On 26 October 2026, advocate Imaan Mazari and her husband Hadi Ali Chattha approached the Supreme Court of Pakistan with a new petition in their anti-terrorism case. The move came a week after the Islamabad High Court, on 19 October 2026, refused to grant them an interim stay of the trial proceedings pending before an anti-terrorism court in Islamabad. The couple are now asking the country's highest court to do what the High Court would not: pause the trial until their pending challenge in the High Court is properly heard.
This article explains, in plain language, what has been reported, what a stay of trial actually means, why Article 10-A of the Constitution matters here, how the Islamabad High Court and the Supreme Court routes differ, and what ordinary readers — especially anyone facing a criminal trial — should understand about the process. Where facts are reported from the news of 26 October 2026, we say so clearly. Where we explain the general law, we say that too. Nothing in this article is legal advice for any individual case.
What has been reported
According to news reports of 26 October 2026, Mazari and Chattha have petitioned the Supreme Court against the Islamabad High Court's order of 19 October 2026. That High Court order rejected their request for an interim stay in their anti-terrorism case. In their Supreme Court petition, as reported, the couple raise several complaints about how the trial has been conducted so far.
First, they say the trial court has proceeded hastily. Second, they say prosecution witnesses were recorded in a single day, which, in their argument, left the defence without a fair opportunity to prepare and cross-examine properly. Third, they argue that the act at the heart of the case — the alleged removal of security barriers — does not amount to terrorism. Fourth, they argue that without an immediate stay from the Supreme Court, their pending application before the Islamabad High Court will become ineffective, because the trial may move so far ahead in the meantime that a later decision in their favour would come too late to matter.
That last point is worth pausing on, because it is the practical heart of the petition. A stay is not a verdict. It is a pause button. The couple are not asking the Supreme Court, at this stage, to decide whether they are guilty or innocent. They are asking it to stop the clock so that their existing challenge can be heard while it still has meaning.
Readers should note an important limit on what we know. Court petitions are often reported in summary form in the press, and the full text of the petition, the High Court's detailed order, and the trial court's record are not reproduced in news reports. This article therefore treats the reported arguments as the petitioners' case, not as findings of any court. The Supreme Court has not, as reported, decided the petition on its merits at the time of writing. What happens next depends on how the Court treats the request for an interim stay and on the progress of the case in the High Court.
Who are the petitioners, and why does this case attract attention?
Imaan Mazari is a practising advocate known for human rights litigation, and Hadi Ali Chattha is her husband. Cases involving lawyers, journalists and activists tend to attract public attention, and anti-terrorism cases attract more, because the Anti-Terrorism Act, 1997 carries serious consequences, including the possibility of long sentences, and because anti-terrorism courts follow a faster, more summary procedure than ordinary sessions courts.
That attention cuts both ways. Public interest can help ensure scrutiny of the process, but it can also create pressure and commentary that has nothing to do with the evidence in the courtroom. The legal questions in this petition, however, are not about personalities. They are about process: how fast is too fast, what counts as a fair opportunity to defend oneself, and when a higher court should step in to pause proceedings below.
What is an anti-terrorism trial?
Pakistan's Anti-Terrorism Act, 1997 created special courts — anti-terrorism courts — to try offences defined as terrorism under the Act. The idea behind the law was speed: terrorism cases were meant to be decided quickly, without the long delays that ordinary criminal trials sometimes suffer. The Act therefore sets short timelines for investigation and trial, limits adjournments, and gives the trial court powers to proceed even when an accused person or a witness is absent in certain circumstances.
Speed, however, is not the only value in a criminal trial. The Constitution guarantees a fair trial, and the criminal procedure law gives every accused person the right to know the charge, to be represented by counsel, to cross-examine witnesses, and to present a defence. The tension between speed and fairness is a permanent feature of anti-terrorism trials, and it is exactly the tension this petition brings into focus.
When the petitioners say the trial proceeded hastily and that prosecution witnesses were recorded in a single day, they are making a fairness argument, not merely complaining about speed. Recording several witnesses in one day is not, by itself, unlawful. Courts sometimes do record multiple witnesses in a day, especially where witnesses are available and the defence is ready. The complaint, as reported, is that the pace left the defence unable to prepare adequately — for example, to study statements, to take instructions from the accused, or to cross-examine effectively. Whether that complaint is justified is a question for the courts, which will look at the actual record: how many witnesses, what they said, what time the defence had, and whether any request for time was refused.
What does a "stay" of trial mean?
