On 16 October 2026, the Lahore High Court did something remarkable. It set aside a life sentence for murder — not because of a technicality, but because the prosecution's own CCTV video contradicted its own eyewitnesses. In Raja Shahid v. The State (Criminal Appeal No. 27357 of 2024, reported as 2026 LHC 7319), Justice Muhammad Amjad Rafiq decided the appeal and, in the process, answered six big legal questions about CCTV footage as evidence in Pakistan: when such footage is admissible, how it must be put to the accused (that is, formally shown and confronted with him during trial under Section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure), whether blurry footage can be "enhanced", whether the court can visit the crime scene, and whether a conviction can rest on video alone.

The judgment has been approved for reporting, which means it will be published in the official law reports and cited in criminal trials across Punjab and beyond. If you run a shop, own a business with cameras, or were simply present when a crime was caught on a street camera, this ruling directly affects how your footage — or the footage that involves you — will be treated in court.

This article explains the case, the six questions, and what the answers mean for ordinary people in plain language.

The Case: A Murder Trial Where the Camera Disagreed With the Witnesses

The story began with FIR No. 2162/2022, registered on 19 September 2022 at Police Station Mughalpura, Lahore, under Sections 302 (punishment for murder), 394 (voluntarily causing hurt in committing robbery), 34 (common intention), and 109 (abetment) of the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC).

According to the prosecution, on 18 September 2022 the victim was picked up from his house on a motorcycle. In front of the appellant Raja Shahid's house, a co-accused allegedly raised a lalkara (a verbal challenge or call to attack), after which the appellant fired repeatedly at the victim's head. The victim's motorcycle, phone, and purse were then taken. The alleged motive was a quarrel that had taken place three days earlier. The trial court believed the eyewitnesses and, on 30 March 2024, convicted Raja Shahid under Section 302(b) PPC, sentencing him to life imprisonment along with Rs. 300,000 in compensation to be paid to the victim's family. His co-accused were acquitted.

The problem was the street CCTV camera. Its footage had been played at the trial. But none of the prosecution's eyewitnesses appeared anywhere in the video. The only person seen arriving was a young girl who reached the spot about three minutes after the attackers had left. The shooter's face was not clearly visible. The trial court made no comparison of the shooter's build or features with the accused, and in the appellant's statement under Section 342 CrPC (the stage at which the accused is confronted with the evidence against him and given a chance to explain), the video was dealt with in a single general question.

On appeal, the Lahore High Court heard the case on 9, 22, and 28 September 2026. Rather than deciding only on the trial's defects, Justice Rafiq framed six questions of law and appointed Ms. Sheeba Qaiser (Additional Sessions Court judge level counsel, appearing as amicus curiae — a friend of the court who assists with the legal questions) and Mr. Naveed Umar Bhatti, the Deputy Prosecutor General, as amici. The Prosecutor General Punjab and the Director General of the Punjab Forensic Science Authority (PFSA) also assisted the court. The judgment was signed on 16 October 2026. The appeal was allowed: the conviction was set aside, and Raja Shahid was acquitted on the benefit of doubt.

Question 1: When Is CCTV Footage Admissible in Court?

The first question was the most fundamental: what is the minimum legal requirement for admitting PFSA-certified, untampered footage from a privately installed CCTV camera?

Before 2023, Article 164 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order 1984 (the QSO — Pakistan's main law of evidence) allowed the court to admit "any evidence that may have become available because of modern devices or techniques." This was the provision lawyers used to bring video, audio, and other electronic evidence into court.

In 2023, Article 164 was amended. The new wording focuses on evidence or witnesses recorded by the Court through modern devices such as video calls, WhatsApp, Skype, or video conferences. The Lahore High Court observed that this shifts the focus from "admissibility of technology-generated evidence" to "recording of evidence through technology." In other words, Article 164 now operates mainly as a procedural provision, not as the door through which video enters the courtroom.

So where does admissibility come from now? The court pointed to several sources:

  • The Electronic Transactions Ordinance 2002 (ETO): Under Section 3 of the ETO, no document can be denied admissibility merely because it is in electronic form. The Ordinance's definition of "information" includes video.

