the FCC's territory, and Article 185 marks out what remains for the Supreme Court.

Article 189(1) is the provision that caused the most argument. As amended by the 27th Amendment, it says: "Any decision of the Federal Constitutional Court shall, to the extent that it decides a question of law or is based upon or enunciates a principle of law, be binding on all other courts in Pakistan, including the Supreme Court." Read on its own, that sentence sounds as though the FCC sits above every other court, including the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court's order says that is the wrong way to read it.

The order insists that Article 189(1) "must deliberately be read in conjunction with the overall post-27th Amendment framework, which intentionally arranges jurisdiction between the Supreme Court and the FCC across distinct domains". The binding effect of an FCC decision, the Court said, is limited to questions of law — the legal principles the FCC lays down — and does not extend to the outcome reached in any particular case by the FCC. Article 189 ensures consistency in legal principles across the country, the Chief Justice noted, but it does not subordinate one court to the other. As the order put it: "Any broader construction of Article 189(1) would have the effect of subordinating one apex court to the other in respect of proceedings constitutionally assigned to fall under its jurisdiction — a result for which there is no warrant in the constitutional text."

Think of it this way. If the FCC decides a question of law — for example, how a particular constitutional provision should be interpreted — other courts, including the Supreme Court, must follow that legal principle when the same question arises before them. That is what "binding" means. But that does not make the Supreme Court subordinate in its own domain, any more than a specialist's opinion on one subject makes a general practitioner subordinate on every other subject. The binding force attaches to the principle of law, not to a chain of command.

Which Court Hears Your Case

The order gives a remarkably clear rule of thumb, and it is worth quoting because it is the most useful sentence in the whole judgment for a litigant: "all writ proceedings, except those relating to rent and family matters, are within the jurisdiction of the FCC, whereas all regular proceedings are within the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court."

A writ petition is a special kind of case. When a citizen believes a government authority has acted illegally, or that a fundamental right has been violated, the usual remedy is to file a writ petition before a high court under Article 199 of the Constitution. Under the new scheme, appeals in writ proceedings — except writs about rent and family matters — go to the FCC. Regular proceedings, on the other hand, are the ordinary civil and criminal cases: a dispute over property, a contract claim, a criminal appeal, a service matter that proceeds as an ordinary suit or appeal. Appeals in those cases go to the Supreme Court.

The order also explains what happens to cases that are already pending. All matters falling within the FCC's appellate jurisdiction stand transferred to the FCC. All regular proceedings are to be heard and decided by the Supreme Court itself. So if you have a case pending before the Supreme Court that is really a writ matter within the FCC's domain, it does not stay where it is — it moves. And if your case is a regular appeal, it stays with the Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court decides it.

There is one notable exception to remember. Writ proceedings relating to rent and family matters do not go to the FCC. They remain within the Supreme Court's appellate jurisdiction. This is a detail that can easily trip up a litigant, because a rent or family dispute may look like an ordinary constitutional writ at first glance. If your case involves rent control or a family dispute that reached the high court as a writ, the appeal route is to the Supreme Court, not the FCC.

What Happens When a Case Mixes Both Kinds of Questions

Real life rarely sorts itself neatly into boxes, and the Supreme Court's order deals directly with that problem. Before the 27th Amendment, the Court recalled, matters were routinely clubbed together where they had proceeded in parallel or involved common questions of law. A single dispute might produce both a writ petition and a regular civil proceeding, and the courts would hear them together for convenience.

Under the new framework, that convenience is no longer possible. Any writ and regular proceedings that have been clubbed together must now be de-clubbed — separated — so that each category of cases can be routed to its proper forum. The writ part goes to the FCC, and the regular part stays with the Supreme Court. Your case may therefore split into two cases, in two different courts, even though it began as one dispute.

The judgment is honest about the risk this creates. Routing such cases to their respective forums, the Court said, "may give rise to a potential complication: both writ-proceedings and regular-proceedings may entail adjudication of the same question of law before the FCC and the Supreme Court, respectively, thereby increasing the possibility of contradictory decisions." In plain terms, the two courts could look at the same legal question from their own sides of the fence and reach different answers. That is the price of a divided apex, and it is a problem the system will have to manage as cases move through it.

The contempt proceedings in the case before the Court illustrate how the routing works in practice. Contempt of court means disobeying or disrespecting a court's order, and a contempt application can arise out of almost any kind of case. The Supreme Court decided that since the matter before it emanated from regular proceedings, the contempt proceedings would be heard by it, rather than being transferred to the FCC. The lesson is that a side proceeding follows the main proceeding it grew out of. If the underlying case is a regular proceeding, its contempt goes to the Supreme Court. If the underlying case were a writ proceeding within the FCC's domain, the logic of the order suggests the contempt would follow the writ to the FCC.

