On 30 October 2026, an Anti-Terrorism Court (ATC) in Islamabad sentenced human rights lawyers Imaan Mazari-Hazir and her husband Hadi Ali Chattha to 10 years' imprisonment each, along with a fine of Rs100,000 each. The case concerned the alleged removal of road barriers during the England cricket team's visit to Pakistan in 2024. The case was registered at Aabpara Police Station, Islamabad, and the trial was held inside Adiala Jail, Rawalpindi.
The verdict has drawn strong reactions, including condemnation from Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International. The defence says it will appeal to the Supreme Court. This article explains, in neutral and plain language, what the court decided, what the sentences mean, how an Anti-Terrorism Court trial works, what "concurrent sentences" means, and what happens on appeal — without taking sides on the contested facts, and distinguishing clearly between what the judgment reportedly says, what the defence says, and what remains to be decided by higher courts.
What the court decided
According to reports of the verdict, Judge Tahir Abbas Sipra of the Anti-Terrorism Court, Islamabad, sentenced both Mazari and Chattha to 10 years' imprisonment each and imposed a fine of Rs100,000 on each of them. The court also handed down one-year and two-year terms for obstructing and assaulting public servants. All of the sentences are to run concurrently — a term explained in detail below — so the effective sentence for each person is 10 years, not the sum of all the individual terms.
The judgment reportedly found that the couple's actions put the security of the visiting cricket team at risk and showed intent to create terror. At the same time, the judgment is also reported to have described the incident as an "ordinary" barrier-removal incident. Those two descriptions may appear difficult to reconcile, and readers should note that this article is reporting what has been reported about the judgment; the full text of the judgment, with its complete reasoning, is the authoritative source for what the court actually held and why. Where the full reasoning is not yet publicly available in detail, this article does not fill the gaps with speculation.
The underlying incident, as described in the reports, is the alleged removal of road barriers during the England cricket team's 2024 visit. Security arrangements during visits by foreign cricket teams in Pakistan are extensive, and road barriers and diversions form part of those arrangements. The prosecution case, as reported, was that interfering with those barriers endangered the visiting team's security. The defence position, and the arguments it is expected to raise on appeal, are addressed below. This article does not state the contested facts of the incident as settled beyond what has been reported, because the verdict is now subject to appeal and the higher courts have not yet ruled.
The background: an earlier PECA sentence, suspension, and re-arrest
To understand the context of this verdict, it is necessary to distinguish it from a separate, earlier case involving the same couple.
In January 2026, Mazari and Chattha were sentenced to 10–17 years' imprisonment under the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act, 2016 (PECA), over social media posts. On 17 September 2026, the Supreme Court suspended those sentences and granted them bail. Suspension of a sentence is not an acquittal — a distinction explained in detail below — but it meant they were not required to serve those sentences while the appeal process continued, and they were released on bail.
On the same day, 17 September 2026, they were re-arrested in separate anti-terrorism cases. The 30 October 2026 verdict arises from one of those separate cases — the barrier-removal case registered at Aabpara Police Station — not from the PECA social media case. Keeping the two sets of proceedings separate matters, because they involve different allegations, different charges, and different courts. A development in one case does not automatically decide the other, although the same persons are involved in both.
Readers following the couple's legal position therefore need to track at least two tracks: the PECA case, in which sentences were suspended by the Supreme Court in September 2026, and the anti-terrorism cases, in which the 30 October verdict has now been delivered. Further proceedings may follow in both tracks, and the outcome in one does not determine the outcome in the other.
What is an Anti-Terrorism Court trial?
Anti-Terrorism Courts are special courts established under the Anti-Terrorism Act, 1997 (ATA). They try offences defined under that Act. The ATA was enacted to deal with terrorism and sectarian violence, and it defines terrorism broadly, covering acts — including the use or threat of force — intended to create fear or insecurity, to advance a cause, or to intimidate the government or the public, among other elements set out in the Act. The precise charge in any given case depends on the sections invoked and the facts alleged by the prosecution.
An ATC trial differs from an ordinary criminal trial in several respects, though the fundamental safeguards remain. The accused is presumed innocent until proved guilty, the prosecution must prove its case beyond reasonable doubt, and the accused has the right to be represented by counsel, to cross-examine prosecution witnesses, and to lead defence evidence. ATCs are, however, designed to proceed more expeditiously than ordinary courts, and the ATA contains special provisions on procedure, evidence and sentencing. Trials in ATCs can also be held at locations other than the ordinary courtroom where security or other considerations require it — in this case, the trial was held inside Adiala Jail, Rawalpindi. Holding a trial inside a jail is not unusual in high-profile or security-sensitive cases, but it does raise practical questions about public access and the ability of the defence and observers to attend, which are matters that can be raised on appeal if the defence considers that any unfairness resulted.
