Imagine this. Someone breaks into your shop at night and steals goods worth several hundred thousand rupees. You go to the police station, give your statement, and the police register an FIR. You walk out holding a copy of that FIR, feeling that justice has begun. But then days pass. Nobody calls you. You hear words you do not understand — investigation, challan, remand, charge, trial — and you begin to wonder: what actually happens now, and how long will it take?

Or imagine the other side. You are named in an FIR. You believe the allegation is false, or exaggerated, or a misunderstanding that could have been settled. The police call you to the station. You do not know what your rights are, what the police can and cannot do, or what will happen if the case goes to court.

This guide explains, in plain language, the full journey of a criminal case in Pakistan after an FIR is registered — from investigation to challan, from charge to trial, and from judgment to appeal. It follows the Code of Criminal Procedure 1898, usually called the CrPC, which is the law that governs how criminal cases move through the police and the courts in Pakistan. It is general legal information, not legal advice for any particular case.

What an FIR Is — and What It Is Not

An FIR is a First Information Report. Under Section 154 of the CrPC, when information is given to the police about a cognizable offence — an offence for which the police can arrest without a warrant, such as theft, robbery, murder, or assault — the police must record it in writing and register an FIR.

The FIR is the starting point of a criminal case. It sets out, in the complainant's words, what happened, when and where it happened, who was involved, and what was taken or damaged. The complainant should read it carefully before signing, because the FIR becomes an important document later. If something in it is wrong — a wrong date, a wrong name, a fact left out — the complainant should ask for it to be corrected at the time, and should keep a free copy.

But an FIR is not proof of guilt. This is one of the most misunderstood points in Pakistani criminal law. An FIR is only an allegation. It says that, according to the complainant, an offence may have been committed. It does not mean the accused person is guilty, and it does not mean a court has decided anything. Every person named in an FIR is presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law, after a proper trial.

An FIR is also not the end of the story. Many people think that once an FIR is registered, the accused will automatically be punished. That is not how the system works. The FIR only triggers the next stage: investigation.

Stage 1: The Investigation

After an FIR is registered, the police investigate the case. This stage is governed mainly by Sections 156 to 173 of the CrPC. The investigating officer — usually called the IO — is responsible for finding out what actually happened.

What the police do during investigation

The investigation can include several steps, depending on the nature of the case:

  • Visiting the place of occurrence. The police visit the scene, look at the surroundings, and prepare a site plan and inspection notes.
  • Recording statements. Under Section 161 of the CrPC, the investigating officer records the statements of the complainant, witnesses, and anyone else who may know something about the case. These statements help the police understand what happened, but they are not the same as evidence given in court under oath.
  • Collecting evidence. This can include documents, CCTV footage, medical reports in injury cases, forensic evidence, recovered property, mobile phone records where lawfully obtained, and anything else relevant to the case.
  • Arrest, where the law allows it. In cognizable cases, the police may arrest an accused person without a warrant. But arrest is not automatic, and it is not punishment. The police must have a reason for the arrest, and the arrested person has rights — including the right to know why they have been arrested, the right to consult a lawyer, and the right to be produced before a magistrate within the time the law requires.
  • Seeking remand. When the police need more time to complete the investigation while the accused is in custody, they ask a magistrate for remand under Section 167 of the CrPC. This is an important safeguard. The police cannot keep a person in their own custody indefinitely. The magistrate decides whether remand is justified, for how long, and whether the accused should be sent to police custody or to judicial custody in jail. Police custody is limited, and the magistrate controls it. The magistrate can also refuse remand and order the accused to be released or sent to judicial custody.
  • Recording statements and confessions before a magistrate. Under Section 164 of the CrPC, a statement or confession can be recorded before a magistrate. This is different from a statement recorded by the police under Section 161. A statement under Section 164 is recorded by a judicial officer, after the magistrate is satisfied that the person is speaking voluntarily. A confession made to a police officer, by contrast, is generally not admissible as evidence against the accused — a rule that exists to prevent forced confessions.

