Imagine this: a woman goes to a well-known hospital in Islamabad for the birth of her twin daughters. The delivery is done by operation. After the operation she develops back pain, her condition gets worse, and she dies. Her husband is convinced the doctors did something wrong. He says he asked for one kind of anaesthesia and the doctors used another. He files a criminal case against the doctors, saying their negligence killed his wife.

The case travelled through the courts for years. The trial court acquitted the doctors. The Islamabad High Court agreed with the acquittal. The husband went to the Supreme Court. On 6 October 2026, the Supreme Court refused to interfere and the acquittals stayed.

The case is Amjad Ali v Dr Taqdees Naqaish and others (Criminal Petition for Leave to Appeal No. 955 of 2020). A two-member bench of Justice Muhammad Hashim Khan Kakkar and Justice Ishtiaq Ibrahim decided it, and Justice Ishtiaq Ibrahim wrote the judgment. The ruling matters to every family that has lost someone in a hospital, and to every doctor in Pakistan, because it draws a clear line: a patient's death, even a tragic and painful one, does not by itself prove that a doctor committed a crime.

This article explains, in plain language, what the Supreme Court decided, what "gross negligence" means, and what patients and doctors should do after this ruling.

What Happened in This Case

Amjad Ali's wife was taken to Shifa Hospital in Islamabad with labour pain. She gave birth to twin daughters after an operation. Amjad Ali's complaint was that the doctors gave his wife spinal anaesthesia even though he had asked for an epidural. He said that after the operation his wife suffered back pain, her condition deteriorated, and she died because of the treatment she received.

The legal journey of the case was long. An FIR about the same allegations had first been registered, but after investigation it was cancelled. Amjad Ali then filed a private complaint on 16 December 2016, under Sections 319, 322 and 34 of the Pakistan Penal Code. Section 319 punishes Qatl-i-Khata, which means causing death by a rash or negligent act without the intention to kill. Section 322 deals with Qatl-bis-Sabab, causing death by an act that is not intended to cause death but is unlawful. Section 34 covers acts done by several persons in furtherance of a common intention.

The Judicial Magistrate, Section 30, Islamabad-West, acquitted the doctors on 25 October 2017 under Section 249-A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which allows a magistrate to acquit an accused person when the charge appears groundless and there is no probability of conviction. The Islamabad High Court upheld that acquittal on 16 July 2020 in Criminal Appeal No. 193 of 2017.

Amjad Ali then asked the Supreme Court for leave to appeal. His argument was that the acquittal had been premature, and that the material before the courts did disclose criminal negligence. The question before the Supreme Court was a narrow one: did the record show the kind of negligence that the criminal law punishes? The Court answered no, and dismissed the petition.

A Poor Outcome Is Not the Legal Test

The Supreme Court began with the ordinary building blocks of negligence. Three things must be shown: the person owed a duty of care, the person breached that duty, and the breach caused the harm. In a medical case, the duty is the duty a doctor owes to a patient. The breach is a failure to treat the patient with the care that the law requires. And the harm must be connected to that failure — the patient must have died because of the lapse, not merely after it.

The Court stressed that showing treatment was followed by a death does not, without the necessary evidence, establish that the treatment unlawfully caused it. A patient can die even when the doctors did everything right. Medicine involves risk, and a bad outcome is not the same thing as a wrong act.

For doctors, the Court applied the standard of reasonable competence in the relevant field. This is known as the Bolam approach, named after a famous English case. A doctor is judged against an ordinarily competent practitioner exercising the relevant professional skill. The law does not demand the skill of the most experienced specialist in every case. It asks whether the doctor acted in the way a reasonably competent doctor in the same field would have acted at the time.

Nor does the fact that a different treatment was available automatically prove negligence. The question is whether the treatment actually given was accepted medical practice and whether it met the care reasonably required at the time. Looking back afterwards, it may be easy to say that another precaution could have prevented the harm. But hindsight alone does not prove that the doctor fell below the required standard.

This does not remove accountability. The judgment recognises that negligence exists where the necessary skill is absent, or where a skill the doctor has is not exercised with reasonable competence. What the Court insists on is that the allegation must be tested against the actual treatment and the actual circumstances, not against the sadness of the outcome.

Why Criminal Liability Requires More

The most important part of the judgment is the difference between civil negligence and criminal negligence. Conduct that may support a civil claim for compensation does not necessarily amount to a criminal offence. For criminal responsibility, the departure from the required standard must be gross or reckless — serious enough to justify punishment.

The Court said the judge must look at the nature of the duty, the surrounding circumstances, the precautions reasonably required, and the seriousness of the departure. The risk must have been sufficiently foreseeable, and the conduct must show a grave disregard for the patient's safety. An ordinary lapse in care cannot become a criminal offence simply because the eventual injury was severe.

For a death during treatment under Section 319 of the Pakistan Penal Code, the prosecution must prove three things:

  • The medical professional owed a duty of care to the patient.
  • A breach of that duty caused the death.
  • The breach amounted to gross negligence.

