When a child is accused of a crime, the law is supposed to treat them differently from an adult. A 14-year-old who steals, a 16-year-old caught in a fight, a 17-year-old accused of a serious offence — none of them should be handled the way an adult offender is. Pakistan has a special law for this, the Juvenile Justice System Act, 2018, which sets out how children in conflict with the law must be arrested, tried, detained, and — most importantly — rehabilitated. Yet in practice, many children still end up in adult police stations, adult lock-ups, and adult jails, because the people handling their cases do not know the law or do not follow it. This guide explains the juvenile justice system in plain language: who counts as a child, what rights a child has on arrest, how juvenile courts work, and what families can do to protect a child.
Key takeaways
- Under the Juvenile Justice System Act, 2018, a "child" is a person under 18 years of age.
- A child must be dealt with by a Juvenile Court, not an ordinary court, and must not be kept with adult prisoners.
- A child cannot be sentenced to death, and cannot be handcuffed, fettered, or kept in a police lock-up with adults.
- The law prefers diversion — settling the matter without a full trial — and rehabilitation over punishment.
- Families should insist on the child's age being determined properly, on legal aid, and on the presence of a guardian or probation officer at every stage.
Who counts as a child?
The Juvenile Justice System Act, 2018 defines a child as a person who has not attained the age of 18 years. This is the definition that matters for criminal cases. If there is any doubt about a child's age — and there often is, because many children in Pakistan do not have birth certificates — the law requires the age to be determined. The Juvenile Court can order a medical examination, such as an ossification test (an X-ray examination of bone development), and consider school records, birth certificates, and other evidence. The benefit of doubt about age generally goes in favour of treating the person as a child, because the consequences of treating a child as an adult are so serious.
Age determination is often the first battleground in a juvenile case. Police may record an inflated age in the FIR to avoid the juvenile procedure. Families and lawyers should challenge the recorded age at the earliest opportunity, produce the birth certificate, B-Form, or school record, and ask the court to determine age formally. A wrong age recorded at the start can taint the entire case, so this step must not be skipped.
What happens on arrest?
When a child is arrested, the police must follow special rules. The child must be informed of the grounds of arrest in language they understand. The child's parent or guardian must be informed immediately, and a probation officer must be notified. The child must not be handcuffed or fettered, must not be kept in a police station lock-up with adults, and must be produced before the Juvenile Court within 24 hours, as with any arrested person under the Constitution and the Code of Criminal Procedure.
In practice, these rules are frequently violated. Children are kept in police stations, sometimes for days, without their families being told. If this happens to your child, act immediately: go to the police station with the child's age proof, demand to see the child, contact a lawyer, and if necessary, file an application before the Juvenile Court or a habeas corpus petition under Section 491 of the Code of Criminal Procedure for the child's production. The court can order the child's release to a guardian or to a proper observation home.
A child also has the right to legal representation from the very beginning. If the family cannot afford a lawyer, the court is required to provide legal aid at state expense. Do not let a child make a statement to the police without a lawyer and a guardian present. Children are easily frightened into confessions, and a confession made to a police officer is in any case inadmissible in evidence under the Qanoon-e-Shahadat Order, 1984 — but a statement can still harm the case in other ways, and a child should never be questioned alone.
Bail for children
Bail is easier for children than for adults, and the law leans strongly towards release. A Juvenile Court can release a child on bail to a parent, guardian, or a fit person or institution, on a bond. The court considers the child's best interests, not just the seriousness of the offence. Even in serious cases, the court must consider whether detention is truly necessary, and detention in an observation home or borstal institution is preferred over a jail.
If bail is refused by the Juvenile Court, it can be challenged before the Sessions Court or High Court. Families should also know that a child's release on probation — where the child is released under the care of a guardian or probation officer, with conditions — is an option the court can use instead of detention or a sentence. Probation officers play a central role in the juvenile system: they prepare social investigation reports about the child's family, education, and circumstances, and they supervise children released on probation.
Juvenile Courts: how trials work
Cases against children are tried by Juvenile Courts, which are designated courts — usually the Sessions Court or a court specially notified for this purpose — sitting with a different procedure. The trial is held in a separate room or at a separate time from adult trials, and the public and media are generally excluded to protect the child's identity. The child's name, photograph, and identifying details must not be published in the media. This protection of identity is a legal requirement, not a courtesy.
The procedure is designed to be less formal and less intimidating than an adult trial. The judge is expected to explain the proceedings to the child in simple language. The child's guardian and probation officer should be present. The court must consider the child's age, maturity, family circumstances, and the social investigation report before deciding the case and, if the child is found to have committed the offence, before choosing a sentence.
Diversion: settling the case without a trial
One of the most important ideas in the Juvenile Justice System Act is diversion. Diversion means dealing with a child's case outside the formal trial process, where appropriate — for example, through a warning, counselling, community service, or an agreement with the victim's family, supervised by a probation officer or a Juvenile Justice Committee.
