What Happened: The Short Version

On 3 October 2026, the Lahore High Court delivered a judgment that every landlord and tenant in Punjab should read. Justice Khalid Ishaq dismissed two petitions filed by a private medical college and hospital seeking exemption from property tax — and in doing so, clarified who actually pays when a property is rented or leased out.

The court's holding, in plain words: the primary liability for property tax rests with the property owner. But if the owner fails to pay, the tax authorities can serve the payment notice on the person using the property on rent or lease. An unregistered lease agreement does not shield anyone, and using court petitions to delay lawful tax only makes things worse — the court imposed a Rs1 million fine for exactly that conduct.

Legal information only, not legal advice: This article explains the ruling in plain language. It is not legal advice for any person or case.

The Case: A Medical College vs the Tax Department

The petitioners were a private medical college and its attached hospital, operating on leased premises. They asked the Lahore High Court to exempt them from property tax. Their arguments, in essence: the tax should not fall on them as occupants, and they also challenged aspects of the assessment, including taxation of their rural-area operations.

The court was not persuaded. It found that:

  • The college and hospital were carrying out commercial activities on rural land, but had failed to produce evidence of the required legal permission — or payment of the fees — for conversion of the rural land's use. They subsequently withdrew their plea seeking non-imposition of property tax in the rural area.
  • The petitioner had continuously avoided payment of lawful taxes and dues and used delaying tactics to defer payment.
  • Both petitions were dismissed, the petitioners were held liable for the previously outstanding property tax, and a Rs1 million fine was imposed — recoverable as arrears of land revenue under the Punjab Land Revenue Act 1967.

The Core Holding: Owner Pays First, Occupier Can Be Asked Next

Strip away the facts and the ruling gives Punjab a clear rule for rented and leased property:

  1. The owner is primarily liable. Property tax is a tax on the property, and the first person the law looks to is the owner.
  2. The occupier is the backup. If the owner fails to pay, the tax authorities are not helpless — they can serve a payment notice on the person actually using the property, whether on rent or lease. The department can recover from the occupier.
  3. The lease being unregistered changes nothing. The court observed that a party cannot avoid its legal tax liability by taking advantage of an unregistered lease agreement — and no person can benefit from their own failure to fulfil legal requirements. If your defence is "the lease was never registered, so I am not the lessee," the court will treat that as your problem, not your shield.

Read with the amendments to the Punjab property-tax law (the ruling was decided under the law as amended by the Finance Act 2024), the practical effect the court endorsed is the one in this article's title: a long-term lessee in possession is treated as liable for the tax — the department does not have to chase only the owner while the occupier enjoys the property tax-free.

Why the Court Came Down Hard: Delaying Tactics

The Rs1 million fine is the part of the judgment that will be quoted for years. The court found the petitioner had:

  • Continuously avoided payment of lawful taxes and dues;
  • Used delaying tactics to defer payment; and
  • Tried to use constitutional jurisdiction — a writ petition — as a tool to violate the law and evade payment of taxes.

The court's message was blunt: constitutional jurisdiction cannot be used to evade the law. A writ petition is not a parking lot for tax dues. The court also held that interim relief cannot be used as a basis for obtaining a permanent exemption — getting a stay order does not mean you have won; it means the court has paused things while it decides, and the tax meter keeps running.

The fine is recoverable as arrears of land revenue under the Punjab Land Revenue Act 1967 — meaning the state can use its full revenue-recovery machinery (attachment and sale of property, among other tools) to collect it.

What This Means for Tenants and Landlords in Punjab

If you are a tenant or lessee

  • You are not automatically safe because "tax is the owner's problem." If your landlord defaults, the Excise & Taxation Department can serve you with the payment notice — and can move against you for recovery.
  • Register your lease. An unregistered lease gives you no protection against the tax department — the court said so expressly. Registration also protects you under the Punjab Rented Premises Act 2009 in eviction and rent disputes.
  • Put the tax clause in writing. Decide in the rent agreement who pays the property tax — owner or tenant — and write it into the agreement. A clear clause prevents the most common landlord-tenant tax fight.
  • Keep proof of payment. If you pay tax on the owner's behalf (or your share), keep the receipts — you may need them to adjust against rent or to prove compliance.