The Other Side: What the FCC Had Said Earlier

A fair account must present the other court's position too, because this ruling did not arrive in a vacuum. Earlier judgments of the FCC had asserted that its decisions are binding on all courts, including the Supreme Court, and that it holds ultimate authority in constitutional interpretation. According to a senior lawyer quoted in press coverage of the Supreme Court's order, the new order appears to be an answer to the FCC's judgment of 18 December 2025, in which the FCC had held that after the 27th Amendment, an exception has been created requiring all courts, including the Supreme Court, to adhere to its judgments.

The FCC's reading has a straightforward logic of its own. Article 189(1) says, in terms, that FCC decisions on questions of law are binding on all other courts "including the Supreme Court". If the Constitution names the Supreme Court expressly, the FCC's supporters argue, then the binding effect must be real and comprehensive, and the FCC is, at least in constitutional matters, the highest authority in the land. On this view, calling the courts "co-equal" risks watering down a deliberate constitutional choice to make the FCC's word final on the Constitution.

The Supreme Court's answer is that binding effect and subordination are two different things. A court's decision on a question of law can bind other courts without making those courts subordinate in their own jurisdiction — just as, in the old system, Supreme Court decisions bound the high courts without making the high courts mere branches of the Supreme Court. The Chief Justice's point is that Article 189(1) secures uniformity of law, while Article 175F and Article 185 secure the division of jurisdiction, and both ideas can live together only if neither court is treated as the other's superior.

It is important to be clear about the status of this debate. The Supreme Court has now stated its position in a reasoned order. The FCC has not, so far as public reporting shows, issued a fresh ruling accepting or rejecting that position. The two courts' readings of Article 189(1) therefore remain in tension, and the practical settlement of that tension will emerge case by case, as litigants raise the question and the courts respond. This article does not predict which reading will ultimately prevail; it reports what each court has said so far.

What This Means for an Ordinary Litigant

For most people, the ruling changes the address on the envelope, not the merits of their case. If you are filing an appeal, the first question your lawyer must now answer is not "how strong is my case" but "which apex court does this case belong to". Getting that question wrong can cost months, because a case filed in the wrong court may have to be transferred, and limitation periods — the deadlines for filing — do not always wait for a transfer.

If your dispute is an ordinary civil or criminal matter — a property appeal, a contract dispute, a criminal conviction you want overturned, a service case that proceeded as a regular appeal — your appellate forum is the Supreme Court. If your dispute is a constitutional matter that reached the high court as a writ petition — a challenge to government action, a fundamental rights claim, a dispute between governments — your appellate forum is the FCC, unless the writ concerns rent or family matters, in which case it is the Supreme Court.

If your dispute has produced both kinds of proceedings, expect them to be separated. Do not assume that because one part of your case is before the Supreme Court, the other part will be heard there too. Ask your lawyer, at the very start, to map each proceeding in your dispute to its proper forum, and to check whether any part of it is liable to be transferred to the FCC. If a part of your case is transferred, follow it: a transferred case does not disappear, but it will proceed under a different court's cause list, with different dates and possibly different procedural requirements.

Finally, do not read the headlines as saying that the Supreme Court has been weakened or that the FCC has been defeated. What the Supreme Court has said is narrower and more technical: the Constitution created two courts of equal rank with different jobs, and each must be allowed to do its own job. For a litigant, the safest course is to treat both courts with equal seriousness, to file in the right one, and to keep a close eye on transfer orders if your case straddles the line.

What Remains Unsettled

Several important questions are still open. The first is the risk of contradictory decisions on the same question of law, which the Supreme Court itself flagged. When a writ proceeding before the FCC and a regular proceeding before the Supreme Court both turn on the same legal question, there is no superior court above them to reconcile the two answers. The Constitution provides no tie-breaker between two coordinate courts, and how such a conflict would be resolved is not yet clear.

The second is the boundary itself. The rule that "all writ proceedings except rent and family" go to the FCC sounds crisp, but many real cases sit on the borderline. A service dispute, a tax challenge, or a regulatory matter may begin as a writ petition but raise questions that look like ordinary civil law. Classification disputes — arguments about which court a case belongs to — are likely to become a routine feature of appellate practice, at least until a body of precedent builds up around the boundary.

The third is the continuing tension over Article 189(1). The Supreme Court has now read the provision narrowly, confining its binding effect to questions of law. Whether the FCC accepts that reading, or reasserts a broader one in a future judgment, remains to be seen. Until both courts speak with one voice on the scope of Article 189(1), lawyers will have to advise clients that the law on this point is settled by the Supreme Court's order but not yet confirmed by the FCC.