A stay is an order by a higher court directing a lower court to stop proceedings for the time being. It does not decide the case. It does not acquit anyone. It does not erase the charge. It simply freezes the trial at the point it has reached, until the higher court decides the matter before it or lifts the stay.
Stays are common in both civil and criminal litigation, but they are not granted automatically. A court considering a stay usually asks three questions. First, does the applicant have a serious, arguable case — something that deserves a hearing, not a frivolous objection? Second, will the applicant suffer harm that cannot be undone if the trial continues — what lawyers call irreparable loss? Third, where does the balance of convenience lie — would pausing the trial cause more harm to the other side or to the public interest than letting it continue?
In a criminal trial, the "irreparable loss" argument often takes a specific form, and it is the form reported here: if the trial finishes and a judgment is delivered before the higher court decides the challenge, the challenge may become pointless. A conviction, once recorded, carries its own consequences — custody, stigma, and the need for an appeal — even if it is later set aside. The petitioners' argument, as reported, is that without a stay their pending High Court application will become ineffective. That is a classic stay argument, and it is one courts take seriously, though they do not always accept it.
It is equally important to understand what a stay does not do. A stay does not stop the investigation, does not release an accused person on bail by itself, and does not prevent the prosecution from pursuing the case once the stay is lifted. A stay is temporary by nature. It lasts until the court that granted it decides otherwise.
Article 10-A: the right to a fair trial
Article 10-A of the Constitution of Pakistan, inserted by the Eighteenth Amendment in 2010, provides that for the determination of a person's civil rights and obligations or in any criminal charge against them, the person shall be entitled to a fair trial and due process. Those few words carry a great deal of weight.
Fair trial is not a single right but a bundle of protections. It includes the right to be informed of the charge in detail, the right to adequate time and facilities to prepare a defence, the right to legal counsel of one's choice, the right to cross-examine prosecution witnesses, the right to produce defence evidence, the right to an impartial tribunal, and the right to a reasoned decision that can be appealed. Due process adds the requirement that the state must follow the law as written, rather than acting arbitrarily, even when it is pursuing a serious charge.
Anti-terrorism law does not sit outside Article 10-A. The Supreme Court has repeatedly held that special laws and fast-track procedures must still comply with constitutional guarantees. Speed is a legitimate aim, but it cannot be achieved by removing the core elements of a fair trial. That is why arguments about hasty proceedings and inadequate opportunity to cross-examine are framed as constitutional arguments, not just complaints about case management.
For ordinary readers, the practical meaning of Article 10-A is this: the state must prove its case, and the accused must have a real, not merely formal, chance to answer it. If a trial moves so fast that the defence cannot meaningfully participate, the resulting judgment is vulnerable — not because the accused is necessarily innocent, but because the process did not test the evidence properly. Courts guard this principle even in cases where public feeling runs strong, because a conviction that survives appeal must rest on a process that was fair.
The Islamabad High Court route and the Supreme Court route: how they differ
To understand why the couple have moved from one court to another, it helps to understand the hierarchy. An anti-terrorism court is a trial court. Above it sits the High Court — in this case, the Islamabad High Court — which exercises supervisory and appellate jurisdiction over courts in the federal capital. Above the High Courts sits the Supreme Court of Pakistan, the final appellate court.
When a party is unhappy with an order of the trial court — for example, a refusal to adjourn, a decision on the framing of the charge, or the pace of proceedings — the usual route is to approach the High Court. The High Court can be asked to stay the trial, to call for the record, or to quash proceedings in appropriate cases. That is what the petitioners did: they went to the Islamabad High Court seeking an interim stay, and on 19 October 2026 the High Court declined to grant it.
A refusal of interim relief is itself an order that can be challenged further. The petitioners have now approached the Supreme Court against that refusal. This is an important distinction. The Supreme Court is not, at this stage, being asked to try the anti-terrorism case itself, nor to decide the merits of the underlying charge. It is being asked to review whether the High Court was right to refuse a stay while the High Court application remains pending. The Supreme Court's jurisdiction here is therefore narrower and more focused: it concerns the interim protection, not the final outcome.
This layered structure matters for anyone following the case. A decision by the Supreme Court on the stay will not end the case. If a stay is granted, the trial pauses and the High Court application proceeds. If a stay is refused, the trial continues, but the High Court application and any later appeal remain available. Either way, the underlying question of guilt or innocence is still to be decided through the ordinary process, unless a court at some stage decides the proceedings themselves cannot continue in law.
