In family courts across Pakistan, there is a familiar and quietly painful scene. A mother who wants a khula — an end to a broken marriage — is told, sometimes by her own lawyer, sometimes by the husband's side, that the divorce will only go through if she signs a paper agreeing to take less maintenance for her children. Rs10,000 a month instead of Rs40,000. Or nothing at all. "Sign it, and the marriage ends today," she is told. She signs — because she is exhausted, because the pressure to exit feels heavier than the paper in front of her, because everyone around her treats this as the standard deal.

On 3 October 2026, the Lahore High Court declared that this paper is not worth what it claims to be. Child maintenance — nan-nufqa — is the child's absolute right, the court held, and parents cannot reduce or waive it, even by mutual consent. A mother who signs an affidavit accepting a token amount to speed up her khula does not, and cannot, surrender her children's claim. That door — the "sign the affidavit so the marriage ends quickly" shortcut — is now closed, and what it means for thousands of pending and past cases is worth understanding carefully.

Here is the full story of the ruling, the reasoning behind it, and what it changes for mothers, fathers, lawyers, and family courts.


The Case Before the Court

The petition was filed by Shazia Noreen, a divorced mother with custody of two minor children — a girl and her brother. In January 2026, the combined monthly maintenance for the children had been fixed at Rs60,000. But during the divorce proceedings, the mother had signed an affidavit agreeing to a reduced amount and withdrawing other demands — the standard pressure arrangement: accept less, and the divorce goes through without a fight.

When the children's side challenged this arrangement before the Sessions Judge, Sargodha, their appeal was dismissed. The Sessions Court effectively treated the mother's signed affidavit as binding — as though a parent's signature could settle a child's entitlement.

The Lahore High Court reversed that approach entirely. The ruling came from Justice Usman Ghani Rashid Cheema, and it did three things at once:

  • It declared maintenance to be the child's absolute right — not a concession the father grants, and not a term the parents can negotiate away between themselves.
  • It held that neither parents nor guardians possess any authority to surrender, reduce, or bring an end to a minor child's maintenance.
  • It ordered that parental agreements must be tested: the family court must examine whether any agreement between former spouses is genuinely in the best interest of the minors — or whether it infringes on their rights.

The case was sent back to the family court to decide the maintenance afresh, after examining the father's finances — not after reading the parents' agreement. As the judgment put it: "minor children are not our tomorrow, but our today."


What the Court Actually Held: The Three Core Findings

It is worth slowing down on the three findings, because each one does distinct work in practice.

1. Maintenance is the child's absolute right. The court treated the father's duty to maintain his minor children as arising from the parent-child relationship itself, not from any contract, decree, or agreement. The law obliges a father to maintain his children according to his means, and a family court's decree merely quantifies and enforces that pre-existing duty. A right that comes from the relationship cannot be dissolved by a signature on a settlement.

2. Parents cannot surrender what they do not own. This is the heart of the reasoning. Because the right belongs to the child, the parents are not its owners — they are, at best, its custodians and representatives. And you cannot sell, waive, or compromise away what you do not own. A mother who signs an affidavit reducing her children's maintenance is attempting to give away something that was never hers to give. The court said, in effect: your signature binds you; it does not bind your children.

3. Every parental agreement touching maintenance must be judicially tested. The family court is not a rubber stamp. Where former spouses present a compromise deed or affidavit fixing maintenance at a token figure, the court must ask a hard question: is this genuinely in the best interest of the minors, or does it infringe on their rights? If the agreement fails that test, the court must look past it and fix maintenance on the father's real financial capacity and the children's real needs.


Why a Parent Cannot Bargain Away a Child's Right

The logic is simple but reaches far beyond family law. Think of it this way: if you owned a house jointly with your child, you could not sell the child's share to get yourself a quicker divorce. Nobody would accept that. Yet for years, family courts routinely accepted exactly that logic applied to maintenance — a parent trading away a child's monthly entitlement in exchange for a faster dissolution.