For an ordinary reader, the key point is this: an ATC is a court of law, not an executive body. Its verdict is a judicial decision, based on the evidence led before it, and it can be challenged on appeal before higher courts. The fact that a case is tried by an ATC does not mean the ordinary principles of fair trial and appellate review do not apply. They do, and the appeal process is the mechanism by which any errors alleged in the trial are examined.
The charges in general terms
The verdict includes a 10-year sentence, together with shorter terms of one year and two years for obstructing and assaulting public servants. Under the ATA, offences relating to terrorism carry severe punishments, including long terms of imprisonment, and the Act also interacts with offences under the Pakistan Penal Code, such as obstructing a public servant in the discharge of official functions and assaulting a public servant to deter them from duty. The exact sections applied in this case, and the court's reasoning on each, will appear in the full judgment.
It is important to explain, in general terms, what the prosecution must show in a terrorism case. It is not enough, ordinarily, to show that an act occurred — for example, that a barrier was removed. The prosecution must also establish the mental element and the purpose that brings the act within the definition of terrorism under the ATA, such as an intent to create terror or insecurity, or to intimidate. That is why the reported finding about "intent to create terror" matters: it is the element that, in the prosecution case, elevates an act of interference with a security barrier from an ordinary offence into a terrorism offence. Whether that element was proved on the evidence is precisely the kind of question an appellate court will examine.
The defence, conversely, would be expected to argue that the act, even if proved, did not amount to terrorism — that it lacked the requisite intent, that it did not create the kind of danger or insecurity the ATA is aimed at, or that the evidence did not establish the prosecution case beyond reasonable doubt. This article does not adjudicate between those positions. It sets them out so readers understand what is at stake on appeal, and why the same incident can be described in very different terms by different sides.
The reported description of the incident in the judgment as "ordinary" has attracted attention, because it sits alongside the finding of intent to create terror. Without the full judgment, it is not possible to say with certainty how the court reconciled those descriptions, or in what context the word "ordinary" was used. Readers should therefore treat that point as one that the full judgment and the appellate proceedings will clarify, rather than drawing a firm conclusion from a single reported word.
What "concurrent sentences" means
The court imposed several sentences on each person: 10 years as the main term, plus one year and two years for the obstruction and assault charges, and a fine of Rs100,000. The order that all sentences run concurrently is crucial to understanding the actual punishment.
When sentences run concurrently, they are served at the same time, not one after another. The longest sentence therefore determines the total time to be served. In this case, the 10-year term is the longest, so the effective imprisonment for each person is 10 years, with the one-year and two-year terms running within that same period. The fine of Rs100,000 is additional: failure to pay a fine can, under the law, lead to further imprisonment in default, as specified in the sentencing order, though the details of any such provision in this case depend on the full order.
The alternative is consecutive sentences, where each term is served one after the other, so the total is the sum of all the terms. Courts in Pakistan generally order sentences to run concurrently unless there is a reason to order otherwise, particularly where the offences arise from the same incident. The concurrent order here means the couple are not facing 13 years each (10 plus 2 plus 1), but 10 years each, plus the fine.
It is also worth noting that the time already spent in custody during the trial may, under the law, count towards the sentence, subject to the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure and the court's order. The exact calculation of time served, remission, and eligibility for any future relief will depend on the full order and on the rules governing imprisonment, and this article does not attempt to compute a release date.
Suspension of sentence is not acquittal
The September 2026 Supreme Court order in the PECA case is often misunderstood, so the distinction is worth explaining carefully. When a court suspends a sentence pending appeal, it pauses the requirement to serve that sentence while the appeal is heard. The conviction itself is not wiped out, and the accused is not declared innocent. The person is released on bail during the appeal, but the appeal must still be decided. If the appeal succeeds, the conviction may be set aside — that is an acquittal, or at least the removal of the conviction. If the appeal fails, the sentence revives and the person must serve it, subject to any time already served.
The same distinction will apply to any suspension sought in the present case. If the defence applies for suspension of the 10-year sentences pending appeal, and a higher court grants it, that would mean Mazari and Chattha would not have to remain in prison while the appeal is pending. It would not mean they have been acquitted. The appeal itself would still need to be heard and decided on its merits.