What the complainant can and cannot do

The complainant is not in charge of the investigation. The police are. But the complainant has an important role. The complainant should cooperate with the investigating officer, provide documents and evidence, identify witnesses, and keep the police informed of any new information. The complainant should also keep a record of every visit to the police station, every application given, and every order passed.

What the complainant cannot do is direct the investigation, demand an arrest, or insist that the police reach a particular conclusion. The police must investigate fairly, which includes looking at evidence that may favour the accused as well as evidence against them. A one-sided investigation that ignores inconvenient facts is a weak investigation, and it often fails in court.

What the accused can and cannot do

An accused person is not without rights during investigation. The accused can engage a lawyer at an early stage, can apply for pre-arrest bail or bail after arrest where the law allows it, can provide documents and evidence in their defence, and can ask the court to intervene if the investigation is unfair or if the police are harassing them.

What the accused must not do is abscond, tamper with evidence, threaten witnesses, or try to influence the investigation. Absconding — running away or deliberately avoiding the police and the court — makes the situation worse, not better. It can lead to proceedings to declare the person a proclaimed offender, and it damages the accused person's credibility before the court.

Stage 2: The Challan — or the Cancellation Report

When the investigation is complete, the police submit their final report to the magistrate under Section 173 of the CrPC. This report is commonly called the challan. It is one of the most important documents in the case.

What a challan contains

The challan sets out what the investigation found. It typically includes the names of the accused persons, the offences they are said to have committed, a summary of the evidence collected, the statements recorded during investigation, and the documents and material relied upon. The investigating officer states whether, in the police view, there is enough material to send the accused for trial.

Challan versus cancellation report

There are two main outcomes:

  • Challan (case sent for trial). If the police find sufficient material against the accused, they submit a challan and the case moves towards trial. The accused will be summoned or produced before the court, and the court will decide whether to take the case forward.
  • Cancellation report (case found false or unproved). If the police find that the allegation is false, or that there is not enough evidence to support it, they submit a cancellation report. This does not automatically end the matter. The magistrate examines the report, and the complainant is usually given a chance to respond.

If the police submit a cancellation report, the complainant has options. The complainant can file a protest petition, asking the magistrate to disagree with the police and take cognizance of the case anyway. The complainant can also file a private complaint directly before the magistrate, asking the court to proceed on the basis of the complainant's own evidence. These remedies exist precisely because the police do not have the last word — the court does.

The reverse is also true. A challan does not mean the court agrees with the police. The magistrate reads the challan and the material with it, and decides independently whether the case should proceed.

Stage 3: Cognizance and Charge

Once the challan or a complaint is before the court, the magistrate takes cognizance of the offence under Section 190 of the CrPC. Taking cognizance means the court formally takes notice of the case and decides to proceed with it. This is a judicial act, not a rubber stamp.

After cognizance, the accused is summoned to court. If the accused is already in custody, they are produced before the court. Copies of the challan and the documents relied upon are supplied to the accused, so that the accused knows exactly what the case against them is.

Then comes the charge. The court frames a charge — a formal statement of the offence the accused is said to have committed, including the time, place, and nature of the act. The charge is read out and explained to the accused, who is asked how they plead: guilty or not guilty.

  • If the accused pleads guilty, the court may record the plea and proceed to conviction and sentence, after satisfying itself that the plea is voluntary and genuine.
  • If the accused pleads not guilty, the case proceeds to trial.

The framing of the charge matters more than most people realise. The accused can only be tried and convicted for the offences set out in the charge, and the charge defines what the prosecution must prove. If the charge is defective or vague, the accused person's lawyer can raise that before the court.

Stage 4: The Trial

The trial is where the case is actually decided. The prosecution — the State, usually represented by a prosecutor — must prove its case. The accused does not have to prove their innocence. The standard of proof in a criminal trial is high: the prosecution must prove the case beyond reasonable doubt.

