Quick Answer: Police custody in Pakistan is temporary and tightly controlled. Article 10(1) of the Constitution guarantees your right to consult and be defended by a lawyer of your choice; Article 10(2) requires production before a magistrate within 24 hours; Section 167 CrPC caps police custody at 15 days and forces the magistrate to record reasons in writing. The Lahore High Court on 5 October 2026 reserved its verdict on a plea by Hammad Azhar's family to let him meet relatives and sign a Wakalatnama — a reminder that these rights exist on paper, but families often have to fight to enforce them.
What Happened: The Lahore High Court Reserved Its Verdict
On 5 October 2026, a two-member bench of the Lahore High Court headed by Justice Shahbaz Ali Rizvi reserved its verdict on a petition filed by the mother of PTI leader Mian Hammad Azhar. The request was simple and human: let her son meet his family and his lawyers.
Hammad Azhar remains in police custody on physical remand. His counsel, Abuzar Salman Niazi, argued before the bench that the Anti-Terrorism Court had directed the family to approach the police for meeting permission — but police-station access was simply not being provided. And there was a sharper legal point: continued police custody was preventing Azhar from signing a Wakalatnama, the power of attorney a client signs to formally engage counsel. Without it, his ability to challenge the remand and consult his legal team was suffering.
The state counsel countered that Azhar is a political figure receiving numerous visitors, and restrictions on some visitors had led to complaints. The state also contended that biometric verification — required for challenging the remand — is not available for suspects held in police custody. Justice Shahbaz Ali Rizvi asked the obvious question: does that mean the remand cannot be challenged at all? The state counsel backed off that position and suggested the family should instead submit a request to the police.
The bench observed that the state had itself acknowledged biometric verification was unavailable in police custody, and considered the petitioner's position in that light. Then it reserved its verdict. The outcome is not known yet. Nobody should tell you otherwise.
This case matters to you because it is not really about one political leader. Every week, in police stations from Gujranwala to Hyderabad, ordinary families hit the exact same wall: the lock-up door, a constable's shrug, a lawyer who cannot reach his own client. The law on this subject is clear. The practice, as this case shows, is where things break down.
What Does "Physical Remand" Actually Mean?
Let's start with basics, because Aksar log ye ghalti karte hain: they treat "remand" as one mysterious thing. It isn't. There are two kinds of custody, and confusing them is the first mistake families make.
Police custody (physical remand) means the accused is in the hands of the police — at the police station, in a police lock-up. Judicial custody means the accused is sent to jail — in Lahore that typically means Camp Jail or Kot Lakhpat Jail — and the police can no longer hold him for investigation.
Physical remand exists for one purpose only: investigation. When police arrest someone and cannot finish the investigation within 24 hours, the officer in charge (or an investigating officer not below the rank of sub-inspector) must do two things under Section 167 CrPC:
- Transmit the case diary (Section 172 CrPC) to the nearest magistrate.
- Forward the accused to that magistrate.
The magistrate then decides. And here is the key number: under Section 167, the magistrate may authorise detention in police custody for a maximum of 15 days in total — whether in one stretch or in pieces. Fifteen days altogether. Not 15 per application. Total.
One important exception to know: in cases tried under the Anti-Terrorism Act, the ATA's own remand provision (Section 21-E) permits the court to grant police custody of up to 30 days at one time, with a total ceiling of 90 days across all grants. That is why the Anti-Terrorism Court in Lahore could hand Hammad Azhar over on a 20-day physical remand — the ATA regime is separate from the ordinary CrPC route. If your loved one's case is an ordinary FIR case (theft, fraud, a brawl), the 15-day total applies. If it is an ATA case, the framework is different and the ceiling is higher. Ask the lawyer which regime applies. It changes everything.
The 24-Hour Rule: Nobody Can Sit in a Thana Indefinitely
Article 10(2) of the Constitution is beautifully blunt: every person arrested and detained in custody must be produced before a magistrate within 24 hours of arrest — excluding only the time needed for the journey from the place of arrest to the nearest magistrate. No detention beyond that period without a magistrate's authority.
