Introduction
In November 2026, many people in Pakistan opened TikTok and saw something that looked, at first glance, like an ordinary legal video. A young woman in a lawyer's black coat was speaking confidently about the law, standing near court premises, and appearing alongside well-known personalities. The videos were shared thousands of times, commented on widely, and forwarded in WhatsApp groups.
The problem is that, according to reports, the person in those videos does not exist in the way she appears. The character is identified in reports as "Alishba Noor", and the videos are said to be AI-generated. That means the face, the voice, the background and even the apparent presence at a court may have been created or heavily altered by artificial intelligence, rather than filmed in real life.
This has raised serious questions for ordinary people. If a fake lawyer can go viral, how can you trust legal advice on social media? What happens when a real person's photo is used without permission? And what does a complaint to the National Cyber Crime Investigation Agency (NCCIA) actually do?
This article explains, in plain language, what happened, what the complaint means, which laws could apply, and — most importantly — how you can protect yourself and your family from deepfake legal advice.
What Actually Happened in November 2026
Videos circulated widely in November 2026 on TikTok and other platforms. In the clips, the fictional character identified as "Alishba Noor" is shown wearing a lawyer's black coat, speaking as if she is giving legal advice, and appearing in settings linked to courts and public figures.
For many viewers, the videos looked professional and believable. The coat, the confident tone, the court-like background and the presence of well-known personalities in some clips made the content feel authentic. That is exactly why the videos spread so quickly.
People shared them because they were interesting, because they seemed to explain the law in simple words, and because they appeared to come from someone connected to the legal system. In Pakistan, where many people first learn about their rights from social media rather than from a lawyer's office, a clear and confident video can reach millions of people in a few days.
But reports have raised a very different picture. The character is described as fictional and AI-generated. That does not mean every single frame was made by a computer, but it does mean viewers cannot safely assume that what they saw was a real lawyer, in a real place, saying words she actually said.
It is important to be clear about what is proven and what is not. The complaint discussed below contains allegations only. There is, at this stage, no finding of an offence. The identity of the person or persons behind the videos is unproven, and it would be wrong to name or blame any individual as the creator on the basis of social media rumours alone.
What is certain is that the videos went viral, that they created confusion about who is a real lawyer, and that the matter has now been taken to the NCCIA for investigation.
Who Is "Alishba Noor"?
According to the reports, "Alishba Noor" is the name attached to the character in the videos. She is presented as a lawyer, but she is described as a fictional, AI-generated persona rather than a verifiable, enrolled advocate practising in Pakistan.
This distinction matters a great deal. A real lawyer in Pakistan must be enrolled with a Bar Council, must have a licence to practise, and can be checked on the official roll. A fictional character has no enrolment, no chamber, no court record and no professional accountability.
An AI persona can be created to look young, confident, friendly and trustworthy. It can be made to speak in Urdu, English or Roman Urdu. It can be placed in front of a court building, a library, or next to a famous person, even if that meeting never happened. Modern AI tools can clone a voice, smooth a face, fix eye contact and make lip movements match the words almost perfectly.
That is why viewers found it hard to tell the difference. The videos did not look like the old, obvious fakes with distorted faces and robotic voices. They looked like normal, polished social media content. In many cases, only a careful check — or a warning from someone who knows the technology — reveals that something is wrong.
The danger is not only that a fictional person is pretending to be a lawyer. It is that people may act on the advice. A person facing a family case, a property dispute, a police matter or a bail issue might follow a step shown in a video, miss a deadline, file the wrong application, or pay money to the wrong person, all because the advice sounded correct.
Why These Videos Went Viral So Fast
There are several reasons why this kind of content spreads so quickly in Pakistan.
- The law feels complicated, and people want simple answers. Most people do not read statutes or court judgments. A short video that says "you can do this" or "this is your right" feels helpful, even if it is incomplete or wrong.
- The black coat creates instant trust. In Pakistan, a lawyer's black coat is a powerful symbol. When viewers see it, they often assume the speaker is qualified and authorised, without checking further.
- Court and celebrity imagery adds credibility. Appearing at court premises or alongside well-known personalities makes a video feel important and official, even if the images have been edited or generated.
- TikTok and WhatsApp reward short, emotional clips. The algorithm promotes videos that get likes, comments and shares. A confident claim, a surprising statement about the law, or a dramatic setting is more likely to be promoted than a careful, qualified explanation.
- Many viewers do not check the source. People often forward a video because a friend sent it, not because they have verified the account, the lawyer's name, or the legal point being made.
When those factors come together, a single account can reach a very large audience before anyone has time to ask whether the content is real. By the time a correction appears, the original video may already have been downloaded, re-uploaded and shared in dozens of groups.