This distinction matters for public understanding. Reports that describe a suspended sentence as an acquittal, or a person released on bail pending appeal as "freed" in the sense of exonerated, are misleading. The legal position remains open until the appellate court delivers its judgment.
The appeal route: what happens next
The defence says it will appeal to the Supreme Court. In Pakistan's legal system, the ordinary route for challenging an ATC verdict is an appeal to the High Court — in this case, the Islamabad High Court, since the ATC was in Islamabad — under the Anti-Terrorism Act. A further appeal to the Supreme Court is possible thereafter, subject to the provisions of the law and, in some cases, to leave to appeal being granted. The defence's stated intention to appeal to the Supreme Court may reflect its strategy, the procedural route it considers available, or the forum in which it intends ultimately to seek relief. The precise forum and form of the first appeal will become clear when the appeal is filed, and readers should follow the filing itself rather than assuming the route from the announcement alone.
Whatever the forum, the appeal process follows a familiar pattern. The defence will file an appeal along with a copy of the judgment and the trial record, setting out the grounds on which it says the verdict is wrong. It may also apply for suspension of the sentence and for bail pending the appeal. The appellate court will first consider the interim relief — whether to suspend the sentence and release the appellants on bail while the appeal is heard — and will later hear the main appeal in full, examining the evidence, the trial court's reasoning, and the points of law raised.
An appeal is not a retrial from scratch. The appellate court reviews the trial record, but it can re-examine questions of fact and law, and it has the power to uphold the conviction, to set it aside (acquitting the accused), to reduce the sentence, to order a retrial, or to modify the conviction in other ways permitted by law. The outcome depends on what the record shows and on the arguments made.
What an appeal would argue
Without access to the full judgment and the grounds of appeal when filed, this article cannot list the defence's actual arguments. It can, however, explain the kinds of arguments that are typically raised in an appeal against an ATC conviction, so readers can follow the proceedings intelligently.
First, the appeal may challenge the appreciation of evidence: whether the prosecution witnesses were reliable, whether their accounts were consistent, whether the evidence actually proved that the accused committed the acts alleged, and whether the trial court gave adequate reasons for accepting the prosecution case.
Second, it may challenge the legal characterisation of the act: whether the facts, even if accepted, amount to terrorism under the ATA, or whether they amount only to lesser offences such as obstruction. This goes to the heart of the case, because the 10-year sentence depends on the terrorism finding. If an appellate court holds that the act did not meet the definition of terrorism, the sentence would have to be reconsidered, even if some lesser offence were held proved.
Third, it may raise procedural points: whether the trial was conducted fairly, whether the accused had adequate opportunity to cross-examine witnesses and present a defence, whether the holding of the trial inside Adiala Jail affected fairness or access, and whether any procedural irregularity caused prejudice.
Fourth, it may challenge the sentence itself: whether 10 years is proportionate to the offence as proved, whether the trial court considered mitigating factors, and whether the sentence is consistent with sentences in comparable cases. Sentencing appeals are a recognised part of appellate review, and courts do reduce sentences where they find them excessive, even where the conviction is upheld.
Fifth, it may raise questions about intent and motive: whether the prosecution proved the specific intent required for a terrorism conviction, and whether the evidence supported an inference of intent to create terror as opposed to some other purpose. Intent is often the most contested element in terrorism trials, because it must usually be inferred from conduct and circumstances rather than proved by direct admission.
None of this predicts the outcome. Appellate courts give weight to the trial court's findings, particularly on questions of fact where the trial judge saw and heard the witnesses. An appeal succeeds only if the appellate court is persuaded that the trial court's decision was wrong in law, in its appreciation of evidence, or in a way that caused a miscarriage of justice. The defence will need to make that case on the record.
Reactions and the wider debate
Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International have condemned the verdict. Their statements, as reported, reflect concern about the use of anti-terrorism laws in cases involving lawyers and human rights defenders, and about the proportionality of a 10-year sentence for the conduct alleged. Those organisations are not parties to the case, and their views do not determine its legal outcome, but they form part of the public debate and may be noted by observers and by the appellate courts only to the extent that legal arguments before the court engage with them.
The case also sits within a wider debate in Pakistan about the scope of the Anti-Terrorism Act. Critics of broad terrorism charges argue that the Act should be reserved for genuine terrorism, and that applying it to protests, interference with security arrangements, or other public-order incidents risks disproportionate punishment and a chilling effect on lawful activity. Supporters of the Act's broad application argue that acts which endanger public security, particularly during high-profile events such as a visiting cricket team's tour, must be deterred firmly, and that the courts are the proper forum to decide whether the legal threshold is met. This article does not take a position in that debate. It records that the debate exists, because it explains why the verdict has attracted attention beyond the courtroom.
