Imagine two of the highest courts in the country disagreeing about who must listen to whom. For most people, that sounds like a problem for lawyers and judges, not for ordinary citizens. But in Pakistan, the question of which court's decisions bind which other courts affects every litigant — because it decides which legal rule will be applied to your case, in whichever court you happen to be standing in. On 5 November 2026, the Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) gave a ruling that goes straight to the heart of that question. In a 16-page judgment, the court held that its observations in judgments and orders that decide a question of law or state a legal principle are binding on all courts in Pakistan — including the Supreme Court.

This guide explains, in plain language, what the court decided, what the words "ratio decidendi" and "obiter dicta" mean, what Article 189 of the Constitution does, why the ruling matters for litigants and lower courts, how it fits into the growing tension between the two apex courts since the 27th Constitutional Amendment, and what remains unresolved.

The Ruling in Brief

On 5 November 2026, a three-member bench of the Federal Constitutional Court, headed by Chief Justice Amin-ud-Din Khan, delivered a judgment authored by Justice Aamer Farooq. The judgment was 16 pages long. Its central holding was this: when the FCC, in a judgment or order, decides a question of law or states a legal principle, that observation is binding on every court in Pakistan — and that includes the Supreme Court itself.

The court said the binding effect covers both kinds of judicial observations: the ratio decidendi, which is the core legal reasoning that decides the case, and obiter dicta, which are the additional legal observations a court makes along the way. Both, the court held, bind all other courts.

The legal basis for the ruling is Article 189(1) of the Constitution, as amended by the 27th Constitutional Amendment. Article 189 is the provision that deals with the binding effect of court decisions. The court read the amended text as placing its own legal determinations above every other court in the country on questions of law and principle.

It is important to be clear about what the court did not do. The ruling does not say that every single word in every FCC order binds every court. The binding effect, as the court described it, attaches to observations that decide a question of law or state a legal principle. That is still a very wide category — most important judgments do exactly that — but the court's own framing ties the binding force to legal reasoning, not to passing remarks about the facts of a particular dispute.

The Case in Which the Point Arose

The constitutional question did not arise in the abstract. It came up in a real dispute about appointments — specifically, two permanent appointments in the Islamabad Capital Territory Private Educational Institutions Regulatory Authority, commonly known as ICT-PEIRA.

The judgment also examined appointments made under the repealed ICT Private Educational Institutions Ordinance of 2009, and the effect of Section 6 of the General Clauses Act 1897. Section 6 is a provision that protects rights acquired under a law that has later been repealed — in simple terms, it says that when a law is taken off the books, things that were lawfully done under it, and rights that were properly acquired while it was in force, are not automatically wiped out. The court referred, in that discussion, to a 2018 decision of the Supreme Court by former Chief Justice Mian Saqib Nisar.

This is a pattern worth noticing. Big constitutional questions in Pakistan often arrive inside ordinary disputes — an appointment, a service matter, a regulatory question — and the court uses the case in front of it to settle a much larger point of law. That is what happened here. A dispute about two appointments in an education regulator became the vehicle for a ruling about the hierarchy of the country's two highest courts.

Ratio Decidendi and Obiter Dicta, in Plain Language

To understand why this ruling is so significant, you need to understand two Latin phrases that lawyers use every day: ratio decidendi and obiter dicta. They sound complicated, but the ideas behind them are simple.

The ratio decidendi — usually shortened to "the ratio" — is the legal reason that actually decides the case. It is the rule the court applies to the facts to reach its conclusion. For example, if a court holds that a particular kind of appointment is unlawful because the law under which it was made had been repealed, the rule about repealed laws is part of the ratio. Future courts dealing with similar facts must follow it. That is the traditional understanding of binding precedent: the ratio binds.

Obiter dicta — usually shortened to "obiter" — are the other legal observations a court makes in a judgment that are not strictly necessary to decide the case. A judge might discuss a wider legal question, explain how a principle would apply in a different situation, or comment on the law more generally. Traditionally, in most common-law systems, obiter is treated as persuasive: later courts should take it seriously and respect it, but they are not strictly bound to follow it.

The 5 November ruling departs from that traditional understanding in a striking way. The FCC held that its obiter dicta, as well as its ratio, bind all courts — including the Supreme Court. In other words, when the FCC states a legal principle in a judgment or order, even in passing, other courts must treat it as binding law, not merely as a helpful suggestion.

Why does that matter? Because judgments are long documents, and judges discuss many legal questions in them. If every legal observation in an FCC judgment binds every court in the country, the FCC's influence over the law becomes very wide indeed. A principle stated in an FCC judgment about, say, appointments, or emergency powers, or the interpretation of a constitutional provision, would have to be followed by the Supreme Court and by every High Court, even if the Supreme Court disagreed with it. That is a far-reaching claim, and it is the reason this ruling has attracted so much attention.