"Removing security barriers is not terrorism": the argument about the charge itself
As reported, the petitioners argue that the alleged act — removing security barriers — is not terrorism. This is a legal argument about the scope of the Anti-Terrorism Act, and it deserves careful explanation, because the word "terrorism" is used loosely in everyday speech but has a specific legal meaning.
Under the Anti-Terrorism Act, terrorism is not simply any unlawful or disruptive act. The Act defines terrorism by reference to actions — such as violence, threats, or acts designed to intimidate the public or a section of the public, or to coerce the government — committed for particular purposes. The prosecution must therefore show not only that an act happened, but that it falls within the statutory definition. An act of protest, obstruction, or removal of a barrier may be unlawful under other laws — for example, as mischief, obstruction of a public servant, or a traffic offence — without necessarily being terrorism.
Courts in Pakistan have wrestled with this boundary for years. The Supreme Court has, in past judgments, cautioned against stretching the definition of terrorism to cover every violent or disruptive act, because doing so would bring ordinary crimes into special courts and dilute the purpose of the anti-terrorism regime. At the same time, courts have recognised that acts which genuinely create fear and insecurity among the public can fall within the Act even if they do not involve the most extreme forms of violence.
Whether removing security barriers in the particular circumstances of this case amounts to terrorism is therefore a fact-sensitive question. It will depend on what the barriers were, why they were there, how they were removed, what followed, and what intention the prosecution attributes to the accused. The petitioners' argument, as reported, is that on the facts alleged the threshold is not met. The prosecution, presumably, takes the opposite view. The courts will decide that question on the record, not on the basis of public debate.
For the general reader, the lesson is broader: the label attached to a charge matters enormously. An anti-terrorism charge brings a special court, a faster timeline, and potentially heavier punishment than an ordinary criminal charge for the same physical act. That is why challenges to the applicability of the Anti-Terrorism Act are common, and why courts examine them closely.
What happens next: the possible paths
Several outcomes are possible from here, and readers should not assume any one of them.
First, the Supreme Court could grant an interim stay. If it does, the anti-terrorism trial will pause while the Supreme Court considers the petition further, or while the High Court application is decided. A stay would not signal that the petitioners will ultimately win; it would signal only that the Court considers a pause necessary to preserve the usefulness of the pending proceedings.
Second, the Supreme Court could decline to interfere with the High Court's order. In that case the trial would continue in the anti-terrorism court, and the High Court application would proceed alongside it, or the petitioners would pursue their remedies after the trial concludes. A refusal of a stay is not a finding on the merits of the charge, and it does not prevent the accused from raising the same fairness arguments on appeal if convicted.
Third, the Supreme Court could issue notice to the other side — the state and the prosecution — and fix the matter for a fuller hearing before deciding on interim relief. This is a common middle course: the Court hears both sides briefly, examines the record, and then decides whether a stay is warranted. In high-profile matters, this stage often attracts the most reporting, but it is still only a preliminary stage.
Fourth, developments in the High Court itself could change the picture. If the High Court decides the pending application soon, the question of an interim stay may become academic. Courts often prefer to decide the main matter rather than prolong interim litigation, and lawyers on both sides will be watching the High Court's schedule closely.
Whatever path is taken, one practical consequence deserves emphasis. Litigation about a stay adds time to the overall case. The petitioners have argued that the trial is moving too fast; ironically, a successful stay will slow it down considerably. That is not a contradiction. The complaint is not about delay in the abstract, but about the defence having enough time at the right stages. A pause that allows proper preparation is, in the petitioners' argument, the remedy for a trial that moved too fast at the wrong stage.
Practical notes for accused persons: what this case illustrates
Most readers will never face an anti-terrorism charge, but the procedural lessons of this petition apply to criminal cases generally. The following notes are general legal information, not advice for any individual case. Anyone facing a criminal charge should consult a lawyer promptly.
First, keep a record. Note the dates of hearings, the witnesses examined, the applications filed, and the orders passed. Fairness arguments often turn on the record: whether time was sought, whether it was refused, and what reasons were given. A clear record makes it possible for a higher court to assess what actually happened, rather than relying on competing recollections.
Second, apply for time properly and promptly. If the defence needs more time to prepare cross-examination or to obtain documents, the request should be made in court, on the record, with reasons. Courts are more sympathetic to a specific request — for example, "we received these statements yesterday and need two days to take instructions" — than to a general complaint made later that the trial was too fast.
