Can a court order Parliament to make a law? That was the question before the Lahore High Court in a petition asking for legislation against marital rape and sexual exploitation within marriage. The Court's answer, in a seven-page written verdict by Justice Abher Gul Khan, was no. Making laws is Parliament's job, not the courts'. The petition was dismissed.
The case has drawn attention because it touches one of the most sensitive subjects in Pakistani law: sexual violence within marriage, and whether the criminal law as it stands today protects a wife against her husband. The Court was careful to say that its decision does not justify violence or coercion within marriage, and that a woman's dignity, security and constitutional protections remain intact after marriage. But it refused to direct the government to legislate.
This article explains, in plain language, what the petition asked for, why the Court refused, what Section 375 of the Pakistan Penal Code actually says, and what protections already exist for women in Pakistan.
What the Petition Asked For
The petition was filed by lawyer Areej Sohail Bhutta. She argued that there are gaps in the existing legal framework concerning sexual violence within marriage, and she asked the Court to direct the federal and provincial governments to introduce appropriate legislation. In particular, she sought amendments to Sections 375 and 376 of the Pakistan Penal Code, 1860, to establish a specific legal framework addressing marital rape.
Section 375 defines rape. Section 376 prescribes its punishment. The petitioner's case was that the law, as it stands, does not deal clearly and specifically with non-consensual sexual relations within marriage, and that the legislature should be directed to fix that gap.
It is important to understand what kind of case this was. The petitioner was not asking the Court to punish a particular person, or to decide whether a particular act was a crime. She was asking the Court to tell the legislature to make a new law. That distinction — between deciding a case and ordering legislation — is at the heart of the Court's reasoning.
Why the Court Refused: Lawmaking Belongs to Parliament
The Lahore High Court dismissed the petition. Justice Abher Gul Khan held that making laws falls within the authority of Parliament and the provincial assemblies, and that courts cannot compel any government institution to enact a particular law or amend existing legislation.
This is a basic principle of the constitutional separation of powers. Under the Constitution of Pakistan, 1973, the legislature makes laws, the executive implements them, and the judiciary interprets and applies them. A court can strike down a law that violates the Constitution. It can interpret a law. It can order the government to perform a duty the law already imposes. But it cannot order the legislature to pass a law that does not exist, or to amend a law in a particular way.
The Court also pointed out a practical problem with the petition: the petitioner had not challenged any specific legal provision. She had not said "this section of the law is unconstitutional and should be struck down." She had asked the Court to direct that new provisions be created. A court that did that would be writing the law itself, and that is not its role.
The judge observed that Parliament could legislate on the matter if it considered such measures necessary. The door to reform was left open — but it is a door that only the legislature can walk through.
What Section 375 of the Pakistan Penal Code Says
Much of the public discussion after the verdict has focused on Section 375. It is worth reading what the law actually says, because there is a common misunderstanding about it.
Section 375 defines rape as sexual intercourse with a woman under five described circumstances: against her will; without her consent; with her consent obtained by putting her in fear of death or hurt; with her consent obtained when she believes the man is her husband when he is not; and with or without her consent when she is under sixteen years of age.
Justice Abher Gul Khan noted something important: the existing wording of Section 375 does not mention an exemption for husbands on the basis of marriage. The section does not say "except when the man is her husband." That observation matters, because in some other countries the old common-law rule was that a husband could not be guilty of raping his wife. The Pakistani statute, as written, contains no such express exception.
At the same time, the Court did not decide that a husband can be prosecuted for rape under Section 375 as it stands, and it did not decide the opposite. That question was not before it. The petition asked for new legislation, not for an interpretation of the existing section in a particular case. The Court's observation about the wording of Section 375 is therefore a starting point for future argument, not a final answer.
The punishment for rape is provided in Section 376, which prescribes death or imprisonment for a term of not less than ten years and not more than twenty-five years, along with a fine. These are serious penalties, and they apply to whoever is convicted under the section.
What Protections Already Exist for Women
The Court also pointed out that provincial legislation already provides legal protections for women. That is an important part of the picture, because the debate is sometimes framed as if a wife who suffers violence at home has no legal remedy at all. That is not the position.
A wife who suffers physical violence from her husband can file a criminal complaint. Causing hurt is punishable under the Pakistan Penal Code, including Sections 332 to 337, which deal with hurt and grievous hurt. A husband who beats his wife commits an offence, whether or not any question of marital rape arises. The Supreme Court confirmed this very point in a separate ruling on 3 November 2026, holding that domestic violence by a civil servant is service misconduct even when it happens at home and off duty.
A wife can also seek protection under the provincial domestic violence laws. Punjab, Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa have enacted protection of women against violence legislation, and the Islamabad Capital Territory has its own law. These laws provide for protection orders, residence orders and monetary relief, and they create a procedure for a woman to approach a court quickly when she is at risk.
