IN THE COURT OF [District Judge, Lahore / Lahore High Court / Civil Judge, __________]
Review Application No. ______ of 20___
In
Civil Suit / Appeal / Revision No. ______ of 20___
[Full name of Applicant], son/daughter/wife of [________], resident of [complete address], CNIC No. [________]
... Applicant / Petitioner / Plaintiff / Defendant
VERSUS
[Full name of Respondent], son/daughter/wife of [________], resident of [complete address], CNIC No. [________]
... Respondent
APPLICATION FOR REVIEW OF JUDGMENT / ORDER DATED [DD-MM-YYYY] UNDER ORDER XLVII READ WITH SECTION 114 OF THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
May it please this Honourable Court:
The Applicant respectfully submits as under:
### 1. Facts of the case
1.1. The Applicant is the [plaintiff / defendant / appellant / respondent] in the above-titled proceedings, which relate to [briefly describe the subject matter, e.g., recovery of Rs [________], declaration of title in respect of property measuring [________] situated at [________], possession, injunction, etc.].
1.2. The [suit / appeal / revision] was instituted on [DD-MM-YYYY] and, after recording of evidence and hearing arguments, was decided by this Honourable Court vide judgment and decree / order dated [DD-MM-YYYY], hereinafter referred to as the "impugned judgment."
1.3. The operative part of the impugned judgment is as under: [reproduce the decree or the relevant paragraph of the order in quotation, exactly as it appears in the certified copy].
1.4. The Applicant received the certified copy of the impugned judgment on [DD-MM-YYYY], as evidenced by the copy application and the endorsement on the certified copy annexed herewith as Annexure "A".
1.5. [Set out, in chronological order, the material facts of the original proceedings: the claim made, the defence raised, the issues framed, the evidence led, and the findings recorded. Keep this section factual and short — do not re-argue the whole case. The purpose is to orient the Court so that the grounds of review can be understood without re-reading the entire file.]
1.6. [Describe the specific development or discovery that has given rise to this review application. For example: "On [DD-MM-YYYY], the Applicant discovered the document annexed as Annexure 'B', namely [describe the document — a registered sale deed, a mutation entry, a bank statement, a court record, a government notification, etc.], which is directly relevant to issue No. [__]." Or: "On a careful reading of the impugned judgment, it has come to the Applicant's notice that paragraph [__] records [a figure / a date / a finding] which is contrary to the record, in that [explain the error precisely]."]
### 2. Grounds of review
The Applicant seeks review of the impugned judgment on the following grounds, each of which falls within Order XLVII Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908:
Ground A — Error apparent on the face of the record (Order XLVII Rule 1(a)):
2.1. There is an error apparent on the face of the record in the impugned judgment, in that [state the error with precision — for example: "the judgment records the suit property as measuring 10 marlas, whereas the plaint, the title documents, and the report of the Local Commissioner all record it as 12 marlas"; or "the judgment applies [a statute / provision] which had already been repealed / amended with effect from [date]"; or "the judgment proceeds on the footing that the Applicant did not file a written statement, whereas the written statement dated [DD-MM-YYYY] is on the record at page [__] of the file"].
2.2. The error is not a matter of debatable interpretation or a point on which two views are possible. It is an error that is visible on the face of the record without a long or elaborate process of reasoning, and it goes to the root of the decision, in that [explain how the outcome would be different if the error were corrected — e.g., "if the correct measurement had been taken, the decree for possession would have covered the entire property"; "if the repealed provision had not been applied, the suit could not have been dismissed on that ground"].
2.3. [Add a second instance of error, if any, in the same precise form. Avoid a laundry list of complaints about the reasoning; review is not an appeal, and a ground that merely says "the judgment is wrong" will fail. Every ground must point to something the record itself shows to be wrong.]
Ground B — Discovery of new and important matter or evidence (Order XLVII Rule 1(b)):
2.4. The Applicant has discovered new and important matter / evidence, namely [describe the document or fact precisely: its date, its author, where it was found, and what it proves].