Maintenance in Pakistan's family law has a special character. Under the West Pakistan Family Courts Act, 1964, family courts have exclusive jurisdiction over suits for maintenance, and the father's obligation is measured against his means — his income, assets, and lifestyle. The duty exists whether or not anyone files a case; the case only determines the number. That is why a compromise deed fixing maintenance at, say, Rs5,000 a month for two children cannot be treated as a final settlement the way a property division might be. Property can be divided by agreement; a child's right to be fed, clothed, schooled, and housed cannot be.

There is also the question of consent itself. Consent given to escape a bad marriage — signed under the pressure of "agree or the case drags on for two years" — is consent in form only. The Lahore High Court's ruling recognises this reality without needing to prove coercion in every case: it simply takes maintenance off the bargaining table altogether. If it cannot be bargained away, then the pressure to bargain it away loses its point.


Compromise Deeds in Khula: How Courts Treated Them Before — and Now

To appreciate the shift, you need to know how khula settlements worked in practice before this ruling.

The old pattern. When a wife sought khula through the family court, the husband's side often made the dissolution conditional: agree to reduced (or zero) maintenance for the children, withdraw claims for dower or dowry articles, and the khula goes through uncontested. The wife, desperate to end the marriage, signed a compromise deed or an affidavit of surrender. The family court would typically record the compromise as a matter of course — a consent decree — and the reduced maintenance figure became the enforceable amount. For the father, it was a cheap exit. For the children, it was a pay cut they never agreed to.

The new position. After the 3 October 2026 ruling, that settlement architecture is legally unstable:

  • Compromise deeds that fix a token maintenance amount to speed up dissolution can now be challenged. A child — acting through a guardian or next friend — can ask the family court to re-fix maintenance on the father's real means, regardless of what the deed says.
  • Affidavits of surrender signed by mothers during divorce negotiations no longer bind the children's claim. The mother's personal undertakings (about her own dower, her own claims) may still stand, but the children's maintenance is carved out.
  • Khula arrangements remain fully effective for ending the marriage. This is important: the ruling does not invalidate the dissolution. The marriage is over; only the maintenance clause is vulnerable.
  • Family courts must now independently scrutinise any parental agreement touching children's maintenance, instead of recording it as a matter of course. The "consent decree" shortcut for maintenance clauses is, in practical terms, dead.

Practically, divorcing couples — and the lawyers drafting their settlements — should now treat children's maintenance as a separate matter, to be fixed on the father's finances and the children's needs, and not as a bargaining chip in the settlement. A deed that tries to bundle the two is building on sand.


What About Decrees Already Built on Compromise? Can They Be Reopened?

This is the question thousands of mothers will ask: I signed one of those deeds last year. Is it too late?

The short answer is: it is very likely not too late — but the route matters.

Maintenance is a recurring, continuing right, not a one-time claim. A maintenance decree — even a consent decree — fixes what is payable going forward. It does not extinguish the child's underlying right. Family law in Pakistan has always recognised that maintenance can be enhanced when circumstances change: the father's income rises, the children's needs grow, the cost of living climbs. An application for enhancement (often called an increase application) is a standard, well-trodden path.

What the Lahore High Court's ruling adds is a second, stronger ground: the original figure was never lawfully fixed at all, because it rested on a compromise the parents had no authority to make. A guardian can therefore approach the family court to have maintenance re-fixed on the father's actual financial means, arguing both that (a) the earlier figure came from an impermissible waiver, and (b) the children's current needs and the father's current capacity justify a higher amount.

A few practical points on reopening:

  • You do not need to get the whole decree set aside. The khula, the custody arrangement, and the mother's own undertakings can stand. You are asking the court to revisit only the maintenance figure — a routine family-court jurisdiction.
  • Evidence of the father's means is everything. The court in the Shazia Noreen case specifically directed the family court to decide afresh after examining the father's finances. Gather salary slips, bank statements, property records, business evidence, and proof of lifestyle (vehicles, travel, school fees of other children). Maintenance is fixed on capacity, not on his word.
  • Do not delay. Arrears accumulate from the date claimed, and maintenance is for the children's day-to-day needs — school fees, food, medical care. A delayed application is a delayed childhood necessity.
  • Limitation is rarely the barrier it is in other civil claims, because the right is continuing — each month's unpaid or underpaid maintenance is a fresh default. But the sooner the application is filed, the stronger the claim for arrears.