So when Bilal, a shopkeeper from Gujranwala, is picked up by police at 6 pm on a Monday over a business dispute his partner converted into an FIR, the police have until Tuesday evening to produce him before the magistrate. If they don't — if they keep him sitting in the lock-up, "investigation chal rahi hai," no court produced — that detention becomes illegal on its own. The family's first question should never be "kitna paisa lagega?" It should be: "Has he been produced before the magistrate yet, and in which court?"
Mere tajurbe me aksar families ka yehi first point miss ho jata hai. They spend days running to the thana with food and requests, never realising the single most powerful question is whether the 24-hour production happened at all.
The Magistrate Is Not a Rubber Stamp
Here is something police don't advertise and families don't know: when the magistrate gets the remand application, he is not supposed to just sign. Section 167 requires the magistrate to record his reasons in writing for granting police custody, and to forward a copy to the Sessions Judge. The accused is produced before the magistrate precisely so he can make a representation — speak for himself, through counsel, against the police request.
Think about what that hearing is for. The magistrate examines the case diary. He asks: has the investigation genuinely progressed? Is continued police custody necessary, or is this a fishing expedition? And the accused — or his lawyer — can contest it right there. The Supreme Court's case law has repeatedly stressed that remand is not a routine order; the magistrate must apply his judicial mind.
Practical reality check, though. In many magistrate courts across Pakistan, remand proceedings last minutes. The diary is pushed across the table, the remand is granted, everyone moves on. That is the norm families face, and it is why having a lawyer present at the remand hearing matters enormously. If no lawyer is engaged — because, as in the Hammad Azhar case, the accused cannot even sign the Wakalatnama — the accused argues alone, in handcuffs, against a system built for speed.
This is exactly why the right to sign the Wakalatnama while in custody is not a formality. It is the door to everything else. No signed Wakalatnama, no counsel formally on record. No counsel on record, no serious challenge to the remand. Do you see how the chain breaks?
Your Constitutional Rights in Custody: Article 10(1)
Article 10(1) of the Constitution says it plainly: no person who is arrested shall be detained in custody without being informed, as soon as may be, of the grounds of his arrest — nor shall he be denied the right to consult and be defended by a legal practitioner of his choice.
That sentence is the backbone of this whole article. Break it down:
- Informed of the grounds of arrest. The police must tell you why you are arrested. Not "uper se order hai." Not "baad me pata chal jayega." The grounds — which FIR, which offence, registered at which police station. Ask for the FIR number and get a copy. Every arrested person is entitled to know.
- Right to consult and be defended by a legal practitioner of your choice. Your choice. Not the SHO's favourite lawyer, not the investigating officer's "contact." You choose, and the Constitution protects that choice.
Can the police refuse to let your lawyer meet you? Legally, no. The Constitution's language is mandatory. But the Hammad Azhar proceedings show the lived reality: the ATC told the family to approach the police; the police station did not provide access; the state defended restrictions by pointing to the volume of visitors. The family's complaint was not hypothetical — it was the core of a High Court petition.
What should families do when access is denied? Write it down. Date, time, which officer refused, who was present. Then put the refusal in writing to the SHO with a copy marked to the DPO or CCPO, and file an application before the magistrate hearing the remand. Verbal refusals evaporate. Written ones create a record the court can see.
The Wakalatnama Problem: Why a Signature Became a Constitutional Question
A Wakalatnama is the power of attorney through which a client authorises an advocate to appear for him. Courts require it before an advocate can formally act. For a man in police custody, signing it means the lawyer can file applications, challenge the remand, seek bail, and receive the case papers.
In the Hammad Azhar hearing, this became a constitutional flashpoint. The petitioner's counsel argued that continued police custody was preventing the signing. The court's question was telling: had an application been made to the Jail Superintendent for the signing? The answer revealed the structural gap — the Jail Superintendent route works for jail custody; Azhar was in police custody, where that route does not exist.
Then came the state's argument about biometric verification being unavailable for suspects in police custody — with the court noting that if biometric verification is genuinely required and genuinely unavailable, the practical effect is that remand cannot be challenged. The bench's observation cut to the point: the state's own admission created the problem. You cannot tell a citizen "you need biometric to challenge your detention" and simultaneously tell him "biometric isn't available where we are detaining you."