2.5. This matter / evidence was not within the knowledge of the Applicant at the time the impugned judgment was passed, despite the exercise of due diligence, for the following reasons: [explain, step by step, what efforts were made — searches made, offices visited, applications filed — and why the evidence could not have been produced earlier. This explanation is essential. If the evidence could have been found with reasonable effort, this ground will fail. State, for example: "The document was lying in the record room of the [Board of Revenue / Sub-Registrar / bank], and was only traced after an application dated [DD-MM-YYYY]"; or "The witness, [name], was residing abroad and returned to Pakistan on [DD-MM-YYYY], after which his statement was recorded."]
2.6. The newly discovered matter / evidence is important because [explain how it would change the outcome — e.g., "it proves that the respondent's title document is forged"; "it shows that the payment of Rs [________] was in fact made on [DD-MM-YYYY], which is the central fact in issue"].
2.7. [If the new evidence is a document, state whether its original or a certified copy is annexed, and whether the Applicant is ready to prove it in accordance with law. If it is oral evidence, name the witness and summarise what the witness will say.]
Ground C — Any other sufficient reason (Order XLVII Rule 1(c)):
2.8. In the alternative, and without prejudice to the grounds above, there exists other sufficient reason for review of the impugned judgment, namely [state the reason — for example: "the impugned judgment was passed without notice to the Applicant, in violation of the principles of natural justice"; "a subsequent judgment of the [Supreme Court / High Court] dated [DD-MM-YYYY] in [case citation] has laid down the law differently on the very point decided"; "the decree as drawn up does not correspond to the judgment, in that [explain the mismatch]"]. Note: this ground is interpreted narrowly by the courts. It must be a reason analogous to the two grounds above, not merely that the judgment is, in the Applicant's view, incorrect. Do not use this ground as a substitute for an appeal.
2.9. [If applicable: "The impugned judgment suffers from a mistake or error that has resulted in a miscarriage of justice, in that [explain, briefly, the injustice — for example, a decree for a sum already paid, or possession of property already transferred]."]
### 3. Why review, and not appeal or revision?
3.1. The Applicant has been advised that the remedy of review is the appropriate remedy in the present circumstances because [state the reason — e.g., "the error is apparent on the face of the record and does not require re-appreciation of evidence"; "the new evidence could not have been placed before the Court earlier, and an appeal would not permit its reception in the same manner"]. The Applicant understands that review is not a rehearing and is not a substitute for an appeal, and this application is confined to the grounds permitted by Order XLVII Rule 1.
3.2. [If an appeal has also been filed, or the limitation for appeal has expired, state the position honestly: "The Applicant [has / has not] filed an appeal against the impugned judgment. The present application is filed [independently of / in addition to] the appeal, for the reasons stated above." Concealing a pending appeal can damage the application.]
### 4. Limitation and court fee
4.1. This application is filed within the period of limitation prescribed by law. [IMPORTANT — DO NOT WRITE A NUMBER HERE WITHOUT CHECKING. Before filing, verify the current limitation period for a review application from the court registry or the Limitation Act, 1908, as applicable to the forum concerned. The Applicant should note: [check current limitation schedule — confirm from the court registry before filing].]
4.2. The Applicant also seeks condonation of delay, if any, on the grounds set out in the accompanying application under [Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1908 / the relevant provision], which is filed along with this application. [Delete this paragraph if there is no delay.]
4.3. The requisite court fee of Rs [________] has been affixed / paid vide [challan / court fee stamps] annexed herewith.
### 5. No concealment; balance of convenience
5.1. The Applicant states that no material fact has been concealed from this Honourable Court, and that all facts stated in this application are true to the best of the Applicant's knowledge, information, and belief.
5.2. [If execution of the decree is pending or threatened, add: "The Respondent has initiated / is threatening execution proceedings in respect of the impugned decree. If the impugned judgment is not reviewed, the Applicant will suffer irreparable loss, in that [describe — e.g., dispossession from the property, attachment of bank accounts, recovery of a sum already paid]. The Applicant therefore also prays for interim stay of execution pending decision of this application, by a separate application filed herewith." If no execution is pending, delete this paragraph.]