What Article 189 Does

Article 189 of the Constitution is the provision that governs the binding effect of decisions of the apex courts. In its original form, it dealt with the Supreme Court: decisions of the Supreme Court, on questions of law, were binding on all other courts in Pakistan.

The 27th Constitutional Amendment changed the constitutional landscape by creating the Federal Constitutional Court as a separate apex court with jurisdiction over constitutional matters. That raised an obvious question: how does Article 189 now work, with two apex courts instead of one? Which court's decisions bind which other courts?

The FCC's answer, in this judgment, is that Article 189(1), as amended, makes its own legal determinations binding on all courts, including the Supreme Court. The court treated the amended provision as establishing its position at the top of the hierarchy on questions of constitutional law and legal principle.

There is a genuine debate to be had about this reading, and it is important for readers to know that the debate exists. Constitutional provisions about court hierarchies are often written in language that leaves room for more than one interpretation. The Supreme Court has not yet, as far as has been publicly reported, responded to this ruling. Until it does — or until the two courts find a way to work out the relationship between them — the FCC's reading stands as the FCC's own statement of its authority, rather than as a settled position agreed by both courts.

The One-Way Hierarchy: Two Rulings in Three Days

The 5 November ruling cannot be understood on its own. It must be read together with another FCC ruling given just three days earlier, on 2 November 2026.

On 2 November, the same court held that judgments of the Supreme Court are only persuasive — not binding — on the FCC. In other words, the FCC said it would treat Supreme Court judgments as arguments worth considering carefully, but not as orders it must obey.

Read together, the two rulings create a one-way hierarchy. The FCC's legal observations bind the Supreme Court, but the Supreme Court's judgments do not bind the FCC. The FCC sits above the Supreme Court on questions of law, but the Supreme Court does not sit above the FCC.

This is an unusual arrangement, and it is worth pausing to understand why it is unusual. In most legal systems, binding precedent flows downwards: a higher court binds a lower court, and courts at the same level generally respect each other's decisions, even if they are not strictly bound by them. What is rare is for one apex court to declare itself binding on another apex court while declaring itself free of the other's decisions. That is what the FCC has done in these two rulings, and it is why lawyers and commentators are watching the relationship between the two courts so closely.

The Tension Since the 27th Amendment

The 27th Constitutional Amendment created the FCC and redrew the map of Pakistan's superior judiciary. Since then, the relationship between the new court and the Supreme Court has been a live question. Who decides constitutional cases? Who has the last word when the two courts disagree? What happens if the Supreme Court reaches one conclusion on a constitutional question and the FCC reaches another?

These are not abstract questions. They affect real cases and real people. A litigant who wins in the High Court may find the matter taken to the FCC. A person challenging a detention, an appointment, or a government action needs to know which court can give them a final answer, and whether that answer will be respected by other courts.

The 5 November ruling is the FCC's clearest statement so far of its view: on questions of law and legal principle, its word is final and binding on everyone, including the Supreme Court. The ruling also shows that the court is prepared to state that position plainly, in a written judgment, rather than leaving it to be inferred.

For now, the position is one-sided. The FCC has stated its view of the hierarchy. The Supreme Court has not published a response. It may do so in a future case, or the two courts may develop a working understanding through their decisions over time. Until then, there is uncertainty — and uncertainty about which court has the last word is itself a problem for litigants, because it can mean more litigation, more delay, and more expense before a dispute is finally settled.

Also on 5 November: The Peshawar High Court and 3-MPO Cases

The same day, 5 November 2026, the FCC also passed an order barring the Peshawar High Court from hearing cases about arrests under Section 3 of the Maintenance of Public Order Ordinance in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. That order, which suspended several PHC orders and adjourned the matter indefinitely, is dealt with in detail in a separate article on this site.

The two developments on the same day are connected in an important way. The order restraining a High Court from hearing a class of cases is itself an exercise of the authority the FCC claimed in its binding-observations ruling. The court is not only saying that its legal principles bind other courts; it is also, in practice, directing what other courts may and may not hear. For readers following events in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, where the province has been under emergency and governor's rule since 11 October 2026, the combination of the two developments on one day is significant.

What This Means for Litigants

For an ordinary person with a case in court, what difference does this ruling make? Several things are worth knowing.

First, if your case involves a question of law on which the FCC has stated a principle, the court hearing your case — whether it is a High Court, a district court, or the Supreme Court — is now, according to the FCC, bound to follow the FCC's position. Your lawyer will need to be aware of FCC judgments, not only Supreme Court judgments, when advising you on the strength of your case.

Second, the ruling makes FCC judgments even more important as a source of law. Lawyers and litigants will now study FCC orders closely, including the observations made along the way, because those observations may bind the court deciding their case. This raises the stakes of every FCC judgment: a principle stated in passing could shape cases far beyond the dispute in which it was made.