The NCCIA Complaint: What Has Been Asked For
A lawyer has submitted a complaint to the NCCIA asking for investigation of the accounts and the people operating them. This was reported on 8 November 2026.
In simple terms, the complaint asks the NCCIA to look into who created and circulated the videos, how the AI-generated persona was made, whether real people's images were used without permission, and whether any law has been broken.
A complaint is not a verdict. It is the start of a process. The person who files it is saying, in effect: "This needs to be investigated by the proper authority." It is then for the NCCIA to examine the material, collect evidence, and decide whether an offence is made out.
This is an important point for readers to understand. On social media, people often treat a complaint as proof that someone is guilty. In law, that is not correct. An allegation must be investigated, the other side must have a chance to respond where the law requires it, and a finding can only be made after proper inquiry and, where needed, a trial.
For that reason, this article does not name any person as the creator of the videos, and readers should also avoid doing so. Sharing an unproven accusation against a named individual can itself create legal trouble, including a defamation claim.
What the complaint does show is that the legal community is taking the issue seriously. Lawyers are concerned not only about misuse of their professional identity, but also about public trust. If people cannot tell a real lawyer from a fake one, confidence in the whole legal system suffers.
What Happens After a Complaint Reaches the NCCIA?
The NCCIA is Pakistan's principal agency for investigating cybercrime. It operates the official online complaint portal for cybercrime reports, where citizens can submit complaints about online fraud, harassment, impersonation, hacking and other internet-related offences.
When a complaint is filed with the NCCIA, the usual process is:
- Receipt and registration: The complaint is received and recorded. The complainant is normally asked to provide links, screenshots, account names and any other material that supports the complaint.
- Initial inquiry: Officers examine whether the material, on its face, suggests a possible offence under the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act, 2016 (PECA 2016) or another law. This is a preliminary check, not a trial.
- Technical investigation: If the matter proceeds, the agency may seek information about the accounts involved, including how they were created, what devices or networks were used, and whether the content was generated by AI tools. This can involve requests to platforms and, where the law allows, to service providers.
- Recording of statements: The complainant and other relevant persons may be asked to give statements and provide original evidence.
- Decision on FIR: If the inquiry shows that an offence appears to have been committed, a First Information Report (FIR) may be registered and a formal investigation begins. If no offence is made out, the matter may be closed with reasons recorded.
- Further action: Where an FIR is registered, the investigation can lead to arrest where the law permits it, collection of digital evidence, and ultimately a challan or report to the court for trial. The court, not the agency, decides guilt or innocence.
The process can take time, especially where accounts are anonymous, where platforms are based outside Pakistan, or where technical evidence is needed to prove who operated an account. That does not mean nothing is happening. Cyber investigations often involve slow, technical work that is not visible to the public.
Members of the public should not expect daily updates, and should not treat a lack of immediate action as proof that the complaint has been ignored. At the same time, the complainant has a right to follow up through the proper channel and to keep a record of the complaint number and any correspondence.
Which Laws Could Apply?
Because the investigation is still at the complaint stage, no one can say today which offence, if any, will ultimately be proved. But it is useful to understand which laws are commonly discussed in cases like this, so that readers understand why a fake lawyer video is not just a social media prank.
PECA 2016 — Impersonation, False Information and Identity Misuse
The Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act, 2016 is the main cybercrime law in Pakistan. It covers a wide range of online conduct, including unauthorised use of identity information, impersonation, transmission of false information, and offences against the dignity and modesty of a person.
If a person creates a fake lawyer's identity and uses it to mislead the public, the question for investigators is whether identity information was used without authorisation, whether false information was knowingly spread, and whether any real person's photo, name or reputation was misused in the process.
PECA also covers cyberstalking, blackmail, and the unauthorised circulation of private images. Those provisions are especially relevant where a real person's image is taken and placed into a fake video without consent.
The exact section that applies depends on the facts found during investigation. For example, using someone else's photo without permission raises a different question from simply creating a wholly fictional character. Making a false claim about the law raises a different question from using a real judge's or lawyer's image to suggest endorsement. Investigators must look at each element separately.
Defamation — If Real People Are Shown
If a video shows a real, identifiable person alongside the fictional lawyer, or suggests that a real person said or did something they did not say or do, defamation may become relevant.
Under Pakistani law, defamation can be both a civil wrong and, in some forms, a criminal matter. The basic idea is simple: a person should not be shown to the public in a false way that harms their reputation.
For example, if a video falsely suggests that a well-known lawyer, judge, politician or other public figure has endorsed the fake lawyer, praised her work, or appeared with her at court, that person could say their reputation has been harmed. Whether a defamation case succeeds depends on what was actually shown, what impression an ordinary viewer would take from it, and whether the publisher can show the statement was true or otherwise protected.
Readers should be careful not to repeat a defamatory claim simply by sharing the video. Forwarding a false video with a comment like "look who is with her" can spread the same harm, even if the person forwarding it did not create the original clip.