For an ordinary family, the lesson is simpler. If your loved one is in police custody and the lawyer cannot get a signed Wakalatnama, the lawyer should move the magistrate directly: seek a court order permitting a meeting in custody for the purpose of signing the power of attorney. Courts routinely allow this. And if even the meeting is blocked, the lawyer can file the application with a special Wakalatnama signed by a family member or, where the rules permit, seek the court's direction to have the accused sign in the presence of court staff. The point is: there is always a procedural route. "Police ne milne nahi diya" is a fact to be recorded and placed before the court — not the end of the road.
Can the Accused Challenge the Remand? Yes — Before the Magistrate
This is the right the state's biometric argument nearly swallowed. The answer is yes, and the mechanism is built into Section 167 itself.
Every time the police seek remand or its extension, the accused is produced. At that moment, the accused or his counsel can:
- Oppose the remand, arguing the investigation diary shows no progress or no genuine need for police custody.
- Point to the 15-day total ceiling, asking whether the grant would exceed it.
- Ask for judicial custody instead, so the accused goes to jail and out of police hands.
- Raise ill-treatment or procedural violations — detention beyond 24 hours without production, denial of counsel, refusal to share the FIR.
One more right sits inside Section 167's proviso: the magistrate is duty-bound to inform the accused of his right to be released on bail when the investigation is not completed within the outer time limits (90 days for serious offences punishable with death, life imprisonment, or 10+ years; 60 days for other offences). This "default bail" is a real, usable right — and for the details of how bail works after custody, see our guide on the bail process in Pakistan.
For readers thinking about getting protection before an arrest ever happens, our guide on pre-arrest bail in Pakistan explains the procedure in advance — because the best remand challenge is the one you never need.
The Right Against Self-Incrimination: You Cannot Be Forced to Confess
Article 13(b) of the Constitution provides that no person, when accused of an offence, shall be compelled to be a witness against himself. Article 14(2) adds that no person shall be subjected to torture for the purpose of extracting evidence.
Read those two together. The accused cannot be forced to confess. He cannot be forced to hand over his passwords, point out the crime scene, or implicate others — at least not through compulsion. Anything said must be voluntary, and the law on confessions is strict precisely because of the power imbalance in a lock-up.
So what does Bilal the shopkeeper actually do when the investigating officer leans across the table and says, "Sach sach bata do, warna remand barha denge"? He says: "I want to consult my lawyer." That is not disrespect. It is Article 10(1) in action. It is also the single safest sentence any accused person in Pakistan can learn.
And Article 10A — the right to a fair trial and due process — blankets the entire process. A trial built on a compelled confession is not a fair trial. Courts know this. The difficulty, always, is proof: what happens inside a lock-up at 2 am has no witnesses. Which is why the earlier rights — counsel access, family meetings, timely production — matter so much. They are the daylight that makes abuse harder.
What the Family Can Actually Do: A Step-by-Step Playbook
Let me lay out what I tell families sitting in my office, in order. If someone you love has been taken into custody:
Step 1: Establish the facts (Day 1). Which police station? FIR number and sections? Name of the investigating officer? Has the accused been produced before a magistrate? Write down the date and time of arrest from your own knowledge — police records sometimes differ, and your timeline matters.
Step 2: Get the FIR copy. The complainant's version is in the FIR. The family is entitled to know it. Our guide on how to file an FIR in Pakistan explains the FIR system from the other side — useful reading so you understand what the police record actually is.
Step 3: Engage counsel immediately and get the Wakalatnama signed. Do not wait for the remand hearing to "see what happens." If the police block a meeting for signing, the lawyer moves the magistrate for an order permitting it. Same day, in writing.
Step 4: Be present at every remand hearing. The lawyer opposes or limits police custody on the record. The accused speaks. Reasons are demanded in writing. Each hearing is a checkpoint — treat it like one.
Step 5: Track the 15-day clock. Mark the calendar. The moment police custody hits its lawful limit, push for judicial custody. Continued police custody beyond the ceiling is unlawful detention, full stop.
Step 6: If access is denied or the person disappears — habeas corpus. Section 491 CrPC and Article 199 of the Constitution give the High Court power to intervene where a person is in unlawful detention. The Hammad Azhar case itself began this way: before the remand, his mother approached the Lahore High Court seeking his recovery when his arrest had not been formally shown. A habeas corpus petition asks the court to have the detainee produced and to examine whether the detention is lawful. It is the emergency brake of the criminal justice system.