Third, use the High Court route early. Interim orders, including refusals of adjournment or of a stay, can often be challenged in the High Court while the trial is still pending. Waiting until after conviction to raise a procedural complaint is possible through appeal, but it is a longer and harder road, and the harm of an unfair trial may already have occurred.
Fourth, understand bail and stay as separate remedies. A stay pauses the trial. Bail releases the accused from custody while the case proceeds. A person can be on bail while the trial continues, and a person can be in custody while proceedings are stayed. Confusing the two can lead to mistaken expectations about what a court order will achieve.
Fifth, do not rely on public commentary. Social media discussion of a pending case can create impressions that have no bearing on the evidence. Courts decide on the record before them. Public statements by parties or commentators do not form part of that record, and in some circumstances commentary about a pending case can itself create legal complications. The safest course for anyone connected to a pending case is to let the lawyers speak through the court.
Sixth, remember that the prosecution also has rights. The state is entitled to a fair opportunity to present its case, and complainants and witnesses are entitled to protection from harassment and delay. Fair trial is not a one-sided concept. Courts balance the rights of the accused against the interests of victims, witnesses and the public in the timely disposal of cases. Arguments that ignore that balance are less persuasive than arguments that acknowledge it and explain why, even allowing for it, the defence was prejudiced.
Why interim orders matter more than they appear to
To a non-lawyer, a dispute about an interim stay can seem like a technical side-show. The real case, after all, is about whether an offence was committed. But lawyers know that interim orders often determine the practical outcome of litigation. A trial conducted without adequate defence preparation may produce a conviction that is difficult to undo, even if an appellate court later finds the procedure wanting. Conversely, a stay granted too readily can delay justice for victims and witnesses and allow memories to fade.
That is why courts treat stay applications with care, and why the refusal of a stay is itself a significant order worthy of challenge. The petitioners' move to the Supreme Court is, in that sense, unremarkable as a matter of procedure: when a High Court refuses interim relief, the Supreme Court is the next forum. What makes this case notable is the combination of the forum, the nature of the charge, and the constitutional argument about fair trial.
It is also worth noting that interim litigation can clarify the law for future cases. If the Supreme Court lays down guidance on when anti-terrorism trials should be stayed, or on the minimum opportunity the defence must be given, that guidance will affect cases far beyond this one. Court decisions on interim relief are often short, but they are read closely by trial judges and lawyers.
Reported facts versus general explanation: a clear line
This article has deliberately separated two kinds of material. The reported facts are limited: on 26 October 2026 the couple petitioned the Supreme Court; on 19 October 2026 the Islamabad High Court refused an interim stay; the petitioners argue the trial proceeded hastily, that prosecution witnesses were recorded in a single day, that removing security barriers is not terrorism, and that without a stay their pending High Court application becomes ineffective. Those points are attributed to news reports of the petition.
Everything else — the explanation of stays, Article 10-A, the hierarchy of courts, the definition of terrorism, and the practical notes — is general legal explanation. It is included so that readers can follow the case intelligently, not as a claim about what any court has decided in this case. No case citation has been invented, no quotation has been attributed to a judge or lawyer beyond what news reports summarise, and no outcome has been predicted.
Readers who want to follow the case further should look for the Supreme Court's order on the stay application, the Islamabad High Court's decision on the pending application, and the trial court's record. Those documents, when available, will provide the authoritative account. Until then, the responsible approach is to treat the petitioners' arguments as arguments, the prosecution's position as yet to be fully heard in this round, and the courts' decisions as pending.
Conclusion
The Supreme Court petition by Imaan Mazari and Hadi Ali Chattha is, at its core, a plea for time: time for the defence to be heard properly, time for the High Court application to be decided while it still matters, and time for the constitutional guarantee of a fair trial to operate in practice rather than on paper. Whether the Supreme Court grants that time is a decision for the Court, on the record and after hearing both sides.
For the public, the case is a useful reminder of how Pakistan's criminal justice system works in stages. A trial court decides facts. A High Court supervises and corrects. A Supreme Court has the final word on the law. At each stage, interim orders — stays, adjournments, directions — shape what happens next. Understanding those stages does not require taking a side in the underlying dispute. It requires only recognising that a fair process is the precondition for a just result, whatever that result turns out to be.
We will update this article as the Supreme Court's proceedings develop and as the Islamabad High Court decides the pending application. Readers facing similar issues should seek independent legal advice, because every case turns on its own facts and record.
Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. It is based on news reports of 26 October 2026 concerning a pending court matter. Court proceedings may develop after publication, and readers should verify the latest position from court records or a qualified lawyer.