How a trial proceeds

A typical trial follows these steps:

1. Prosecution evidence. The prosecution calls its witnesses — the complainant, eyewitnesses, the investigating officer, medical experts where relevant, and others. Each witness gives evidence on oath, and their statement is recorded by the court.

2. Cross-examination. After each prosecution witness gives evidence, the accused person's lawyer has the right to cross-examine them — to test their account, point out contradictions, and challenge their reliability. Cross-examination is one of the most important safeguards in a trial. A witness whose account does not survive cross-examination may not be believed by the court.

3. The accused's statement. Under Section 342 of the CrPC, after the prosecution evidence is complete, the court examines the accused and puts the evidence to them, giving them a chance to explain it. The accused may choose to answer or remain silent. Remaining silent is not evidence of guilt.

4. Defence evidence. The accused may produce their own evidence — witnesses, documents, or other material — to support their defence. This is optional, not compulsory.

5. Final arguments. Both sides make their final arguments, summarising the evidence and explaining why the court should decide in their favour.

6. Judgment. The court delivers its judgment, giving reasons for its decision.

Magistrate's court or sessions court?

Not all trials are the same. Less serious offences are tried by a magistrate, while more serious offences — such as murder, robbery, and other grave offences — are tried by a sessions court. The court that tries the case depends on the offence charged and the law that applies. Sessions trials tend to be more formal and can take longer, because the offences involved are more serious and the evidence is often more complex.

Discharge and acquittal during trial

A trial does not always run to its full length. In some situations, the court can bring it to an end earlier. Under Section 249-A of the CrPC, a magistrate can acquit an accused person at any stage if the charge appears groundless and there is no probability of conviction. Similarly, under Section 265-K of the CrPC, a sessions judge can acquit an accused person at any stage if there is no probability of the accused being convicted of the offence. These provisions exist to prevent people from being put through a long and pointless trial when the evidence is clearly not enough.

Stage 5: Judgment, Sentence, and What Follows

At the end of the trial, the court delivers its judgment. There are two possible outcomes:

  • Acquittal. The court finds that the prosecution has not proved the case beyond reasonable doubt, and the accused is acquitted — set free. An acquittal does not necessarily mean the court found the accused innocent in every sense; it means the evidence was not enough to justify a conviction.
  • Conviction and sentence. The court finds the accused guilty and imposes a sentence. The sentence depends on the offence and the law that applies — it may be imprisonment, a fine, or both.

Appeal and revision

A judgment is not necessarily the end. A person convicted by a trial court generally has the right to appeal to a higher court, asking it to review the judgment and the sentence. The prosecution can also appeal in some circumstances, for example against an acquittal, where the law allows it. In addition, the higher courts have powers of revision, under which they can examine the record of a lower court and correct an error. Strict time limits apply to appeals and revisions, so a person who wishes to challenge a judgment should consult a lawyer promptly and not delay.

Compensation where a case was false

The law also provides a remedy for a person who was wrongly put through a criminal case. Under Section 250 of the CrPC, where a court finds that a complaint or information was false and frivolous or vexatious, it may order the complainant to pay compensation to the accused. This provision is not used in every acquittal — an acquittal alone does not prove that the complaint was false. But it is an important reminder that filing a false FIR is not without consequences.

How Long Do Criminal Cases Take — and Why Do They Get Delayed?

This is the question almost everyone asks, and the honest answer is that criminal cases in Pakistan often take a long time — sometimes months, sometimes years. The law sets out a clear sequence of stages, but in practice the timeline depends on many factors.

Common reasons for delay include a large number of cases before the same court, witnesses who do not appear on the date fixed, frequent adjournments, transfers of judges or investigating officers, lawyers seeking time to prepare, and the sheer volume of evidence in complex cases. Sometimes the delay is caused by one side deliberately; sometimes it is caused by the system itself.