Step 7: If the case involves public speech or online content, know the bail landscape. Detentions connected to social media posts, journalism, or online expression increasingly run through special laws. Our explainer on PECA bail for journalists in Pakistan maps that terrain.
Police Custody vs Judicial Custody: Why the Difference Decides Everything
Families often ask me: "Jail bhej dena behtar hai ya thane me rehna?" The answer is almost always: judicial custody is better for the accused.
In police custody, the accused is under the control of the very people investigating him. Interrogation happens. Pressure happens. The lock-up is not designed for anyone's comfort.
In judicial custody, the accused is in jail — Camp Jail Lahore, Adiala, wherever the court sends him — under the jail authorities, not the police. The investigation continues on paper, but the police cannot simply walk in and question him at will. Meetings with family and counsel follow jail rules, which are written, published, and enforceable. The Jail Superintendent route for signing a Wakalatnama — the very route the LHC asked about in the Hammad Azhar hearing — exists precisely because judicial custody has a structure police custody lacks.
A competent lawyer's job at the remand stage is often simply this: get the client out of police custody and into judicial custody as fast as the law allows.
Common Mistakes Families Make (Learn From Others' Regrets)
- Running to the thana instead of the court. Food, blankets, and requests to the SHO feel productive. They are not legal strategy. The magistrate controls custody. The lawyer should be at the court, not just at the police station gate.
- Paying "settlement money" through middlemen. Mere tajurbe me aksar yehi hota hai: a "well-wisher" appears, claims the IO can be managed for Rs. 200,000 or Rs. 500,000, and the family pays in panic. The case continues anyway. The money is gone. Never pay anyone except through proper legal channels, and never without a receipt.
- Waiting to engage a lawyer. "Pehle dekhte hain, phir wakeel karenge." By the time you hire counsel, two remands have been granted unopposed and the 15 days are nearly over. The remand hearing is where the case's direction gets set. Miss it, and you are playing catch-up.
- Not getting the FIR number in writing. Everything downstream — the remand, the bail, the challan — hangs on the FIR. Without the number, sections, and police station, your lawyer is working blind.
- Believing "police ne mana kar diya" is final. A refusal by a constable or SHO is not a court order. It is a fact to be placed before the magistrate. Escalate: written application, then the court.
- Letting the accused talk freely to police without counsel. "Hum ne kuch nahi kiya, hum sab bata denge." Admirable honesty, terrible strategy. Statements made in custody are a minefield. Lawyer first, statements later — and only voluntary ones.
- Ignoring the calendar. Remand dates, the 15-day ceiling, the 90/60-day default bail window — families who track dates get results. Families who don't, get surprises.
Documents and Checklist: What You Need Ready
Keep a file — a physical folder — from day one. It should contain:
- [ ] FIR copy (number, sections, police station, date)
- [ ] Arrest memo / roznamcha entry — date and time of arrest, as you know it
- [ ] Production record — when and before which magistrate the accused was produced
- [ ] All remand orders — get copies from the court; check the reasons recorded in writing
- [ ] Signed Wakalatnama (or the court order permitting its signing)
- [ ] Written record of every denied meeting — date, time, officer's name, witnesses
- [ ] CNIC copies of the accused and of the family members who will visit or file applications
- [ ] Applications filed — copies of everything submitted to the SHO, DPO/CCPO, and the magistrate, with receiving stamps
- [ ] Medical record if there is any allegation of ill-treatment — get an examination noted at the earliest opportunity
- [ ] Calendar marking the 15-day police custody ceiling and remand hearing dates
Aksar log ye ghalti karte hain: they keep everything "in their head" or on WhatsApp. Courts run on paper. A folder with dated copies is worth more than a hundred phone calls.
What About High-Profile Cases? The Law Does Not Have Two Versions
One argument the state made in the Hammad Azhar hearing deserves attention: that a political figure receives numerous visitors, so restrictions are practical. Fair point on its face. But constitutional rights do not shrink with fame, and they do not grow with it either. Article 10(1) belongs to Bilal the shopkeeper exactly as it belongs to a former federal minister. The visitor-management problem is real — police stations are not built for crowds — but the answer to it is regulated access, scheduled meetings, counsel-first priority. Not a closed door.
