What This Application Is For
This is a ready-to-use format for asking a civil court to allow additional evidence after the evidence of a party has closed.
Order XVIII Rule 17-A of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908 allows the court, at any stage of a suit, to permit a party to produce additional evidence if the court considers it necessary for the just decision of the case.
In simple words, the court does not have to refuse new evidence only because the evidence stage is over. It can allow it, but permission is not automatic. The court has discretion, and it will look at the reason for the delay, the importance of the evidence, and the effect on the other party before deciding.
Use this format when a document, witness, or record came to light late, was not in the applicant's possession earlier, or could not be obtained earlier even after reasonable efforts. For example, a certified copy was applied for in time but received late, a record was found after a fresh search, a witness became available after illness or travel, or a document was in the custody of a department or a third person.
Do not use this application to fill a gap left by carelessness, to delay the case, to repeat evidence already led, or to introduce evidence that has no connection with the issues framed in the suit. The application must be honest about why the evidence was not produced before, and it must be filed as soon as the evidence becomes available.
Fill in every placeholder in square brackets before filing. Attach the affidavit given at the end, and attach copies of the documents you want to produce, if any, as annexures.
The Legal Test Under Order XVIII Rule 17-A
The court will allow additional evidence only if the applicant satisfies the court on the following points:
- The evidence is relevant to an issue in the suit. It must help prove or disprove a fact that the court has to decide. Evidence that does not relate to any issue, or that only repeats what is already on record, is not likely to be allowed.
- The evidence could not be produced earlier despite due diligence. The applicant must show what efforts were made, when they were made, and why they did not succeed in time. A general statement that the evidence was not available is not enough. Dates, applications, receipts, letters, and visits should be mentioned.
- The evidence is necessary for a just decision of the case. The court must be satisfied that without this evidence, it may not be able to decide the real dispute fairly and completely. The applicant should explain, in plain words, which issue will remain undecided or wrongly decided if the evidence is refused.
- The application is made in good faith and without undue delay. The court will consider whether the applicant acted promptly once the evidence became available, and whether allowing it will cause unfair delay or prejudice to the other side.
- The other side will have a fair opportunity to respond. If the evidence is allowed, the opposite party should be given a chance to cross-examine any new witness and to lead evidence in rebuttal, if so advised. Stating this in the application shows that no unfair advantage is being sought.
The court has discretion in every case. Even if the evidence is relevant, the court may refuse it if the applicant cannot explain the earlier delay, or if the application appears to be a tactic to prolong the trial. A clear, specific, and truthful application has the best chance of success.
Before You File — Checklist
- Write the correct suit number, year, court, and names of the parties exactly as they appear in the suit.
- Describe the additional evidence precisely. Name each document with its date, or name each witness and state briefly what that witness will prove.
- State the date on which the evidence of the applicant was closed, and the date on which the new evidence became available.
- Attach proof of due diligence, such as a copy of the application for a certified copy, a postal receipt, a departmental letter, or a medical certificate for a witness.
- Number the annexures clearly, for example Annexure A, Annexure B, and refer to them in the application.
- Sign the application and the affidavit, and file them through counsel where required by the court.
Application
In the Court of [District Judge / Civil Judge], [District / City]
Suit No. [Suit Number] of [Year]
[Full Name of Plaintiff], son / daughter / wife of [Father's / Husband's Name], resident of [Complete Address] — Plaintiff
Versus
[Full Name of Defendant], son / daughter / wife of [Father's / Husband's Name], resident of [Complete Address] — Defendant
Application on behalf of the [Plaintiff / Defendant] for leading additional evidence under Order XVIII Rule 17-A, Code of Civil Procedure 1908
Respectfully Sheweth:
1. That the above-titled suit is pending before this Honourable Court and is fixed for [final arguments / judgment / next date of hearing] on [Date].
2. That the applicant is the [Plaintiff / Defendant] in the above suit and has already led [his / her] evidence, which was closed on [Date].
3. That the applicant now seeks permission to produce additional evidence, namely [describe the evidence clearly — for example, the original sale deed dated [Date], the certified copy of the mutation record, the bank statement for the period from [Date] to [Date], or the statement of witness [Name of Witness]].
4. That the said evidence is directly relevant to [Issue No. / the main dispute], because [explain in one or two lines how the evidence proves or disproves the point in issue, for example, it shows the payment made, the ownership of the property, or the date of the transaction].
5. That the said evidence could not be produced earlier despite due diligence, because [give the true reason — for example, the document was in the custody of [Name of Authority / Department], the certified copy was applied for on [Date] and received on [Date], the witness was ill / out of station, or the record was traced only on [Date] after a fresh search].
6. That the applicant made the following efforts to obtain the evidence in time: [list the steps taken, with dates — for example, application filed on [Date], letters written on [Dates], visit to the record office on [Date], and fee deposited on [Date]].
7. That the applicant has not delayed the proceedings deliberately and has no intention to prolong the trial. The evidence is now available and can be produced without causing undue delay.
8. That no prejudice will be caused to the other side if the evidence is allowed, because the opposite party will have a full opportunity to cross-examine the witness and to lead evidence in rebuttal, if so advised.
9. That the additional evidence is necessary for a just decision of the case. Without it, the court may not be able to decide [Issue No. / the main question] on complete material, and the applicant may suffer irreparable loss.
10. That this application is made in good faith, in the interest of justice, and is supported by an affidavit.
Prayer
It is, therefore, most respectfully prayed that this Honourable Court may be pleased to allow the applicant to lead additional evidence as described above under Order XVIII Rule 17-A, Code of Civil Procedure 1908, and to pass any other order that this Honourable Court deems just and proper in the circumstances of the case.
Applicant
[Full Name]
Through Counsel
[Name of Advocate]
[Advocate's Address and Contact Number]
Dated: [Date]
Affidavit in Support
I, [Full Name], son / daughter / wife of [Father's / Husband's Name], resident of [Complete Address], do hereby solemnly affirm and declare as under:
1. That I am the [Plaintiff / Defendant] in the above-titled suit and am fully conversant with the facts of the case.
2. That the contents of the accompanying application are true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief, and nothing has been concealed from this Honourable Court.
3. That the additional evidence described in the application could not be produced earlier despite due diligence for the reasons stated therein, and that I made genuine efforts to obtain it in time.
4. That the evidence is relevant and necessary for a just decision of the case, and that this application is made in good faith.
Deponent
[Full Name]
[CNIC No.]
Verified on [Date] at [Place] that the contents of this affidavit are true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.
[Signature of Deponent]
[Signature and Seal of Oath Commissioner / Attesting Officer]
Dated: [Date]