### Prayer
It is, therefore, most respectfully prayed that this Honourable Court may graciously be pleased to:
(a) Admit this application for review and, after notice to the Respondent and hearing the parties, review, recall, and set aside the impugned judgment and decree / order dated [DD-MM-YYYY], and pass such fresh judgment / order as may be just and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case;
(b) In the alternative, modify the impugned judgment / decree to the extent of [state the precise modification sought — e.g., "correcting the measurement of the property from 10 marlas to 12 marlas"; "deleting the finding recorded in paragraph [__]"];
(c) Grant such interim relief as may be just, including stay of execution of the impugned decree pending final decision of this application, if applied for separately;
(d) Award costs of this application to the Applicant; and
(e) Grant any other relief which this Honourable Court may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case.
Applicant
Through Counsel
[Name of Advocate], Advocate High Court / District Courts [Chamber address, phone number, email] [Enrolment No. / Licence No.]
Place: [City] Dated: [DD-MM-YYYY]
Verification
I, [Full name of Applicant], son/daughter/wife of [________], resident of [address], do hereby solemnly verify and declare that the contents of paragraphs [1 to 5] of the accompanying application are true to my personal knowledge, and the contents of paragraphs [__] are true to the best of my information derived from the record, and believed by me to be true. No part of it is false and nothing material has been concealed therefrom.
Verified at [City] on this [__] day of [Month], 20___.
Deponent
Affidavit in support of review application
I, [Full name of Applicant], son/daughter/wife of [________], resident of [address], CNIC No. [________], do hereby solemnly affirm and declare on oath as under:
1. That I am the Applicant in the above-titled review application, and I am fully conversant with the facts of the case.
2. That the contents of the accompanying application are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief, and I have read / understood the same (through my counsel, as the case may be).
3. That the document(s) annexed as Annexure(s) "[A / B / C]" [are true copies of the originals / are the originals] in my possession, and the same have not been tampered with.
4. That [in a case of newly discovered evidence: "the evidence described in paragraph 2.4 above came to my knowledge on [DD-MM-YYYY], and despite due diligence, as explained in paragraph 2.5, it could not have been produced earlier"].
5. That no other review application against the impugned judgment is pending before any court, [except as stated in paragraph 3.2 above].
Deponent
[Signature, name, CNIC]
List of documents annexed
1. Annexure "A" — Certified copy of the impugned judgment and decree / order dated [DD-MM-YYYY], with the endorsement showing the date of receipt. 2. Annexure "B" — [Newly discovered document: describe it, with its date and source]. 3. Annexure "C" — [Copy application and the Court's endorsement / the record showing the date on which the certified copy was obtained]. 4. Annexure "D" — [Any other document relied upon: e.g., the title document, the mutation, the bank statement, the prior order]. 5. Court fee / challan, as applicable. 6. Power of attorney / Wakalatnama in favour of the counsel.
Filing notes (read before you file — not part of the application)
What review is, and what it is not. Review under Order XLVII read with Section 114 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, is a narrow remedy. It is available only on three grounds: (i) discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence, was not within the knowledge of the applicant or could not be produced at the time the decree was passed; (ii) some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record; or (iii) any other sufficient reason. Review is not a rehearing. It is not an opportunity to re-argue points that were already argued and decided, and it is not a substitute for an appeal. An application that merely says "the judgment is wrong" or "the Court misappreciated the evidence" will almost certainly be dismissed. The strongest review applications point to something specific — a figure, a date, a document, a provision — that the record itself shows to be wrong, or to evidence that genuinely could not have been produced earlier.
Error apparent on the face of the record — the test. The courts apply a strict test: the error must be so clear that it is visible without a long process of reasoning. Examples that have succeeded include arithmetical mistakes, applying a repealed law, overlooking a document that is already on the record, and a finding directly contradicted by the record. Examples that usually fail include: "the Court should have believed my witness rather than theirs"; "the Court's interpretation of a contract is debatable"; and "another judge might have decided differently." Before filing, ask yourself this question: can a stranger, reading the judgment and the record together, see the error at once? If the answer requires a long argument, the ground is probably not an "error apparent" and you should consider whether an appeal is the better remedy.