The causal requirement and the seriousness of the breach must both be established. Proof of death cannot stand in for proof of either. In other words, the prosecution cannot point at the death and ask the court to assume the rest. It must prove, with reliable and legally admissible evidence, what exactly the doctor did wrong, how that caused the death, and why the failure was so serious that it deserves criminal punishment.

This is a high bar, and the Court set it deliberately. Criminal punishment — imprisonment, a criminal record, the loss of a career — is the harshest response the law has. The Court's view is that it should be reserved for conduct that is truly blameworthy, not for every medical tragedy.

Why the Evidence Did Not Meet That Standard

On the facts of this case, the Supreme Court found that the evidence did not meet the standard. The Court recorded that the post-operative complications had been managed under standard medical protocols. It also noted that an initial regulatory censure against the doctors had later been withdrawn after a finding of no medical negligence. These were part of the record against which the Court assessed the criminal complaint.

The complainant had not identified a specific illegal act, or a specific instance of gross professional indifference, attributable to the doctors that could establish the criminal offence alleged. The disagreement about spinal anaesthesia instead of epidural anaesthesia did not fill that gap. A treatment choice followed by an unfortunate result was not enough without reliable evidence of criminally culpable treatment and its connection with the death.

The Court was careful to say what it was not deciding. It did not announce that spinal anaesthesia is always appropriate, and it did not decide the clinical merits of that technique for every patient. Its conclusion concerned only the failure to establish the offence alleged in this particular case, on this particular record.

The Court also found that the trial court and the High Court had given convincing reasons for the acquittals under Section 249-A CrPC. No misreading or non-reading of the evidence, no perversity and no illegality had been shown that called for interference. The petition was dismissed and leave to appeal was refused.

Consent: Relevant, But Not a Free Pass

The judgment also dealt with Section 88 of the Pakistan Penal Code, which protects acts done with the relevant consent, in good faith, and for a person's benefit, without an intention to cause death. Its surgical illustration recognises that a known risk may materialise even though the operation was undertaken for the patient's benefit.

The Court expressly rejected treating that protection as absolute. A consent form does not settle the criminal inquiry. Benefit, good faith, the absence of an intention to cause death and the requisite consent must all coexist, and the court must examine whether the act falls within the provision and whether the evidence establishes criminal culpability.

In this case, the Court recorded that the complainant's consent had been obtained before the operation. The procedure was undertaken for the patient's medical benefit, and the record did not establish bad faith, an intention to cause death, or other circumstances taking the doctors outside Section 88's protection.

So the ruling preserves two separate questions. The first is whether there was the required consent. The second is whether the treatment was performed within the statutory protection. Consent does not answer the second question automatically. A doctor who relies on consent must still meet all of Section 88's conditions, and a doctor whose treatment is criminally culpable cannot hide behind a signature on a form.

What This Means for Patients and Families

If you have lost a loved one during treatment, this ruling may feel harsh. It is important to understand what it does and does not do.

First, it does not say doctors can never be punished. A doctor who is grossly negligent — who acts with grave disregard for a patient's safety, who ignores obvious risks, who performs a procedure without the basic skill or care the situation demands — can still face criminal charges under Sections 318 and 319 of the Pakistan Penal Code. The ruling only says that the prosecution must prove that level of fault with real evidence.

Second, it does not close the civil route. A family that cannot prove criminal negligence may still have a civil claim for compensation. The standard in a civil case is lower: the family must show that the doctor fell below the standard of a reasonably competent practitioner and that this caused the loss. Many medical negligence claims in Pakistan are fought as civil suits for damages, not as criminal cases, and this ruling does not change that.

Third, it does not close the regulatory route. Families can complain to the Pakistan Medical and Dental Council (PMDC) and to the hospital's own complaints system, and they can approach the Healthcare Commission in their province. A doctor can face professional discipline — including suspension or cancellation of a licence — even when the conduct does not amount to a crime.

What the ruling does change is the advice a lawyer should give at the start. Before filing a criminal complaint, a family should ask: what exactly did the doctor do wrong, and can we prove it? A medical opinion from an independent expert, the complete treatment record, and evidence connecting a specific lapse to the death are essential. A complaint that only says "my loved one died in the hospital" will not survive. The FIR route is also not the first step: in this very case, the first FIR was cancelled after investigation, and the criminal case only proceeded as a private complaint.

Families should also keep every document from the start: admission papers, consent forms, prescriptions, test reports, discharge summaries, bills and receipts. They should note the names of the doctors and staff involved, and write down what happened and when, while memories are fresh. If a post-mortem is an option, the family should consider it carefully, because without it the cause of death can become a matter of dispute.

What This Means for Doctors and Hospitals

For doctors, the ruling is reassuring but not a licence to be careless. The Supreme Court has confirmed that a doctor is judged against the standard of an ordinarily competent practitioner, not against perfection, and that a bad outcome alone is not a crime. But the protection depends on the doctor actually meeting that standard: taking a proper history, following accepted protocols, recording what was done and why, and obtaining proper informed consent.