  • Article 46A QSO: electronic statements are treated as relevant facts.

  • Article 73 QSO: an electronic document counts as primary evidence (that is, the original and best form of evidence, as opposed to a secondary copy) if the information system was in working order — a fact which is presumed unless shown otherwise.

  • Article 78A QSO: if the genuineness of the electronic document is denied, the security procedure used must be proved.

In plain terms: CCTV footage is documentary (electronic) evidence. It does not sneak in through Article 164's old wording. It enters the courtroom as an electronic document under the ETO and the QSO's provisions on electronic records.

But the court laid down a practical requirement: the footage must be produced through a relevant witness. That means someone must take the witness stand and say where the camera was, who operated it, how the footage was extracted, and what it shows. The footage must be put to witnesses so they can explain the identity of the people in it and the circumstances it depicts (including under Article 22 QSO, which deals with facts establishing identity, where that is attracted). And — crucially — it must be put to the accused under Section 342 CrPC. Where the authenticity of the footage is disputed, the court said the guidelines laid down by the Supreme Court in Ishtiaq Ahmed Mirza v. Federation of Pakistan (PLD 2019 SC 675) must be followed. That Supreme Court decision sets the test for proving the genuineness of electronic and digital evidence.

Question 2: What Does Section 342 CrPC Require — and Why Does a General Question Fail?

Section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) is one of the most important safeguards in a criminal trial. After the prosecution finishes its evidence, the court must question the accused about the evidence on record, so he can explain anything that goes against him. This is the accused's chance to answer — and anything he says here becomes part of the record.

The Lahore High Court held that when CCTV footage is on record, the incriminating parts of the footage must be specifically put to the accused. A vague, omnibus question such as "What do you say about the video evidence?" is not enough. The judge must confront the accused with the specific frames, actions, and circumstances shown in the video — "This video shows a man in black shalwar kameez firing at the deceased at this spot; what do you say?" — so the accused genuinely understands the case against him and can respond.

Why does this matter? In Raja Shahid's case, the trial court had asked only one general question about the video. On appeal, that defect became a serious problem for the prosecution. For defence lawyers, this is now a clear ground of appeal: if the trial court failed to confront your client with each incriminating part of the footage, the trial procedure was defective.

Question 3: Can the Appellate Court Fix What the Trial Court Missed?

Yes — the High Court said so. Where the trial court did not follow the proper procedure, the appellate court (the court hearing the appeal) may summon the witnesses and the accused to fill the gap.

The court drew a useful distinction:

  • Clarifying what is already on record: If the footage was already admitted at trial and the appellate court only wants to ask the witnesses or the accused what is seen in it, that is not "additional evidence" under Section 428 CrPC. It is merely an inquiry to understand facts already observed. The trial court's omission can therefore be cured this way without reopening the whole prosecution case.

  • Footage that was never collected: If relevant footage was never taken into custody or brought on record, the court may summon it under Sections 428, 94, and 540 CrPC. The High Court may record the evidence itself, or direct a Magistrate or Court of Session to record it, and may issue a search warrant under Section 96 CrPC to trace the footage.

On the mode of recording, the court referred to Section 365 CrPC and the Lahore High Court Rules and Orders (Volume V, Chapter 4, Part I-A): the judge may make a memorandum (a written summary) of the substance of the evidence, or have it taken down in shorthand by an officer of the court.

The practical warning here is for the defence. In this very case, on 28 September 2026 the appellant and two prosecution witnesses were called before the High Court and shown the footage. The appellant identified the house as his own, said the shooter in black shalwar kameez was a co-accused who had already been acquitted, and — importantly — admitted that he had kicked the victim after he fell, claiming he did not know the victim had been shot. The two witnesses named the appellant as the shooter but admitted they did not appear in the video.

So the cure has a price: once the accused is called before the appellate court and confronted with the footage, his answers become evidence. Here the appellant admitted his presence at the scene and the kick. Defence counsel must prepare clients very carefully for this stage.

Question 4: Can Blurry CCTV Footage Be "Enhanced"?