Contempt and Misuse of Court Imagery
Courts in Pakistan have the power to protect their dignity and authority. Misusing court premises, court symbols, judicial robes or the image of a court to create a false impression can raise questions of contempt or misuse of official imagery, depending on the facts.
The concern is not that someone filmed outside a court. The concern is whether the imagery was used to mislead the public into believing that a court, a judge, or the legal system itself had approved, appointed or recognised the person in the video.
A fake lawyer standing in front of a court building may seem harmless, but if viewers believe she is authorised by that court, the court itself has an interest in correcting the record. That is one reason why lawyers, bar councils and courts take impersonation seriously — it is not only about one person, it is about public confidence in the justice system.
Fraud and Cheating — If Money Is Involved
In many fake lawyer cases, the risk increases sharply if money is involved. If followers are asked to pay a fee for legal advice, for drafting a document, for filing a case, or for "fast-track" help, and the person receiving the money is not a qualified lawyer, that can raise questions of fraud, cheating and dishonest misappropriation under the Pakistan Penal Code, in addition to any cybercrime offence.
No such payment allegation has been proved in this case at the complaint stage, and readers should not assume it. But as a general rule, anyone who is asked to pay for legal services online should be especially careful. A genuine lawyer will normally have a verifiable enrolment, a real office or chamber, a proper fee structure, and a written record of the work to be done. A social media account alone is not enough.
Why AI Fake Lawyers Are Especially Dangerous
A fake lawyer is not the same as a person giving a wrong opinion about the law. A wrong opinion can be corrected. A fake lawyer creates a whole system of false trust.
- People act on the advice. A person may miss a limitation period, file in the wrong court, or sign a document they do not understand, because a video told them to do so.
- People share personal details. Victims may send CNIC copies, case papers, family details or photos to an account they believe belongs to a lawyer. That information can then be misused for blackmail, fraud or further impersonation.
- Real lawyers are undermined. When a fake account gets more followers than a real advocate, the public may start to trust popularity instead of qualification.
- The courts are misrepresented. Videos filmed or generated to look like court proceedings can create false expectations about how quickly a case will be decided, what a judge will do, or what a stay order means.
- Women and vulnerable people are at greater risk. A friendly, approachable female persona may feel safer to approach, especially for women seeking help in family, harassment or custody matters. That trust can be exploited if the persona is fake.
This is why the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) has issued public guidance on identifying deepfake content and verifying suspicious digital media. The guidance encourages users to pause before trusting or sharing a video that looks too perfect, too dramatic, or too good to be true, and to verify the source before acting on it.
How to Spot AI-Generated Legal Advice
No single trick will catch every deepfake, and AI tools are improving quickly. But there are practical tells that, taken together, should make you stop and check.
- Unnatural hands, teeth and ears: AI still struggles with fine detail. Look for extra fingers, hands that melt into objects, teeth that look too even, or ears that do not match. Pause the video and look closely.
- Voice and lip sync that is slightly off: The voice may sound smooth but the lips may not match the words exactly, especially on difficult sounds. The blinking may be too rare, too regular, or absent.
- Too-perfect skin and lighting: AI faces often have flawless skin, no pores, no shadows, and lighting that never changes even when the person moves. Real video has small imperfections.
- Background that shifts or repeats: Look at the edges of the frame. Books, doors, court signs or people in the background may blur, duplicate or change shape between seconds.
- Claims that are too absolute: Real law is rarely absolute. Be suspicious of phrases like "this always works", "you will win 100%", "no court can refuse this", or "just send this one application and your case is finished." A real lawyer will explain conditions, exceptions and risks.
- No verifiable identity: A real lawyer can be checked. If the account gives no full name that matches a Bar Council roll, no enrolment number, no chamber address, and no way to meet in person, treat the advice with caution.
- No case details or citations you can verify: A genuine legal explanation will usually refer to a specific law, section or court, and will explain that the outcome depends on the facts. A fake video often gives a general slogan without any verifiable reference.
- Pressure to act immediately or pay quickly: Be very careful if the video or the account asks you to pay urgently, to send documents on WhatsApp immediately, or to share a code or OTP. That is a classic fraud pattern.
- Account history that does not add up: Check when the account was created, how many videos it has, whether the style suddenly changed, and whether comments are disabled or only praise is visible. A new account with sudden viral fame deserves extra checking.
- The person appears in impossible places: If the same person appears in different cities, different courts and with different famous people in a short period, and there is no news report or independent record of those appearances, ask how that would be possible.
If two or three of these signs appear together, do not act on the video. Save the link, take a screenshot, and verify the claim from a reliable source before you do anything.
How to Verify a Real Lawyer in Pakistan
You do not need to be a legal expert to do a basic check. These steps take only a few minutes and can save you from a serious mistake.