If you are a landlord or property owner

  • The primary liability is yours. Do not assume the tenant will be chased first. If the tax is unpaid, the department starts with you.
  • A written, registered lease protects you too. It fixes who the occupier is, what the rent is, and who bears the tax — which matters if the department ever asks.
  • Do not use litigation as a delaying strategy. This judgment shows courts will see through it — and fine you for it. If you dispute an assessment, use the proper appellate route (objections, appeals under the tax statutes) rather than trying to park the dispute in a writ petition.

If you run an institution on leased premises

Schools, colleges, hospitals and offices on rented property should note the second half of this case: operating a commercial activity on rural/agricultural land without conversion permission and fee payment will not survive judicial scrutiny. Get the land-use conversion regularised before the tax department comes calling.

The Proper Way to Dispute a Property Tax Demand

Disagreeing with a tax demand is your right. Doing it the wrong way is expensive. The lawful route:

  1. Read the demand notice carefully — check the property description, the assessment year, and the calculation. Many disputes are arithmetic.
  2. File objections within time before the assessing authority, with documents (ownership proof, lease, exemption notifications if any).
  3. Use the statutory appeals provided in the tax law — do not jump straight to the High Court unless a genuine constitutional question (like vires of a provision) is involved.
  4. Pay or secure the disputed amount as the law requires while the appeal proceeds, so that "delaying tactics" can never be alleged against you.
  5. Keep the paper trail — every notice, every receipt, every order. In tax litigation, the file is the case.

Key Terms Glossary

  • Property tax (urban immovable property tax): the annual provincial tax on buildings and lands, administered in Punjab by the Excise, Taxation & Narcotics Control Department under the Punjab Urban Immovable Property Tax Act 1958 (as amended).
  • Arrears of land revenue: a recovery mode under the Punjab Land Revenue Act 1967 letting the state recover dues with coercive revenue powers.
  • Interim relief: a temporary court order (like a stay) granted while the case is pending — not a final decision.
  • Unregistered lease: a lease agreement not registered as required by law — the court held it cannot be used to dodge tax liability.
  • Writ petition / constitutional jurisdiction: a petition directly to the High Court under Article 199 of the Constitution — meant for enforcement of fundamental rights and genuine jurisdictional questions, not for evading lawful taxes.

Frequently Asked Questions

I am a tenant. Can the tax department really ask me to pay the property tax?
Yes — if the owner fails to pay. The Lahore High Court has now confirmed that where the owner defaults, the authorities can serve the payment notice on the person using the property on rent or lease. The primary liability stays with the owner, but you are the lawful backup.

My lease was never registered. Does that protect me?
No — the opposite. The court expressly held that a party cannot avoid tax liability by taking advantage of an unregistered lease, and no one can benefit from their own failure to fulfil legal requirements. Register the lease.

Can I get a stay order and stop paying while the case runs?
A court may grant interim relief in a genuine case, but this judgment warns that interim relief is not a permanent exemption — and using court proceedings as a delaying tactic for lawful dues can attract a heavy fine. The petitioners here got a Rs1 million fine for exactly that.

Who should the property tax clause name in a rent agreement?
Either party can agree to bear it, but write it down. In the absence of a clause, the owner is primarily liable — while the tenant remains exposed if the owner defaults. A one-line clause in the agreement prevents years of dispute.

Does this apply outside Punjab?
This judgment is from the Lahore High Court and concerns Punjab's property-tax law. Other provinces have their own statutes, but the underlying principle — owner primarily liable, occupier reachable on default — is widely reflected in property-tax laws. Check your province's statute.

The Bottom Line

The Lahore High Court has closed a popular loophole: you cannot enjoy a property while its tax goes unpaid and then point at the owner — or at an unregistered lease — when the notice arrives. Owners pay first; occupiers can be asked next; and using the courts to stall lawful taxes now carries a Rs1 million lesson. Put the tax clause in your lease, register the agreement, and pay on time — it is cheaper than the alternative.