What matters for both the complainant and the accused is to stay engaged with the case. Missing dates, failing to produce witnesses, and leaving the matter entirely to others are all ways in which a case slows down or goes wrong. A case that is followed up regularly — with the lawyer, the court staff, and the record — moves more reliably than one that is left unattended.

What to Do If the Police Do Not Investigate Properly

A common complaint in Pakistan is that the police registered the FIR but then did nothing — no investigation, no arrests, no challan, or an investigation that seems one-sided. If that happens, the complainant is not helpless.

  • Approach the Justice of Peace. Under Sections 22-A and 22-B of the CrPC, a Justice of Peace — usually a sessions judge acting in that capacity — can direct the police to register an FIR or to investigate a case properly. This is one of the most commonly used remedies in Pakistan when the police refuse to act.
  • Approach the High Court. In appropriate cases, the High Court can be approached for directions to the police, or for other relief connected with the investigation.
  • Keep a written record. Every application to the police, every visit, and every order should be in writing and kept on file. A written record is far more useful than a verbal complaint when the matter reaches a court.

For the accused, the corresponding advice is to engage a lawyer early, keep copies of the FIR and every court order, attend every date fixed by the court, and not abscond. Running away from the case does not make it go away. It makes the case harder to defend and harder to settle.

Common Mistakes by Both Sides

Mistakes by complainants

  • Not reading the FIR before signing it. Errors in the FIR create problems throughout the case. Read it, correct it, and keep a copy.
  • Adding exaggerated or untrue facts. An exaggerated FIR is harder to prove and damages the complainant's credibility. State the facts plainly and truthfully.
  • Not preserving evidence. CCTV footage is overwritten, documents are lost, and witnesses forget details. Preserve what you have, and do it early.
  • Disappearing after the FIR. A complainant who does not appear in court, or does not produce witnesses, weakens their own case — and in some situations the case can fail for want of prosecution.

Mistakes by accused persons

  • Ignoring the case. Hoping the case will go away on its own is the most common and most costly mistake. Criminal cases do not disappear; they proceed, with or without the accused.
  • Talking to the police without advice. Anything said to the police can be recorded and used in ways the accused does not expect. Speak to a lawyer before making detailed statements.
  • Threatening witnesses or the complainant. This can lead to separate criminal proceedings and destroys any chance of a sympathetic hearing.
  • Absconding. As noted above, absconding leads to proclaimed-offender proceedings and makes bail and acquittal harder.

Mistakes by both sides

  • Relying on influence instead of evidence. Criminal cases are decided on evidence, not on who knows whom. Influence may affect the pace of a case, but it rarely decides the outcome in court.
  • Not keeping copies. Keep a copy of the FIR, the challan, every court order, every bail order, and every application. Without a file of your own, you cannot follow your case or instruct your lawyer properly.
  • Settling without understanding the law. Some offences are compoundable — they can be settled between the parties with the court's permission — while others are not. Do not assume a private settlement ends a criminal case. Ask a lawyer whether the offence in your case can be compounded, and whether the court's permission is needed.

A Final Word

An FIR is the beginning of a long process, not the end of one. Between the FIR and the verdict lie investigation, challan, charge, trial, and judgment — each with its own rules, its own safeguards, and its own opportunities for things to go right or wrong. Understanding that process does not make a case easy, but it does make it less frightening, and it helps both complainants and accused persons make better decisions at each stage.

If you are a complainant, follow your case, preserve your evidence, and use the remedies the law gives you when the police do not act. If you are an accused person, engage a lawyer early, attend your dates, and do not run from the case. And in either position, remember that the court — not the police station, and not public opinion — decides guilt or innocence.

*This article is general legal information about the criminal process in Pakistan. It is not legal advice for any particular case. The law and court practice can change, and the right step in your situation may depend on the facts. For advice about your own case, consult a qualified lawyer.*