A wife can seek dissolution of marriage on the ground of cruelty under the Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act, 1939. Cruelty in that law has been interpreted broadly by the courts, and physical violence is a recognised ground. The Supreme Court's 2026 ruling on shiqaq also confirmed that a woman can obtain dissolution even where cruelty is not proved in the technical sense, where the marriage has broken down irretrievably.
A wife can also approach the police for an FIR where an offence has been committed, and she can seek help from the provincial women's protection authorities, shelter homes and helplines. None of these remedies depends on a new law about marital rape being passed.
None of this means the existing framework is complete. The petitioner argued, with reason, that there is a gap in the law where sexual violence within marriage is concerned. The Court did not disagree that a gap may exist. It held only that filling it is Parliament's job.
Separation of Powers: Why Courts Do Not Write Laws
To understand the verdict, it helps to understand why the separation of powers matters. The Constitution divides power between the legislature, the executive and the judiciary for a reason: so that no one institution has all the power, and so that each can check the others.
When a court orders the government to do something the law already requires — for example, to release a person held without lawful authority, or to pay a pension the law already grants — it is enforcing the law. When a court orders the legislature to pass a new law, it is stepping into the legislature's shoes. It would be deciding what the law should say, which is a political decision that belongs to elected representatives who are accountable to voters.
This is also why the Court noted that the petitioner had not challenged any specific provision. If a law is unconstitutional, a citizen can challenge it and a court can strike it down. That is the judiciary's proper role. But asking a court to create a law is different from asking it to remove one.
There are examples of courts nudging the legislature. Courts sometimes observe in a judgment that a gap in the law should be addressed, and legislatures sometimes respond. But an observation is not an order, and the Lahore High Court's verdict makes that distinction clear.
What Happens Next
The dismissal of the petition does not end the debate. It moves it to the place where it belongs: the legislature and public discussion.
Parliament can amend Sections 375 and 376 of the Pakistan Penal Code at any time. Provincial assemblies can amend their own laws. A member of the National Assembly or a provincial assembly can introduce a private member's bill. The Law and Justice Commission of Pakistan, and the Council of Islamic Ideology, can be asked for their views. Women's rights organisations, bar associations and legal scholars can continue to press the case for reform.
The Court's observation that Section 375 contains no express marital exemption may also become important in a future case. If a prosecution is ever brought on the basis that a husband's non-consensual sexual act with his wife falls within Section 375, a court will have to interpret the section and decide. The Lahore High Court's verdict does not answer that question, but it records the wording of the law, and that record is now part of the legal discussion.
For women facing violence at home, the practical message of this verdict is unchanged: the existing criminal law, the domestic violence laws and the family courts remain available, and a woman does not need to wait for a new law to seek protection. If you are in danger, contact the police, a women's protection centre, or a lawyer immediately.
The Bottom Line
The Lahore High Court has declined to order Parliament to legislate against marital rape. Its reasoning is constitutional, not moral: courts interpret and enforce the law, they do not write it. The verdict does not say that violence within marriage is acceptable. It says, expressly, that a woman's dignity, security and constitutional protections remain intact after marriage. It also records that Section 375 of the Pakistan Penal Code, as written, contains no exemption for husbands.
The gap the petitioner identified remains a matter for Parliament. Until the legislature acts, the protections that do exist — the criminal law against hurt, the provincial domestic violence laws, and the family courts — are the remedies available to women, and they should be used without delay where a woman is at risk.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did the Lahore High Court say marital rape is legal?
No. The Court declined to order Parliament to pass a new law. It did not decide whether a husband's non-consensual sexual act with his wife is an offence under the existing Section 375, because that question was not before it.
Does Section 375 of the Pakistan Penal Code exempt husbands?
The Court noted that the existing wording of Section 375 does not mention an exemption for husbands on the basis of marriage. The section defines rape without any express marital exception.
Can a court order the government to make a law?
No, according to this verdict. Making laws is the job of Parliament and the provincial assemblies. A court cannot compel the legislature to enact or amend legislation.
What can a woman do if her husband is violent towards her?
She can file a criminal complaint for hurt under the Pakistan Penal Code, seek a protection order under the provincial domestic violence laws, approach the police or a women's protection centre, and seek dissolution of marriage on the ground of cruelty in the family court.
What happens next on this issue?
Reform, if it comes, must come from Parliament or a provincial assembly, through an amendment to the Pakistan Penal Code or new legislation. The Court observed that Parliament can legislate on the matter if it considers it necessary.
*This article is general legal information, not legal advice. If you are facing violence at home, contact the police, a women's protection centre, or a lawyer immediately.*