One caution: this ruling is a Lahore High Court judgment. It is binding on family courts and district judiciary within Punjab, and persuasive authority elsewhere in Pakistan. A family court in Sindh or Khyber Pakhtunkhwa is not strictly bound by it, but the reasoning — that a parent cannot waive a child's right — draws on principles recognised across the country's family jurisprudence, and advocates elsewhere can and will cite it.


What Lawyers and Family Courts Must Do Differently Now

For lawyers advising mothers: stop recommending the shortcut. The affidavit that "gets the khula done fast" no longer delivers what it promises — the maintenance clause will not survive a challenge, which means you are advising your client to trade away something for nothing. Draft settlements that keep maintenance separate from the dissolution terms, compute it on real income evidence, and tell the client plainly that any attempt to waive it is unenforceable. In the short run this may make negotiations harder; in the long run it protects the client from signing a paper that humiliates her later, when her children ask why their maintenance was signed away.

For lawyers advising fathers: warn your client that a token-maintenance compromise is now a false economy. A deed fixing Rs5,000 a month may buy an uncontested khula today and a re-fixation application — with arrears — tomorrow. It is cheaper, and safer, to agree a fair figure based on documented means from the start.

For family courts: the ruling imposes an active duty. When a compromise deed or affidavit touching children's maintenance comes before the court, the judge must examine the father's finances and test the agreement against the minors' best interest before recording anything. This means asking for income evidence as a matter of routine, not as an exception. It also means being alert to the power imbalance in khula negotiations — the court is the one institution in the room whose job is to speak for the children.

For guardians and NGOs working with divorced mothers: this ruling is a tool. Many women signed away maintenance believing they had no choice and no remedy. Outreach should carry a simple message: what you signed about your children's maintenance can be challenged — come to the family court.


Enforcing Maintenance Decrees: Practical Reminders

A right the court declares is only as good as its enforcement, and maintenance decrees in Pakistan are notoriously hard to execute. Fathers change jobs, hide income, move assets, or simply refuse to pay. A few reminders, sharpened by a second Lahore High Court ruling handed down days after the first:

Pensions can no longer be used as a shield. On 8 October 2026, a two-member Lahore High Court bench — Justices Malik Waqar Haider Awan and Malik Javid Iqbal Wains — ruled that a pension cannot be attached-proof against a final maintenance decree in favour of minor children. The case involved Muhammad Latif, a retired army official who challenged the family court's attachment of his pension account. The court held that Section 11 of the Pensions Act, 1871 — which bars attachment of pension "at the instance of a creditor" — does not apply, because a child holding a maintenance decree is not a "creditor" in the ordinary sense: the right flows from the father's maintenance obligation, not from any loan or commercial transaction. Nor does the pay protection in Section 171 of the Pakistan Army Act extend to pensions. The executing court was directed to conclude execution within 30 days.

The message is unmistakable, and the two rulings read as a pair: the 3 October judgment protects the amount of maintenance from being bargained away, and the 8 October judgment protects the recovery of maintenance from being hidden behind a pension.

Beyond that, the standard enforcement toolkit remains: attachment of salary (through the employer), bank accounts, and property; warrants where the defaulter wilfully refuses to pay; and — critically — moving the executing court quickly and repeatedly. A decree that sits unenforced for a year teaches the defaulter that defiance works. File for execution promptly, press for attachment orders, and use the pension ruling wherever a retired father claims his pension is untouchable. It is not.


The Bottom Line

The Lahore High Court's 3 October 2026 ruling draws a clean line through one of family litigation's oldest bad habits: a child's maintenance is the child's right, and no parent — however willing, however pressured — can sign it away. Compromise deeds and affidavits that fix token maintenance to speed up a khula can now be challenged and re-fixed on the father's real means; family courts must test every such agreement against the children's best interest; and with the follow-up 8 October ruling, even a pension account is no refuge from enforcement. If you signed one of those deeds in the past, the door to the family court is still open — but walk through it soon, with evidence of the father's means in hand.

This article provides general legal information about the Lahore High Court's October 2026 rulings on child maintenance. It is not legal advice for your specific situation. Family disputes turn on their facts — speak to a qualified family lawyer before acting.