CCTV footage is often grainy, dark, or shot from a distance. Can the prosecution ask an expert to "enhance" it — to zoom in, sharpen, and make the face identifiable? The court said yes, but with strict conditions.

Enhancement techniques such as contrast, brightness, and gamma adjustment, histogram equalisation, super-resolution, sharpening and deconvolution, noise reduction, interpolation, and frame averaging can be used. But — and this is the DG PFSA's key point, which the court accepted — enhancement can only reveal what already exists in the recording. It cannot create new detail that was never captured. If the face was never recorded, no software can truthfully produce it.

Because enhancement requires specialised equipment, validated methods, and documented procedures, the court held it must be done in a forensic laboratory (such as the PFSA), not by an expert performing tricks live in the courtroom. The processed output is then played before the court.

Two related points from the judgment matter here:

  1. The court may itself compare. Where image quality allows, the judge may personally compare the video with the accused in open court — what the court called a "trier-of-fact comparison." The court drew support from the reasoning behind Article 84 QSO (which allows comparison of handwriting, signatures, and fingerprints) and the English case Parish v. R (2021 EWCA Crim 1693). If the judge's own comparison is inconclusive, the court may direct the PFSA to carry out forensic facial comparison, gait analysis (identification from the way a person walks), clothing comparison, photogrammetry (measurements from photographs), body morphology (body shape analysis), behavioural analysis, or voice analysis.

  2. The PFSA needs more tools. The PFSA told the court that gait analysis, photogrammetry, and body-morphology analysis are not yet available with it. The court therefore directed the Government of the Punjab to equip the PFSA with these techniques. Until that happens, a court may refer footage to a competent international forensic laboratory at the parties' expense, with proper safeguards for the integrity and chain of custody of the material.

Question 5: Can the Court Visit the Crime Scene?

The fifth question concerned Section 539B CrPC, which allows a judge to personally inspect the place of occurrence. The court held that this power is personal to the court and cannot be delegated to someone else — relying on the Supreme Court's decision in Asfandyar v. Kamran (2016 SCMR 2084). However, the High Court may exercise the power at the appellate stage.

Accepting the Deputy Prosecutor General's suggestion, the court added that when it sits as an appellate criminal court, it may — exceptionally, and for reasons recorded in writing — direct further investigation or appoint a person or a commission to inspect the scene, using its powers under Section 423 CrPC and its inherent powers under Section 561A CrPC (the High Court's inherent power to do what is necessary to secure the ends of justice). This must not become a back-door way of delegating the Section 539B function or a way around the safeguards of investigation.

In practice: a judge cannot send an assistant to look at the scene instead of going himself, but the appellate court has limited room to order a fresh look when justice requires it.

Question 6: Can a Conviction Rest on Video Alone?

Yes — in principle. The court relied on the "silent witness" doctrine endorsed by the Supreme Court of Pakistan in Zahir Zakir Jaffar v. The State (PLD 2026 SC 251), under which authenticated footage can "speak for itself." It also recognised the business-records idea under Articles 46(2) and 48 QSO and the Explanations to Article 73 QSO: footage from, for example, a public office's CCTV system, with system logs and metadata showing the date, time, and location, satisfies the requirements for electronic documents.

But video is circumstantial evidence, so the full chain must be proved. A conviction on footage alone is safe only when three conditions are met:

  1. The footage's quality reliably identifies the accused;

  2. Its integrity is established — where genuineness is disputed, through a PFSA report confirming it has not been tampered with or edited; and

  3. Together with the surrounding circumstances, the video excludes every reasonable hypothesis except the guilt of the accused.

If the face cannot be identified and enhancement fails, the footage cannot fill the gap on the basis of suspicion. The benefit of doubt goes to the accused — the court cited Muhammad Ramzan v. The State (2025 SCMR 1742) for this. As the court put it, the decisive question is not whether the eyewitnesses appear in the frame, but whether the video forms an authentic, complete, and conclusive chain of guilt.

The core lesson: cameras don't lie, but they don't always tell the whole story either. Blurry footage plus shaky eyewitnesses equals reasonable doubt — and reasonable doubt means acquittal.