New evidence — due diligence is the whole game. The second ground fails more often on due diligence than on importance. It is not enough that the evidence is new to you, or that it helps your case. You must show that, despite genuine effort, you could not have known about it or produced it earlier. Your application must therefore explain, in concrete detail, what you did: which offices you visited, which applications you filed, when you filed them, and when the evidence actually came to light. Attach proof of those efforts — copies of applications, receipts, correspondence — wherever possible. Vague statements such as "the document was not available earlier" will not do.
"Any other sufficient reason" is narrow. Despite its wide wording, this ground is interpreted by the courts to mean a reason analogous to the first two grounds — something of a similar character, such as a judgment passed without notice, or a subsequent binding decision of a superior court that changes the law on the point. It is not a general licence to ask the Court to reconsider. Use it sparingly, and always plead it in the alternative to the first two grounds, not as your only ground.
Limitation — verify before filing. Review applications are subject to a limitation period, and delay can be fatal. Do not rely on memory or on this template for the number of days. Before filing, confirm the current limitation period from the court registry, from the Limitation Act, 1908, and from any special law applicable to your forum. The correct instruction is: [check current limitation schedule — confirm from the court registry before filing]. If there is any delay, file a separate application for condonation of delay, explaining each day's delay honestly. Courts are more sympathetic to a short, honestly explained delay than to a long, unexplained one.
Court fee and forum. A review application is filed in the same court that passed the judgment — a District Court reviews its own judgment, a High Court reviews its own. Check the current court fee for a review application from the registry, as it may differ from the fee for an appeal. File the application with a certified copy of the impugned judgment, the Wakalatnama, and all annexures, and keep a complete set of copies for service on the respondent.
What to expect after filing. The Court will first consider the application, usually after notice to the other side, and decide whether a case for review is made out. If the application is admitted, the case is reheard to the extent necessary, and a fresh decision is given. If it is dismissed, the original judgment stands. Note that filing a review does not automatically stay execution of the decree. If execution is pending or threatened, file a separate stay application and press for an interim order. Do not assume that the decree is on hold merely because a review is pending.
Frequently asked questions
Can I file both an appeal and a review?
In principle, the remedies are different, and the interaction between them is technical. As a general rule, do not file both without legal advice, because the filing of an appeal can affect the maintainability of a review and vice versa. State your position honestly in the application, as paragraph 3.2 requires, and take advice on which remedy fits your grounds.
How long does a review take?
There is no fixed timeline. It depends on the court's workload, whether notice is issued, and whether evidence needs to be recorded. Ask your counsel for a realistic estimate for your particular court, and do not promise yourself a quick result.
What if the judge who passed the judgment has been transferred?
A review is ordinarily heard by the same judge, but if that is not possible, the successor judge may hear it. This does not affect maintainability, but it is a reason to make your application self-contained and easy to follow — the new judge will be reading the file fresh.
Can new evidence be added at the review stage that I deliberately held back?
No. Evidence that was available but deliberately withheld, or that could have been produced with reasonable diligence, will be rejected. The due-diligence requirement exists precisely to prevent parties from keeping evidence in reserve for a second round.
What happens if my review is dismissed?
The original judgment stands, and you may still have other remedies — such as an appeal or revision, if limitation permits. Take advice immediately on dismissal, because the limitation clock for other remedies may already be running.
Do I need a lawyer for a review application?
You may appear in person, but review is a technical remedy with strict tests, and a poorly drafted application can waste the one chance you have. For most litigants, engaging a lawyer experienced in civil litigation is strongly advisable.
Bottom line
A review application is a scalpel, not a hammer. It works when you can point to a specific, visible error on the record, or to genuinely new evidence that you could not have produced earlier despite real effort. It fails when it is used as a second appeal dressed up in different language. Before filing, test every ground against the strict tests described above, verify the limitation period from the registry, assemble your documents, and be honest about delay and about any pending appeal. A short, precise, well-documented review application stands a far better chance than a long complaint about a judgment you disagree with — and if your real complaint is that the judgment is wrong on the merits, an appeal, filed in time, is usually the remedy you actually need.
Disclaimer: This template is for general information only and is not legal advice. Consult a qualified lawyer before filing.