The fourth is practical: the transfer of pending cases. Thousands of matters were pending before the Supreme Court when the FCC was created, and the process of identifying which of them fall within the FCC's jurisdiction, and physically moving their records, is an administrative task of considerable size. Litigants with pending cases should check the cause lists of both courts rather than assuming their case remains where it was filed.

None of this means the system is broken. Every major constitutional change produces a period of adjustment while courts, lawyers and litigants learn the new map. What the Supreme Court's order does is draw that map more clearly than it had been drawn before: two apex courts, equal in rank, distinct in jurisdiction, bound together only by the shared duty to follow each other's settled principles of law. The coming months will show how well that map works in practice.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the Supreme Court ignore an FCC ruling?
No, not where the FCC has decided a question of law. Under Article 189(1), an FCC decision on a question of law, or based on or enunciating a principle of law, is binding on all other courts in Pakistan, including the Supreme Court. What the Supreme Court has said is that this binding effect covers the legal principle, not the outcome of a particular FCC case, and it does not make the Supreme Court subordinate in cases that belong to its own jurisdiction. So the Supreme Court must follow the FCC's settled principles of law, but it decides its own cases itself.

Is the Federal Constitutional Court now the highest court in Pakistan?
Not in the sense of sitting above the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court's order describes the two courts as coordinate and co-equal, exercising clearly demarcated jurisdictions. The FCC is the highest — indeed the only — apex authority in constitutional matters within its domain, and the Supreme Court is the highest appellate authority in regular civil, criminal and other non-constitutional matters within its domain. There is no single court above both of them.

Can I appeal from the Supreme Court to the FCC, or from the FCC to the Supreme Court?
No. The order states expressly that the constitutional scheme does not position either court as an appellate forum for the other. Appeals from a high court go to one apex court or the other depending on the nature of the case, but there is no appeal from one apex court to the other. If you believe the wrong court decided your case, the remedy is to raise the jurisdictional question before the court concerned, not to appeal to its coordinate court.

I have a writ petition pending before a high court. Where will my appeal go?
In most cases, to the Federal Constitutional Court, because writ proceedings fall within the FCC's jurisdiction under Article 175F. The exception is writ proceedings relating to rent and family matters, which remain within the Supreme Court's appellate jurisdiction under Article 185. Your lawyer should confirm which category your writ falls into before the appeal is filed, because filing in the wrong court can cause delay.

What happens if my case has both a writ petition and a regular appeal?
The two proceedings will be de-clubbed — separated — and each will go to its proper forum. The writ part goes to the FCC and the regular part stays with the Supreme Court. This may mean pursuing two cases in two courts at the same time, with separate dates and possibly separate lawyers' preparations. You should ask your counsel to track both proceedings and to watch for the risk, noted by the Supreme Court itself, that the two courts could decide the same question of law differently.

Does this ruling affect cases that have already been decided?
The order deals with the routing of pending and future proceedings; it transfers matters within the FCC's jurisdiction to the FCC and confirms that regular proceedings remain with the Supreme Court. It does not reopen decided cases. If your case has already been finally decided by a competent court, this ruling does not by itself give you a fresh appeal. If your case is still pending, however, you should check whether it is liable to be transferred.

What should I do if I am not sure which court my case belongs to?
Ask your advocate to classify the proceedings before filing anything. The classification turns on whether the matter is a writ proceeding within Article 175F or a regular proceeding within Article 185, and on whether any rent or family exception applies. Filing in the wrong forum wastes time and can create limitation problems, so this is a question to settle at the outset, not after the appeal is lodged.

The Bottom Line

The Supreme Court's order is best understood as a map, not a verdict in a contest between two courts. Pakistan's Constitution, after the 27th Amendment, has two apex courts instead of one. The Federal Constitutional Court owns constitutional matters: writ proceedings, disputes between governments, fundamental rights, and the constitutional questions that used to go to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court owns everything else at the appellate level: regular civil and criminal appeals, and writs about rent and family matters. Article 189(1) makes the FCC's principles of law binding on all courts, including the Supreme Court, but the Supreme Court has now held that this binding force does not create a hierarchy. The courts are coordinate, equal in rank, and each supreme within its own domain.

For the ordinary litigant, the message is practical rather than dramatic. Find out which court your case belongs to, file there, and if your dispute has produced both kinds of proceedings, expect them to travel separately. Keep an eye on transfer orders if your case was already pending, and do not assume that a headline about one court "winning" over the other changes the merits of your own case. The law on the boundary between the two courts is still being worked out, and the possibility of conflicting decisions on shared questions of law is a real, acknowledged risk. But the basic structure is now clearer than it was: two courts at the top, neither above the other, each doing the job the Constitution assigned to it. That clarity, even with its rough edges, is something every litigant in Pakistan can use.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for your specific case.