Third, the one-way hierarchy may affect how cases are argued. A party that has an FCC observation in its favour will argue that the observation binds the court. A party that has a Supreme Court judgment in its favour, but faces an FCC observation going the other way, will find that the Supreme Court judgment counts only as persuasive before the FCC. The balance of authority has shifted, and litigation strategy will shift with it.

Fourth, there may be a period of uncertainty. Because the Supreme Court has not yet responded, and because the relationship between the two apex courts is still being worked out, a litigant may face arguments in court about whether the FCC's reading of Article 189 is correct. That uncertainty may itself generate more cases, as parties test the boundaries of the ruling.

What This Means for the Lower Courts

For High Courts and district courts, the ruling adds a new layer of binding authority. Judges in the lower courts already follow the Supreme Court's decisions on questions of law. They must now also follow the FCC's legal observations — including its obiter dicta — and, where the two conflict, the FCC's position is the one that prevails, according to the FCC's own ruling.

That is a demanding position for a lower-court judge. Judgments of the FCC will need to be read carefully, and the judge will need to decide which observations in a judgment state a legal principle and which do not. The ruling ties binding force to observations that "decide a question of law or state a legal principle", so judges will have to draw that line in practice, case by case.

It also matters for the day-to-day work of the courts. Where a High Court was previously free to treat an FCC observation as helpful but not binding, it must now treat it as the law. That could change the outcome of cases in areas where the FCC has spoken — service matters, appointments, emergency powers, and constitutional interpretation among them.

What Remains Unresolved

It is important to be honest about what this ruling does not settle.

The first unresolved question is the Supreme Court's response. No Supreme Court response to this ruling has been published yet. The Supreme Court may agree with the FCC's reading, disagree with it, or address it indirectly in a future case. Until that happens, the hierarchy the FCC has described is the FCC's own view, not a position both apex courts have accepted.

The second unresolved question is how the binding effect of obiter dicta will work in practice. The traditional distinction between ratio and obiter exists precisely because judges write long judgments that discuss many things. If every legal observation binds, courts and lawyers will need to develop a way of identifying which statements in a judgment count as legal principles and which are merely passing comments. That work has not yet been done, and different courts may draw the line differently.

The third unresolved question is what happens in a direct conflict. If the FCC states a legal principle and the Supreme Court later states the opposite principle, which one governs? The FCC's rulings of 2 and 5 November point to the same answer: the FCC's view prevails. But that answer has been given by the FCC itself, and the Supreme Court has not yet had its say. A genuine conflict between the two apex courts would be a serious constitutional moment, and it has not yet happened in this form.

The fourth unresolved question is the practical one: how quickly will the lower courts adjust? Court systems change slowly. Judges, lawyers, and court staff will need time to absorb the new hierarchy, to build FCC case law into their research, and to change habits formed over decades under a single apex court. During that transition, there may be inconsistent decisions while the new arrangement settles.

Practical Takeaways

If you are a litigant, a lawyer, or simply a citizen following constitutional developments, these are the points to carry away from the 5 November ruling.

First, the FCC has now stated, in the clearest terms yet, that its legal observations — both ratio and obiter — bind all courts in Pakistan, including the Supreme Court, under Article 189(1) as amended by the 27th Amendment.

Second, read together with the 2 November ruling that Supreme Court judgments are only persuasive on the FCC, the two decisions create a one-way hierarchy with the FCC at the top on questions of law.

Third, the ruling arose from a dispute about two permanent appointments in ICT-PEIRA and involved questions about appointments under a repealed 2009 ordinance and the protection of rights under Section 6 of the General Clauses Act 1897 — a reminder that landmark constitutional points often arrive inside ordinary disputes.

Fourth, for your own case, make sure your lawyer is following FCC judgments as well as Supreme Court judgments. A legal principle stated by the FCC may now decide your case, even if your case is being heard in another court.

Fifth, expect a period of uncertainty. The Supreme Court has not yet responded publicly, and the practical questions — how to identify binding obiter, and what happens in a direct conflict — have not yet been answered. If your case turns on a point where the two apex courts might disagree, get advice on the current position before you act, and keep an eye on new judgments from both courts.

Finally, remember that constitutional arrangements are not fixed forever. The 27th Amendment created a new court, and the courts are still working out what that means. The 5 November ruling is a major step in that process, but it is a step, not the end of the story.

A Note on This Article

This article is general information about a court ruling and the constitutional questions around it. It is not legal advice, and it is not a substitute for advice from a qualified lawyer about your own case. Court rulings can be interpreted in different ways, the Supreme Court has not yet responded to this ruling, and the law in this area is still developing. If your rights or your case are affected by the issues discussed here, consult a lawyer who can advise you on the facts of your own matter.