How the Appeal Was Decided

When the High Court called the appellant and the witnesses on 28 September 2026 and played the footage, the contradictions became impossible to ignore:

  • The witnesses said the shooter stayed at the scene threatening them, but the video showed the man in black did not linger.

  • At trial the witnesses said the appellant escaped as the pillion rider (the passenger on the back of the motorcycle), but the video showed the pillion rider was the shorter man in a shirt and trousers.

  • The post-mortem report showed only two through-and-through wounds to the head, inflicted while the victim was still on the motorcycle — with no injury from shots allegedly fired after he fell.

Making its own trier-of-fact comparison, the court noted that the appellant's stature resembled the shorter man who kicked the victim, not the shooter. Still, it held that a partial admission and general physical similarity, without expert facial comparison or strong corroboration, could not prove murder beyond reasonable doubt. Since one reasonable doubt is enough in a criminal case, the appeal was allowed. Raja Shahid was acquitted and ordered to be released, if not required in any other case.

The tragedy — and the warning — of the case is that the footage helped neither side: it destroyed the eyewitness account, but it was too unclear to convict on its own.

How CCTV Footage Must Be Collected and Proved

Drawing the judgment together with established practice, here is how CCTV footage should travel from the camera to the courtroom:

  1. Seize early. The police should take the footage into custody immediately, with a recovery memo (a written record of what was seized, from where, and from whom). Most DVR/NVR systems overwrite footage within days — a delay can destroy the evidence permanently.

  2. Keep the chain of custody. Every hand that touches the footage — the camera owner, the person who extracted it, the police officer, the forensic analyst — must be documented. Gaps in this chain are exactly what defence lawyers attack.

  3. Hand over originals. The camera's DVR (the recording device) or an exact copy should be handed to the police against a written receipt. The video should be produced on a USB drive or CD/DVD in court through a witness who operated or was responsible for the system.

  4. Don't edit, crop, or compress. Adding captions, cutting clips, or forwarding the video through WhatsApp as the only copy damages its evidential value, because compression alters the data and editing destroys the claim that the footage is untampered.

  5. Get a forensic report. Where genuineness is disputed, a PFSA report confirming that the footage has not been tampered with or edited is essential.

  6. Put it to witnesses and the accused. The footage must be shown to the eyewitnesses during their examination and, frame by frame where relevant, to the accused in his Section 342 CrPC statement.

  7. Request enhancement before trial ends. Where faces are unclear, the prosecution should request PFSA enhancement and forensic facial or clothing comparison before the trial closes — not afterwards.

Practical Tips for Victims and Businesses

If a crime was captured by a camera at your home, shop, office, or street, what you do in the first hours can decide the case:

  • Act fast. Most systems overwrite footage within days. Ask the camera owner to preserve it immediately — do not let the system keep recording over it.

  • Keep the original. Hand the DVR or an exact copy to the police against a written recovery memo. Keep your own backup if possible, but the original belongs in police custody.

  • Do not edit it. No captions, no cropping, no "improving" it yourself, and no sending it around on WhatsApp as your only copy. Compression and editing destroy its evidential value.

  • Note who, when, and how. Write down the camera owner's name, the system's location, the date and time settings on the device, and who extracted the footage. These people may be needed as witnesses to prove the video is genuine.

  • Insist on forensic examination. A PFSA report on authenticity — and enhancement where needed — strengthens the case and answers the defence's questions before they are asked.

  • Tell the truth about what you saw. The sharpest warning of this judgment: if the camera shows you were not at the spot, claiming to be an eyewitness can destroy the entire prosecution. In Raja Shahid's case, the witnesses' absence from the video was fatal to the prosecution's case.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is CCTV footage admissible as evidence in Pakistani courts? A: Yes. After the 2023 amendment to Article 164 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order 1984, admissibility flows from the Electronic Transactions Ordinance 2002 (Section 3) and Articles 46A, 73, and 78A of the QSO. CCTV footage is treated as documentary (electronic) evidence — an electronic document that must be produced through a witness and proved according to the rules for electronic records. If its genuineness is disputed, the Supreme Court's guidelines in Ishtiaq Ahmed Mirza v. Federation of Pakistan (PLD 2019 SC 675) apply.