Diversion is available mainly for minor offences, and it requires the child's admission of responsibility and the consent of the victim where relevant. Its advantage is enormous: the child avoids a criminal record, avoids detention, and gets help instead of punishment. Families and lawyers should ask the court or the Juvenile Justice Committee about diversion at the earliest stage, especially in first-time and minor cases. A diverted case that is completed successfully should not leave the child with a conviction.
Sentences: what a court can and cannot do
If a child is found guilty after trial, the court's options are limited by law and guided by rehabilitation. The court can release the child on probation, place the child under the care of a guardian or a fit institution, order community service, or, in appropriate cases, send the child to a borstal institution or juvenile rehabilitation centre for a specified period.
Two prohibitions are absolute. A child cannot be sentenced to death, under any circumstances. And a child cannot be sentenced to imprisonment in an ordinary jail with adults. Where detention is ordered, it must be in a juvenile institution — an observation home, a borstal institution, or a rehabilitation centre — separate from adult prisoners. If you learn that a child has been sent to an adult jail, raise it before the court immediately: it is unlawful, and the court can order transfer to a proper institution.
The law also limits the length and nature of detention, and requires periodic review. The emphasis throughout is on education, vocational training, counselling, and family reintegration, not on punishment for its own sake. A child who completes a sentence in a juvenile institution should be supported to return to school or work, not branded for life.
The child's record: does it follow them forever?
A juvenile record is not the same as an adult criminal record. The law provides for the protection of the child's identity and restricts disclosure of juvenile records. In practice, however, police records and FIRs can still surface later — for example, in character verification for a job or a visa — so families should keep copies of all court orders, especially orders of acquittal, discharge, diversion, or release, and should seek legal advice about expungement or record clearance where the law allows. The safest approach is to resolve the case through diversion or acquittal where possible, and to keep the complete case file for the future.
Girls in the juvenile system
Girls in conflict with the law face additional risks: they are fewer in number, so facilities for them are often inadequate, and they may be detained in unsuitable places or mixed with adult women. The law requires separate, appropriate facilities for girls, and female staff for their supervision. Families of a detained girl should insist on these protections, ensure she is not kept in an adult women's barrack, and seek the help of women lawyers, legal aid organisations, and child protection bodies if the facility is unsuitable.
Children as victims and witnesses
The juvenile justice system also concerns children who are victims or witnesses, not only those accused. A child victim of abuse or exploitation is entitled to special protections in court, including in-camera proceedings, a support person, and avoidance of repeated traumatic testimony. If your child is a victim, report the matter to the police and to the provincial child protection authority, and seek a lawyer experienced in child cases. The same principle applies throughout: the system must treat the child as a child first, and as a case second.
What families should do, step by step
First, stay calm and act fast: find out where the child is, and go there with age proof. Second, do not let the child be questioned alone: insist on a lawyer and a guardian being present. Third, challenge the recorded age if it is wrong, and get the court to determine it. Fourth, apply for bail before the Juvenile Court immediately, and ask about diversion if the offence is minor and it is a first offence. Fifth, engage the probation officer: the social investigation report influences bail, diversion, and sentencing. Sixth, keep every document — FIR copy, court orders, bail papers, medical reports — in one file. Seventh, if the child is detained, visit regularly, check the conditions, and complain to the court if the child is kept with adults or mistreated.
Legal aid and help
Many organisations provide free legal aid for children, including provincial legal aid bodies, bar council legal aid committees, and NGOs working on child rights. The court itself must provide a lawyer if the family cannot afford one — ask the judge directly if no lawyer has been appointed. Do not accept the idea that a child must face the system alone because the family is poor: legal aid for children is a legal obligation, not a favour.
Common problems and how to challenge them
The most common problems are: police recording an adult age; detention in a police station or adult jail; no probation officer involved; trial in an ordinary court instead of a Juvenile Court; and publication of the child's identity in the media. Each of these can be challenged before the Juvenile Court, the Sessions Court, or the High Court through revision or a constitutional petition. The High Court has repeatedly emphasised that juvenile protections are mandatory, not optional, and that violations can lead to the child's release and to departmental action against the officials responsible.
A final word
A child who breaks the law is still a child. Pakistan's juvenile justice law recognises this, and it gives children protections that adults do not have: special courts, easier bail, diversion, no death sentence, no adult jail, and a focus on rehabilitation. These protections only work if families, lawyers, and courts insist on them. If a child in your family is in trouble with the law, learn these rights, use them from the first hour, and remember that the goal of the system is not to punish a child into a criminal career, but to guide them back to school, family, and a normal life.
Note: Procedures and institutional arrangements vary by province, and the law is amended from time to time. Confirm the current position with a lawyer practising in juvenile cases in your province. This article is general information, not legal advice for any specific case.
The Bottom Line
This article provides general legal information for readers in Pakistan and is not legal advice. For advice about your own situation, consult a qualified advocate.