Consent deserves special attention after this judgment. The Court treated consent as relevant but not decisive. A consent form signed in a hurry, without explaining the risks, is weak protection. Doctors should explain the procedure, its risks and its alternatives in words the patient and family understand, and record that explanation. Where a patient or family asks for a different treatment — as Amjad Ali asked for an epidural rather than spinal anaesthesia — the doctor should record the request, the advice given, and the reasons for the final decision.

Hospitals should make sure their protocols are written, followed and documented. In this case, the fact that post-operative complications were managed under standard protocols was part of the record that protected the doctors. Good record-keeping is not paperwork for its own sake: it is the evidence that a court will read years later.

Doctors should also remember that this ruling concerns criminal liability. A civil claim and a PMDC complaint operate on different standards, and a doctor can lose a civil case even when no crime is proved. Professional indemnity insurance, careful documentation and honest communication with patients remain essential.

The Difference Between Civil and Criminal Medical Negligence

Many people use the words "medical negligence" as if they mean one thing. In law, they mean two different things, and the difference matters.

Civil negligence is about compensation. The patient or the family sues the doctor or the hospital for damages. The question is whether the doctor fell below the standard of a reasonably competent practitioner and whether that caused the loss. If the answer is yes, the court can order compensation. The standard of proof is the balance of probabilities — more likely than not.

Criminal negligence is about punishment. The state, or a complainant through a private complaint, says the doctor's conduct was a crime. The question is whether the departure from the required standard was gross or reckless — a grave disregard for the patient's safety. The standard of proof is beyond reasonable doubt, which is much higher.

This is why the same facts can lead to different results in different forums. A doctor may be ordered to pay compensation in a civil suit, or disciplined by the PMDC, and still not be guilty of a criminal offence. The Amjad Ali ruling is about the criminal side only. It does not say that the treatment was perfect. It says that the criminal charge was not proved.

How to Complain About Medical Treatment in Pakistan

If you believe a doctor or hospital treated you or a loved one negligently, there are several routes, and they can be used together:

  • Complain in writing to the hospital administration and ask for the complete medical record. Hospitals are required to maintain records, and a patient or their family is entitled to copies.
  • Complain to the Pakistan Medical and Dental Council (PMDC), which can inquire into professional misconduct and take action against a doctor's registration.
  • Complain to the provincial Healthcare Commission, which regulates hospitals and can act against a facility.
  • Consult a lawyer about a civil suit for compensation. A lawyer will usually want an independent medical opinion before advising on the strength of the claim.
  • Consider a criminal complaint only after legal advice, and only if there is evidence of gross negligence. A criminal complaint filed without that evidence is likely to end in acquittal, as it did here, and can expose the complainant to a claim for malicious prosecution.

Whatever route you choose, do not delay. Limitation periods apply to civil claims, and evidence — records, memories, test results — fades with time. Get advice early, even if you decide not to proceed.

The Bottom Line

The Supreme Court's ruling in Amjad Ali v Dr Taqdees Naqaish sets a clear and demanding test for criminal medical negligence in Pakistan. A patient's death during or after treatment is a tragedy, but it is not, by itself, a crime. The prosecution must prove a duty of care, a breach that caused the death, and a departure from professional standards serious enough to amount to gross negligence. Consent matters, but it is not a free pass for a doctor, and a signed form does not end the inquiry.

For families, the message is to build the case on evidence: an identified lapse, a proven connection to the death, and expert support. For doctors, the message is that the law protects competent practice, but only competent practice — documented, consented to, and carried out with reasonable care. The ruling does not leave patients without remedies. It directs them to the right ones: civil compensation, professional discipline, and criminal prosecution only where the fault is truly grave.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a patient's death automatically prove criminal medical negligence?

No. The Supreme Court required proof of a duty of care, a breach that caused the death, and negligence serious enough to be called gross. An adverse outcome alone cannot establish those elements.

What is the difference between civil and criminal medical negligence?

Civil negligence can support a claim for compensation when a doctor falls below the standard of a reasonably competent practitioner. Criminal negligence requires a gross and culpable departure from that standard, proved beyond reasonable doubt.

Does a consent form protect a doctor from every criminal charge?

No. Section 88 of the Pakistan Penal Code requires the relevant consent, good faith, treatment for the person's benefit, and the absence of an intention to cause death. Consent alone does not supply all those conditions or excuse criminally culpable treatment.

Did the Court say spinal anaesthesia is always safe?

No. The Court held that choosing spinal anaesthesia instead of the requested epidural did not by itself establish a criminal offence in this case. It did not decide the clinical merits of the technique for every patient.

What happened to Amjad Ali's petition?

The Supreme Court dismissed Criminal Petition for Leave to Appeal No. 955 of 2020 and refused leave to appeal on 6 October 2026. The doctors' acquittal under Section 249-A CrPC, already upheld by the Islamabad High Court, remained in place.

*This article is general legal information, not legal advice. If you have lost a loved one during medical treatment, or you are a doctor facing a complaint, consult a qualified lawyer about the facts of your own case.*