Q: What is Section 342 CrPC, and what does it require in a CCTV case? A: Section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure requires the court, after the prosecution evidence closes, to question the accused about the evidence on record so he can explain it. In a CCTV case, the Lahore High Court has held that every incriminating part of the footage must be specifically put to the accused — not in one vague question like "what do you say about the video evidence?", but frame by frame where relevant. A general question is a defect that can become a ground of appeal.

Q: Can the police take footage from my private home or shop camera? A: Yes. The police can request and take custody of footage relevant to an investigation, and under the principles discussed in the judgment, the appellate court can even order footage that was never collected to be summoned under Sections 428, 94, and 540 CrPC, including through a search warrant under Section 96 CrPC. Cooperate, keep the original safe, and get a written receipt when you hand it over.

Q: Can blurry CCTV footage be enhanced to identify a face? A: Yes, but only by experts in a forensic laboratory such as the Punjab Forensic Science Authority (PFSA), using techniques like contrast adjustment, super-resolution, and noise reduction. Enhancement cannot be done live in the courtroom by an expert with a laptop. And it can only reveal what the recording already contains — it cannot create detail that was never captured. Where the PFSA lacks a technique (such as gait analysis or photogrammetry), the court may refer footage to a competent international laboratory at the parties' expense.

Q: Can the judge compare the video with the accused himself? A: Yes. The judgment recognises a "trier-of-fact comparison": where image quality allows, the judge may personally compare the footage with the accused in open court, by analogy with Article 84 QSO (comparison of handwriting and signatures). If that comparison is inconclusive, the court may order forensic facial, clothing, gait, or voice comparison by the PFSA.

Q: Can someone be convicted only on the basis of CCTV footage, with no eyewitnesses? A: In principle, yes. Under the "silent witness" doctrine recognised by the Supreme Court in Zahir Zakir Jaffar v. The State (PLD 2026 SC 251), authenticated footage can speak for itself. But the prosecution must prove the full chain: the footage must reliably identify the accused, its integrity must be established (a PFSA report confirming no tampering, where disputed), and it must exclude every reasonable hypothesis except guilt. If the face cannot be identified, suspicion is not enough — the benefit of doubt goes to the accused.

Q: What should I do if my shop's camera recorded a crime? A: Preserve the footage immediately (systems often overwrite within days), hand the DVR or an exact copy to the police against a written recovery memo, do not edit, crop, or compress the video (avoid WhatsApp as your only copy), note the names of the people who operated the system, and ask for the footage to be sent to the PFSA for an authenticity report. If you saw the incident yourself, tell the truth — the judgment shows that a false eyewitness claim which the video contradicts can destroy the whole case.

Q: Can a court visit the crime scene to understand the footage? A: Yes. Under Section 539B CrPC, a judge may personally inspect the place of occurrence, and the Lahore High Court confirmed this power is personal to the court and cannot be delegated (following Asfandyar v. Kamran, 2016 SCMR 2084). At the appellate stage, the court may also order further investigation or a scene inspection by a person or commission, exceptionally and for recorded reasons, under Section 423 and its inherent powers under Section 561A CrPC.

The Bottom Line

The Lahore High Court's judgment in Raja Shahid v. The State (2026 LHC 7319) is the most detailed guidance Pakistani courts have given on CCTV footage in criminal trials. It tells us that video is documentary electronic evidence that must be produced through witnesses, proved like any electronic record, and confronted with the accused point by point under Section 342 CrPC. It tells us that blurry footage may be enhanced, but only in a forensic laboratory — software cannot invent what the camera never saw. It confirms that a judge may compare the video with the accused himself, and that a conviction can rest on video alone, but only when the footage is authentic, identifies the accused, and leaves no other reasonable explanation.

For ordinary citizens, the message is practical: preserve your footage, keep it original, hand it over with a receipt, get it examined forensically — and never claim to have seen with your own eyes what the camera proves you did not. One man's life sentence was set aside because the video did not match the witnesses. In the age of cameras on every street, the truth the lens records will always, eventually, come out in court.

This article provides general legal information for readers in Pakistan and is not legal advice. For advice on a specific criminal case, consult a qualified advocate.