- Ask for the full name and Bar Council enrolment. Every practising advocate in Pakistan is enrolled with a Provincial Bar Council and the Pakistan Bar Council. Ask for the name as it appears on the enrolment, not just a first name or a social media handle.
- Check the Bar Council roll. You can contact the relevant Bar Council or check its published list. If the name does not appear, or if the person refuses to provide it, do not proceed.
- Look for a real chamber or office. A genuine lawyer will have a place where clients can meet them, even if it is a small chamber. An account that only exists on TikTok or WhatsApp, with no office, should be treated with care.
- Ask for a written fee and scope. Before you pay anything, ask what work will be done, what the fee is, and what documents will be filed. A professional will give you this in writing.
- Do not send original documents or CNIC copies to an unverified account. Share copies only after you have verified the lawyer, and keep a record of what you sent and when.
- Cross-check the legal point. If a video makes a surprising claim, check it against the website of a court, the text of the law, or a second qualified lawyer. Do not rely on one viral clip.
If you are unsure, you can also visit a local District Bar Association, a legal aid clinic, or a trusted lawyer recommended by someone you know personally. A short in-person consultation is far safer than acting on a video alone.
What To Do If Your Photo or Video Is Misused
If you discover that your photo, video or name has been used in an AI-generated legal video without your permission, act quickly but calmly. Do not get into a public argument with the account, and do not share the video further in anger, because that can spread the misuse.
- Preserve the evidence immediately. Take screenshots that show the account name, the video, the date and time, the URL, and the number of views, likes and comments. Use screen recording to capture the video itself, because the account may delete it later. Save the original links.
- Do not delete your own copies. Keep the screenshots and recordings in a safe folder. Do not edit them. They may be needed as evidence.
- Report the content on the platform. Use TikTok's or the relevant platform's reporting tool for impersonation, false information or harassment. Ask for removal and keep a record of the report number.
- Complain to the NCCIA through its official online portal. Provide the links, screenshots, and a clear description of how your image was used and what harm it caused. Keep your complaint number safe.
- Contact the PTA for takedown where appropriate. The PTA can be approached for removal of unlawful online content. Provide the exact URLs and explain the misuse clearly.
- Tell the people who might be affected. If the fake video suggests you endorsed someone or appeared somewhere you did not, tell your family, employer or colleagues briefly and factually, so they are not misled if they see the clip.
- Consult a lawyer before filing a case. A lawyer can advise you whether the facts support a complaint under PECA 2016, a defamation claim, or another remedy, and what evidence you will need. Do not file a false or exaggerated complaint, as that can create its own legal problems.
- Do not pay anyone who offers to "remove" the video for a fee. Many scammers exploit victims a second time by charging for removal. Use the official platform, PTA and NCCIA channels.
If the misuse involves private or intimate images, the matter is even more urgent. Do not wait. Preserve the evidence, report immediately on the platform and to the NCCIA, and seek help from a trusted person or lawyer the same day. The law treats unauthorised circulation of private material very seriously.
What To Do If You Shared or Believed Such a Video
Many people will have shared the "Alishba Noor" videos without knowing they were AI-generated. That does not make you a criminal. But you can help stop the spread.
- Delete your share if you can, or add a correction. If you posted the video, remove it or add a clear note that the person appears to be an AI-generated persona and the matter has been referred to the NCCIA.
- Do not forward it again, even to warn others, without context. If you must warn someone, send a screenshot of a reliable news report or this kind of explanation, not the original misleading video.
- Check whether you acted on the advice. If you filed a document, paid money, or missed a step because of a video, speak to a real lawyer urgently and explain what happened. A lawyer can tell you whether the mistake can be corrected and within what time.
- Change passwords if you shared personal information. If you sent documents, photos or login details to an unverified account, change your passwords, monitor your accounts, and consider reporting the matter to the NCCIA as well.
What Happens Next?
The NCCIA complaint is the beginning, not the end. Investigators will need to identify who operated the accounts, how the content was created, and whether any real person's identity was misused. That work may take weeks or months, especially if technical evidence has to be obtained from platforms.
In the meantime, the public can help by not sharing unverified legal videos, by checking a lawyer's enrolment before acting on advice, and by reporting misuse through the proper channels instead of spreading rumours.
The wider lesson is clear. Artificial intelligence has made it easy to create a convincing lawyer who does not exist. The law has not yet fully caught up with the technology, but the basic principles have not changed: a real lawyer can be verified, a real claim can be checked, and a real court order can be seen and read. If a video cannot pass those simple tests, it should not decide your case, your money, or your future.
Before you trust legal advice online, pause, verify, and ask a real, enrolled advocate. That one habit will protect you far more than any single complaint, however important that complaint may be.