And here is the sharper question the bench raised: if the state's own procedures (biometric unavailability) make it impossible to challenge remand, then the procedure itself is defeating the right. That observation will matter far beyond this case, whichever way the reserved verdict goes. Because the same logic applies to any accused person anywhere in Pakistan: no procedural technicality can be allowed to cancel a constitutional right.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long can police keep someone in custody in Pakistan? Police must produce an arrested person before a magistrate within 24 hours. After that, the magistrate may authorise police custody (physical remand) up to 15 days in total under Section 167 CrPC. In Anti-Terrorism Act cases, the court may grant police custody of up to 30 days at one time under Section 21-E, with a total ceiling of 90 days. Beyond these limits, the accused must go to judicial custody (jail) or be released.
Does an accused person have the right to meet family in police custody? Yes. Article 10(1) of the Constitution guarantees the right to consult and be defended by a legal practitioner of choice, and the right to family contact during detention is recognised as part of humane treatment and due process. Police rules regulate visits; they cannot impose a blanket ban. If access is refused, the family should record it in writing and move the magistrate or the High Court — as the Hammad Azhar family did before the Lahore High Court in October 2026.
Can an accused sign a Wakalatnama while in police custody? Yes. There is no law forbidding it. If police block the meeting needed for signing, counsel can obtain a court order permitting a meeting in custody for that purpose, or seek the magistrate's direction. In the October 2026 LHC proceedings, the court treated the inability to sign a Wakalatnama as a serious issue affecting the right to challenge remand.
What is the difference between police custody and judicial custody? Police custody (physical remand) keeps the accused at the police station under the investigating agency's control for interrogation. Judicial custody sends the accused to jail, out of police hands. The 15-day police custody ceiling under Section 167 CrPC is total — afterwards, only judicial custody or release is possible.
Can the family challenge a remand order? The remand itself is challenged at the hearing before the magistrate, where the accused or counsel can oppose police custody and demand reasons in writing. If detention is unlawful — beyond 24 hours without production, or beyond the 15-day ceiling — the family can approach the High Court under Section 491 CrPC or Article 199 for habeas corpus.
What should I do in the first 24 hours after someone is arrested? Note the exact time of arrest, identify the police station and FIR number, engage a lawyer immediately, and confirm the accused is produced before a magistrate within 24 hours. Do not let the accused make statements to police without counsel. Keep every document in a dated folder.
Can police refuse to let a lawyer meet the accused? Not lawfully. Article 10(1) makes the right to consult counsel mandatory. If the police station refuses access, put the refusal in writing with date, time, and the officer's name, and place it before the magistrate at the remand hearing or before the High Court.
What if the police deny that they arrested the person at all? This is the "missing person" scenario. The family's remedy is a habeas corpus petition before the High Court under Article 199/Section 491 CrPC, asking the court to order the authorities to produce the detainee and disclose the legal basis of detention. That is exactly how the Hammad Azhar matter first reached the Lahore High Court.
Does the accused have to answer police questions during remand? No. Article 13(b) protects against compelled self-incrimination, and Article 14(2) prohibits torture to extract evidence. The accused may remain silent and should say, "I want to consult my lawyer." Silence is a constitutional right, not an admission of guilt.
What was the Lahore High Court's verdict on Hammad Azhar's family meeting petition? As of the time of writing, the verdict is reserved — the two-member bench headed by Justice Shahbaz Ali Rizvi heard the arguments on 5 October 2026 and reserved its decision. No outcome has been announced yet, and this article will be updated when the judgment is delivered.
The Bottom Line: Practical Mashwara
The Hammad Azhar case put a national spotlight on something ordinary families face quietly every day. Your rights in police custody are not favours the police grant. They are written into the Constitution and the CrPC: counsel of your choice, production within 24 hours, a maximum of 15 days in police hands, reasons in writing, the right to stay silent, and the High Court's door when detention turns unlawful.
The gap between paper and practice is real. Close it the way the system intends: engage counsel on day one, be present at every remand hearing, track the calendar, and put every refusal in writing. And remember Bilal's safest sentence — "I want to consult my lawyer." Four words. Article 10(1). That is where your defence begins.
This article is for general information about Pakistan's criminal law and is not legal advice. Laws and procedures change; consult a qualified advocate for your specific situation.