For readers, the important discipline is to separate three things: what the trial court decided, what critics and supporters say about that decision, and what the appellate courts will decide. Only the third will finally determine the legal outcome. The first is the subject of the appeal; the second is public commentary, however well informed. Conflating them leads to confusion about the status of the case.
Why the venue and timing matter
Two practical features of the case deserve brief explanation. The first is that the trial was held inside Adiala Jail, Rawalpindi. Trials inside jails are held for security reasons or where the accused are already in custody in that jail, and the law permits them. The defence and the prosecution both attend, and the proceedings are judicial proceedings in the same sense as a trial in a courtroom. Questions about access for family members, the media and observers, and about whether the venue affected the fairness of the trial, are matters that can be raised on appeal if the defence considers them relevant.
The second is the timing: the verdict comes weeks after the Supreme Court suspended the couple's PECA sentences and granted bail in September 2026, followed by their re-arrest the same day in separate anti-terrorism cases. That sequence explains why the couple were in custody to face the ATC trial, and why the 30 October verdict has immediate custodial consequences unless the sentences are suspended on appeal. It does not, by itself, prove anything about the merits of either case. Each case must be judged on its own evidence and its own legal basis.
What to watch next
Readers following this case should watch for several developments. The first is the filing of the appeal: the forum, the grounds, and any application for suspension of sentence and bail. The appellate court's decision on interim relief — whether the sentences are suspended pending the appeal — will determine whether Mazari and Chattha remain in custody during the appeal or are released on bail.
The second is the full judgment of the ATC. When it becomes available in full, it will clarify the court's reasoning, including how it approached the question of intent and how it described the incident. That reasoning will shape the appeal, because the appellate court will examine whether it is legally sound and supported by the evidence.
The third is the progress of the separate PECA appeal, in which the Supreme Court suspended the sentences in September 2026. That appeal remains pending on its own track, and its outcome is independent of the ATC appeal, though both involve the same persons.
The fourth is any further proceedings in the other anti-terrorism cases in which the couple were re-arrested in September 2026, if any remain pending beyond the barrier-removal case. The public record, as reported, does not fully detail those cases, and this article does not speculate about them. Readers should rely on court filings and verified reporting for updates.
Until the appellate courts rule, the legal position is as follows: Mazari and Chattha stand convicted by the ATC and sentenced to 10 years each with a fine of Rs100,000 each, with shorter concurrent terms for obstruction and assault; the conviction is subject to appeal; and the defence has said it will appeal to the Supreme Court. That is the position as it stands on 1 November 2026. Anything beyond that — including predictions about the appeal — would be speculation, and this article does not offer it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What does it mean that the sentences run concurrently? A: Concurrent sentences are served at the same time, not one after another. Mazari and Chattha each received a 10-year term plus one-year and two-year terms for obstructing and assaulting public servants. Because all sentences run concurrently, the effective imprisonment is 10 years each — the longest term — plus the fine of Rs100,000 each. If the sentences had run consecutively, they would have added up to 13 years.
Q: Is this the same case as the PECA social media case from January 2026? A: No. In January 2026 the couple were sentenced to 10–17 years under PECA over social media posts. The Supreme Court suspended those sentences and granted bail on 17 September 2026. They were re-arrested the same day in separate anti-terrorism cases. The 30 October 2026 verdict is in one of those separate cases — the alleged removal of road barriers during the England cricket team's 2024 visit, registered at Aabpara Police Station. The two tracks are legally distinct.
Q: Does suspension of a sentence mean acquittal? A: No. Suspension pauses the requirement to serve a sentence while an appeal is pending, and the person is released on bail during that period. The conviction remains in place until the appellate court decides the appeal. Only if the appeal succeeds and the conviction is set aside does the person stand acquitted. If the appeal fails, the sentence revives.
Q: Where does an appeal against an Anti-Terrorism Court verdict go? A: The ordinary route is an appeal to the High Court under the Anti-Terrorism Act, 1997, with a further appeal to the Supreme Court possible thereafter subject to the law. The defence in this case has said it will appeal to the Supreme Court. The precise forum and form of the appeal will be clear when it is filed. The appellate court can uphold the conviction, set it aside, reduce the sentence, or order a retrial, depending on what the trial record shows.
The Bottom Line
This article provides general legal information for readers in Pakistan and is not legal advice. For advice about your own situation, consult a qualified advocate.
